Gransnet forums

Books/book club

Books that defeated you!

(256 Posts)
TerriBull Wed 01-Mar-23 11:45:06

Hot on the heels of Doodledog's uplifting thread, best novels and why?. What book/s have you abandoned or wished you had!

Mine would be, Cloud Atlas, I did finish it but found really heavy going, at the time a few people around me were saying "what a great book" I think it was a very clever concept and although I can be ok with a non linear narrative, I just didn't get on with it at all. Similarly, Lincoln in The Bardo which has won so many literary awards, Booker Prize winner and then the best Booker Prize Winner ever shock and very much loved over on MN, not by me, I think, it was my worst book ever. Other than that Johnathan Strange and Mr Norrell, I gave up 100 pages in, not enjoying it with 600 or more pages to go. The Lovey Bones, I just hated it, thought it was utter shite, I couldn't understand why it had so many accolades heaped on it at the time.

So what did you hate and abandon and what did you finish but wish you hadn't wasted your time on?

Rosie51 Wed 01-Mar-23 23:56:33

MaizieD

Oh, just remembered. Michelle O'Bama's autobiography. So worthy, so dull. I never got as far as her becoming First Lady.

So disappointing because I admire her greatly.

I struggled with the printed version so bit the bullet and went for the audio version read by Michelle Obama and loved it! I'd already had a couple of Barack Obama books on audible read by him and enjoyed them, so thought it worth the punt.

I struggled with "The Goldfinch" which one of my sons bought for me. That was a determined effort to get to the end. A good story that could have stood dramatic shortening! I really don't like to abandon any book I start to read.

Chardy Wed 01-Mar-23 22:16:08

Thursday Murder Club divided our craft group - people either love it or loathe it. I did get to the end, but I had to make myself.
I read War & Peace on holiday decades ago. I finished it, it was a good story.
Can't manage to get past the first few chapters of Far from the Madding Crowd or (1st) Lord of the Rings, though I'vetried each several times and they're also excellent stories. Am trying to get DGD into The Hobbit on Audible to encourage me to try again.

Sara1954 Wed 01-Mar-23 20:19:07

Grumpa
I enjoyed the book, but the only way I could read it was to go and sit at the dining room table.

downtoearth Wed 01-Mar-23 19:54:28

Read The Lovely Bones,whilst arranging a memorial for my daughter who wasnt buried for 11months,I loved the book

Musicgirl Wed 01-Mar-23 19:13:43

Lord of the Rings. My brother read it several times as a teenager and I tried to get into it but little elves don’t do it for me. I am not a fan of fantasy or sci-fi anyway.

grumppa Wed 01-Mar-23 19:06:17

I an fighting a losing battle with The Mirror and the Light: present tense, tedious detail, and impossible weight.

Sara1954 Wed 01-Mar-23 18:55:04

Susie
You made a good choice.
It’s so hard to follow, the story itself could be interesting, it was a good idea, but so much unnecessary nonsense.
In my opinion it was at least twice as long as it needed to be.

NanKate Wed 01-Mar-23 18:47:48

‘Where the Crawdads sing’. I started it twice but it was so slow I gave up. I know I am in the minority.

At school I hated ‘The pilgrim’s Progress’ - dire imo, all that slough of despond stuff. I quietly read Enid Blyton and loved it. No wonder I still love ginger beer.

Susie42 Wed 01-Mar-23 18:18:33

Midnight’s Children by Salman Rushdie, I’ve tried several times and never reached beyond Page 60.

Sara1954 Wed 01-Mar-23 18:12:31

I think I would have missed some very good books if I had abandoned them too quickly, and I would always have that niggle that I may have missed something great.
Not Catch 22 though, I’m prepared to be defeated there.

LRavenscroft Wed 01-Mar-23 18:04:29

dogsmother

Plenty …….. have no interest in books that don’t “ do it for me”
A waste of time, if I’m not enjoying something it’s put down in favour of something else. There are so many books to be enjoyed.

Yes, I totally agree with you. I know within a page if I am going to enjoy a book by the way the author 'talks' to me.

LRavenscroft Wed 01-Mar-23 18:01:30

suninthewest

The Hobbit and Watership Down. Everyone seemed to be talking about them and enjoying them at the time I read them and I couldn't understand the attraction of either. I kept wondering what it was I was missing in both novels and never found out.

I cheated on Watership Down and watched the film. grin

Kate1949 Wed 01-Mar-23 17:58:35

The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists.
The Beekeeper of Aleppo.

Visgir1 Wed 01-Mar-23 17:55:47

Lovely Bones.. Agree rubbish.
Got half way through Lord of the rings.. Got bored
War and Peace only few chapters, life is too short!

Hellogirl1 Wed 01-Mar-23 17:51:27

Aged 14, I borrowed Anna Karenina from the school library. I enjoyed it, so my next one was War and Peace. I gave up after about 3 chapters, but then a few years ago I bought a cheap paperback copy from Amazon to have another go. This time I finished it, but definitely did NOT enjoy it.

Chocolatelovinggran Wed 01-Mar-23 17:46:37

Oh MOnica - so with you on Martin Amis, the old poseur. I did finish The Unconsoled by Kazua Ishiguro, but that's hours of my life I've wasted...

MaizieD Wed 01-Mar-23 17:45:42

Oh, just remembered. Michelle O'Bama's autobiography. So worthy, so dull. I never got as far as her becoming First Lady.

So disappointing because I admire her greatly.

Sara1954 Wed 01-Mar-23 17:39:17

I was listening to the car radio one day, and they were discussing Vera Britains Testament of Youth, just listening was bringing tears to my eyes, so I rushed out and bought it, and obviously it was very worthy, the subject unbearably sad, but I couldn’t get into it, I found it to be very flat and boring, and it took me ages to get through it.
I thought it read more like a text book.

Sara1954 Wed 01-Mar-23 17:15:45

I really enjoyed the Wolf Hall trilogy, but my complaint would be the size and weight of the Mirror and the Light, impossible to read comfortably.

Aldom Wed 01-Mar-23 17:13:47

TerriBull As the parent of a child who died tragically I did not think The Lovely Bones was 'shite' as you so crudely stated. There are hundreds, possibly thousands of bereaved parents out there who have identified with that book. I'm just one of them.

Sara1954 Wed 01-Mar-23 17:12:24

Ekwanimitee
Can’t believe you gave up on The Corrections, have another go, it might surprise you

AGAA4 Wed 01-Mar-23 17:08:31

The Mirror And The Light was heavy going till about two thirds of the way through. I rarely give up on books but now I won't buy any that I feel I am not going to enjoy.
Some of the classics I loved and some bored me but I used to keep on to the end. Not any more.

BridgetPark Wed 01-Mar-23 17:07:20

Absoluting hated Kim by Rudyard Kipling. We had to read it aloud in class, in turn, and it was the most tedious and boring book I have ever had the misfortune to have to read. Totally unsuitable for 13 to 14 year olds. I have always been an avid reader, read very fast, and I, sad to say, was very intolerant of my classmates who did not have the same enthusiasm that some of us did.

Maggiemaybe Wed 01-Mar-23 16:56:50

Oh, I loved The Corrections, EkwaNimitee, and I really enjoyed Wolf Hall and Bring Up The Bodies as well (I found The Mirror And The Light heavy going though).

But what do I know? I’ve enjoyed Richard Osman’s books. grin

Soroptimum Wed 01-Mar-23 16:52:47

Have tried to read Labyrinth by Kate Moses a number of times! Just can’t get going with it.