acommonreader, I like the sound of your recommendation, I like to read this type of book in winter, I haven't heard of it before but will be looking out for it now winter is upon us. Have read Crimson Petal and the White mentioned in your link, also good, and would also recommend The Meaning of Night, The American Boy, Star of the Sea, The Quincunx a Dickensian pastiche. All of these are mysteries set in the 19th century and ideal winter reading in my opinion. However, bought Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell last December as I thought it might also might be in the similar vein as the others I have mentioned, but unfortunately I couldn't get on with it.