Gransnet forums

Chat

Here we go again

(11 Posts)
york46 Tue 29-Jan-13 19:42:55

According to the BBC, Britain is to send in the region of 330 military personnel to Mali in a "non-combat roll" (sound familiar, anyone?). Just when we are within sight of bringing our troops home from Afghanistan, we are committing them elsewhere. How long before mission creep occurs and we are up to our necks in it again? God forbid!

Mishap Tue 29-Jan-13 22:10:39

Yes - mission creep has to be the worry. Oh dear.

Joan Tue 29-Jan-13 22:38:48

On the other hand, destroying evil fundamentalists who impose their evil radical beliefs on an unwilling society, stop women from having any sort of life, destroy ancient libraries and monuments, repress people brutally, has to be a worthwhile duty.

I would like to believe the Government has imposed a time and manpower limit on this mission.

absent Wed 30-Jan-13 07:20:17

Destroying evil fundamentalists will not destroy evil fundamentalism but rather encourage it to breed.

Ylil Wed 30-Jan-13 07:58:43

Why would we send troops to Mali but not Syria where untold horrors are happening? Thousands dead, people reduced to cave dwellings. Doesn't make sense to me.

Riverwalk Wed 30-Jan-13 08:29:12

Ylil the cynic in me wonders if the West really wants the Assad regime to fall; with a secular dictator in power, there's less chance of the country becoming fundamentalist and fragmented, along the lines of Iraq and Egypt.

dorsetpennt Wed 30-Jan-13 09:24:59

The fact that we are keeping out of Syria is all to do with oil - it exports crude oil - not a lot but enough to keep us from meddling. One wonders just how bad it has to get before the West decides to 'interfere' - has Assad said he has WMD's?
As for Mali - it's an old French colony so why are we going in - there is enough of the French Army afterall, its not as if they are anywhere else like Iran or Afghanistan

celebgran Wed 30-Jan-13 10:20:30

is a worry and with the army being cut down so drastically wonder they have troops to send.

god forbid is another huge issue starting up.

Mishap Wed 30-Jan-13 10:56:49

We always go in with a time limited promise and we always find ourselves up to our necks and unable to withdraw; and the results never live up to expectations. Why do we keep doing this?

We all abhor the regimes where all these atrocities and inequalities exist, but we have yet to find a way of solving these problems. We just keep doingt the same things with the same poor results and loss of British lives.

Nelliemoser Wed 30-Jan-13 23:37:40

Riverwalk I am afraid you have probably hit the nail on the head there!

FlicketyB Thu 31-Jan-13 14:15:05

Just remember those British expatriates killed in Algeria two weeks ago. The Islamic extremists responsible for that attack were part of the Islamic movement that occupied the northern half of Mali and provided a refuge for terrorists groups attacking European and British installations in neighbouring countries.

Remember also the reason we went into Afghanistan was because the Taliban were training the terrorists that blew up the World Trade Building in New York. caused the explosions and deaths in London on the tube ad countless other thwarted terrorist attacks.

We no longer live in a world where the greatest threat to our lives and freedom is the country next door. The mass movement of people and arms throughout the world and the growth of fundamentalism means that even countries like Mali that probably many had never heard of and fewer still knew where it is can be a serious threat to our own lives and freedoms.

What is the alternative?