Gransnet forums

Chat

bogus posters?

(78 Posts)
Ariadne Thu 21-Jun-12 08:53:05

And, though we are quite good at being suspicious, some of these people are very clever! Thanks, pettallus

Bags Thu 21-Jun-12 08:52:21

i've just read this and my immediate thought is: how is it unethical? OK, such 'researchers' might be finding out what people think/say without identifying themselves as researchers, but so long as they don't use the information they collect in this way in a damaging way, what harm could it do? Are they not just collating information that we are making freely available?

Will now go and think more on this, but that was my initial reaction – why is it unethical?

Seen as listening at the keyhole, perhaps?

petallus Thu 21-Jun-12 08:46:55

My DD visited at the w/e and was quite interested in Gransnet and how I saw it. I said it felt like we were an intimate group of women (and some men) who give each other support, bounce ideas off each other, share jokes etc., in other words like a group of friends. Of course, at the same time we all know Gransnet is open to anyone who wants to have a look. But added to this DD (who is a psychologist) tells me that there is currently quite a bit of concern amongst professional bodies over the way some researchers collect their material over the net. Not only do they trawl websites like ours for opinions and attitudes but sometimes they might even create an identity for themselves and post a question in order to get responses they can use in their research.

This isn't illegal but it is seen as unethical by, for instance, the British Psychological Society.

Don't know if this matters but thought I'd mention it.