Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Really Rubbish Books

(292 Posts)
FannyCornforth Mon 15-Mar-21 14:14:43

Hello Everyone!
Let's talk about blooming awful books.

As mentioned elsewhere, it's quite difficult to remember them if you give up as soon as you realise that you aren't going to get anywhere with it.

Unlike my dear Grandmother who feels that she has to see them through to the bitter end.
Many is the time she has said to me, 'Thank goodness I've finished that; it was a complete load of rubbish'.

So, what have you wasted time on?
Thank you!

Jane43 Tue 16-Mar-21 09:08:57

Lucca

Jane43

I am a big fan of Kate Atkinson’s books and I recently bought Transcription on Kindle and really struggled to finish it. DH kept saying don’t bother with it but I felt I had to persevere. The only book I’ve given up on was Catch 22 by Joseph Heller.

Agree, I didn’t even finish it.
Also thought Big Sky was disappointing

Yes I thought Big Sky was disappointing too, she should leave Jackson Brodie alone now, the first two were brilliant.

MerylStreep Tue 16-Mar-21 09:11:10

I’m sure there are some here who got to the end of Midnights Children: I wasn’t one of them ?

Urmstongran Tue 16-Mar-21 09:11:53

I spotted ‘Thousand Suns’ on my bookcase the other day MerylStreep and plan to read it again this summer! I read it about 10 years ago on a holiday. I can recall where I was sitting with a glass of red wine in the late evening sun. I couldn’t stop turning the pages and my heart was in my mouth. I wonder how I’ll feel re-reading it? I can’t remember much about it after all this time so that will be interesting. I will report later in the year on your 50 books thread Terribull.

I’m reading Donna Tartt’s ‘Secret History’ at present and not exactly loving it ... my friend raved about it.
?

I really enjoyed ‘Goldfinch’ so I will persevere. If I ditch it, I’ll be back on here later, hehe!

Charleygirl5 Tue 16-Mar-21 09:20:22

The Echo by Minette Walters dor me. How could a 14 year old illiterate boy remember word for word so much an old down and out had told him and work out what had happened?

Would a journalist allow the same 14 year old to share his 2 bedroom flat knowing the same boy could pull the "rape scam" he had done other times? For me it went from bad to worse, I found it difficuklt to follow but read it to the bitter end.

Charleygirl5 Tue 16-Mar-21 09:20:50

difficult!

TerriBull Tue 16-Mar-21 09:21:13

I loved A Thousand Splendid Suns an incredibly moving but traumatic book.

I read Secret History years ago and thought it was very good, but you are like me Urmston in liking The Goldfinch, there seems to be a propensity of people who don't like it.

I'm also reading a book I'm not loving at the moment, "Real Tigers" from the Mick Herron series about spooks. My husband loves these books, usually we agree about crime genre books, but I'm find this quite tedious, I'll keep going but I won't read any more from the series, it doesn't appeal to me that much.

Sara1954 Tue 16-Mar-21 09:48:47

A Thousand Splendid Suns, is an extraordinary book, I had to keep reminding myself that I was reading a contemporary novel, not one set in biblical times.

NotTooOld Tue 16-Mar-21 09:57:40

I thought your remark was quite funny actually, Terribull! I agree with you.

NotTooOld Tue 16-Mar-21 09:58:03

PS Bet they had not read it, either. grin

Urmstongran Tue 16-Mar-21 10:06:07

Those comments about burkas stayed with me, all those years later.

I remember chatting to a Muslim friend about them. She is a GP and wears Western clothes. She said her own father encouraged education and assimilation for his daughters as well as his sons. She said the burka, in her family’s opinion, is all about control.

For instance, I didn’t know that on a burka, the head covering is tight to the scalp. This is so when I woman wants to look at something, she literally has to turn her head to it first to look through the eyeholes. That way, her husband, brother or father knows exactly what she is looking at.

Another senior doctor at the hospital I worked in for many years, told me a different, less liberal way of life, unlike that of my GP friend had enjoyed. This hospital doctor said her own brother, a consultant, did not want a Western bride. With all her exposure to our way of life. He returned to Pakistan for a while and chose a girl from the village in the mountains who spoke no English. He married her and brought her back to England. He wanted a wife well versed in the traditional ways who would bring up any children, having only limited contact in the western ways.

I shall think of these two anecdotal stories next time I read the book.

Sorry for derailing your thread Fanny.
?

FannyCornforth Tue 16-Mar-21 10:39:36

Urms No worries, I genuinely love a derailment! In my opinion, they should happen more often ?

Btw, they can't change the title because it's already gone in the newsletter and it won't work (something like that)

FannyCornforth Tue 16-Mar-21 10:41:22

Really interesting about controlling what women look at. Horrific

FannyCornforth Tue 16-Mar-21 10:46:27

NotTooOld

PS Bet they had not read it, either. grin

I know I'm at great risk of enraging Lucca here - but I really can't imagine Harry reading anything.
But I get most of my knowledge of the Royals from The Windsors, which has got me into trouble on here before!
(Sorry Lucca ?)

JdotJ Tue 16-Mar-21 11:04:47

I read Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy at the start of lockdown. I really enjoyed it so thought, months later I would try another Hardy classic.
Downloaded Tess of the d'Urbervilles and settled down to start another classic but urgh, I couldn't get into it at all, despite trying really hard so I gave up. Unfortunately that has put me off trying any other classic.
Much like Henry IV Part 1 which I had to read at school. Turned my stomach against Shakespeare to this day!

Riggie Tue 16-Mar-21 11:08:21

vampirequeen

I hate Dickens. There I've said it and now I'm going to hide behind the sofa grin. It's not the stories but the way they're written. The only book of his that I finished was Hard Times. I had to read it as part of my degree. I called it Hard Going and forced myself to read a chapter each day until it was over.

I don't like Dickens either!!

dragonfly46 Tue 16-Mar-21 11:08:57

I couldn't get on with Girl, Woman, Other or Catch 22.

I loved A Secret History but I read it when I was much younger so maybe wouldn't now.

I love all Thomas Hardy but not Jane Austen.
I just found Normal People full of teenage angst!

gran5up Tue 16-Mar-21 11:09:55

Nell G, I read Diane Setterfield's " Once Upon a River" and loved it so much I bought (used!) copies for my nearest and dearest. However, like you, "Bellman and Black" was not for me.

Sad when folk say they," don't like Dickens" as they are all so very different." Martin Chuzzlewit" not for me but "Oliver Twist", "Old Curiosity Shop"."Barnaby Rudge" all very gripping-his stuff was mainly written in instalments so there are often real cliff-hangers!

NellG Tue 16-Mar-21 11:13:48

gran5up The Thirteenth Tale and Once upon a River are great, I suspect she was having dreaded second book syndrome and had to deliver another on her contract. Second books are often duffers.

Moggycuddler Tue 16-Mar-21 11:14:48

Can't think of any books I thought were rubbish right now. Oh yes I can - Cloud Atlas. And I hate Jane Austen. I find it hard to understand why some people feel they have to finish books that they're not enjoying. Why??!! You could be spending all those hours of your life reading a different book that you will actually enjoy. I really don't get it! I do stick with books for a short while because some are just a bit slow or maybe confusing at the start and then pick up, but I only allow about 50 pages. Sometimes I've abandoned books after about 10 pages if I just know I won't like it.

Madley Tue 16-Mar-21 11:20:03

As my daughter says, 'Life is too short to read a bad book or drink bad wine'.

Jane43 Tue 16-Mar-21 11:24:29

JdotJ

I read Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy at the start of lockdown. I really enjoyed it so thought, months later I would try another Hardy classic.
Downloaded Tess of the d'Urbervilles and settled down to start another classic but urgh, I couldn't get into it at all, despite trying really hard so I gave up. Unfortunately that has put me off trying any other classic.
Much like Henry IV Part 1 which I had to read at school. Turned my stomach against Shakespeare to this day!

How interesting. I love Tess Of The D’Urbervilles and have read it several times over the years but I really disliked Jude The Obscure, way too dark. My older son studied The Woodlanders for A Level and it is still one of his favourite books.

Amberone Tue 16-Mar-21 11:26:19

Greyduster

I’m another one who adored M.M. Kaye’s “The Far Pavilions”. I followed it up with her “Shadow of the Moon” and didn’t enjoy it half as much. But this has reminded me of how much I loved John Masters’ novels of India. Read them all. Must read then again.

Although I enjoyed them both I prefer 'Shadow of the Moon' to 'Far Pavilions' - and I didn't like what TV did to 'The Far Pavilions' either. I also used to love John Masters' novels, although the only ones I can remember right now are 'Nightrunners of Bengal' and Bhowani Junction'.

Never been able to get on with Donna Tartt, OH reads hers but he seems to be going off them too.

bigbird1 Tue 16-Mar-21 11:26:54

Over I am Pilgrim. Read it twice!!

bigbird1 Tue 16-Mar-21 11:28:11

That was supposed to say loved ,not over

Babs758 Tue 16-Mar-21 11:28:12

Re "Far Pavilions", have you read "Shadow of the Moon" by the same author?