Gransnet forums

Chat

Education

(129 Posts)
enterprisegran Thu 18-Apr-13 21:17:00

With a long career in education and now with two grandchildren to love and worry about, I feel passionately that we all need a say in what is happening to education at the moment. I was inspired to see Debra Kidd talk on Channel 4 about the current proposed changes which will impact on our little ones and their teachers. She has written about it here:
http://debrakidd.wordpress.com/2013/04/17/calling-all-parents/
I hope that some of you will feel strongly enough to add your names to the petition. Don't worry about the box asking for your education title. Just put 'Grandparent' in there.
We all need to be heard so that our children have the chance to be creative, happy and confident.

Greatnan Sat 20-Apr-13 12:58:29

Enterprise, I have read that youth vehicle crime is vastly reduced if they are sent on a car maintenance course instead of being given a custodial sentence.
I organised a child development course for my 'ROSLA' girls, liaising with all the nurseries and infant schools in the district. It was hugely popular and all the schools reported that the girls were polite, mature and helpful.
This did not mean that I was not paying attention to their literacy and numeracy skills as well - it does not have to be an either/or situation.
As most of them would be mothers at a fairly young age, I hoped it would help them to understand their own children better.

Deedaa Sat 20-Apr-13 21:33:16

Galen my daughter is a biochemist and tells me that science is not an exact science grin educated guess work seems to be the polite description of some of her research.

j08 Thu 09-May-13 19:20:28

I know I'm harking back to a slightly old thread, and one where some of us (me) got a bit aerated, but I have just come across this.
If you look at the age groupings along the top, is does seem history is taught chronologically. Seems sensible to me.

And it seems to be taught quite imaginatively.

merlotgran Thu 09-May-13 19:26:32

Seeing as Mr. Men books are aimed at toddlers and small children, might not yrs 6 and 7 be insulted or am I missing a point here?

nanaej Thu 09-May-13 20:04:42

Merlot I think Mr Men books are not aimed at toddlers. To understand the humour and irony of the books needs a level of sophistication that is beyond most 3 yr olds. They happily watch them on TV as a lively moving image but I suspect many don't 'get' the story.

merlotgran Thu 09-May-13 20:21:20

Isn't WW2 supposed to be a rather serious subject?

whenim64 Thu 09-May-13 20:24:03

My nearly 5 year old grandsons have lots of Mr Men and Little Miss books, but they don't quite get the subtle humour yet and the paragraphs are just that bit long for them to be able to keep up with the stories. They have the toys and DVDs, though, and love those.

Sel Thu 09-May-13 22:31:01

I read the original Mr Men books to my children and still have them. They did understand the humour at an early age and loved it. My daughter has a boxed set now and the grandchildren love them too. The original Roger Hargreaves are so much better than the subsequent ones written by family members after his death.

I loved reading them at bedtime as they weren't too long smile

nanaej Thu 09-May-13 22:45:05

I think they are terrible stories and I hated having to read them! So many better books I would prefer to read to children and that children enjoy.

Perhaps your kids were particularly sophisticated or mature sel. In my experience most under 5s really struggle to appreciate them properly.

Sel Thu 09-May-13 22:55:22

I doubt many children, even unsophisticated or immature ones would not enjoy reading Mr. Tickle with me nanaej as readings became very physical and descended into ticking matches.

merlotgran Thu 09-May-13 22:58:39

Somehow Hitler doesn't quite come across as Mr. Tickle. hmm

Sel Thu 09-May-13 23:06:54

merlotgran I'm confused smile I would have said Mr. Men books were for the under 5s. I did try and keep them going beyond as I loved the length of them for reading at bedtime.

merlotgran Thu 09-May-13 23:10:26

Am I the only one who has read Jingle's link?

Ana Thu 09-May-13 23:18:29

I read it, merlot. I think there is some talking at cross-purposes here! confused

Sel Thu 09-May-13 23:20:07

Actually, in my case, you're right, I hadn't. I missed the blue smile What a bizarre idea. Mr Men and Hitler? Hey ho. I'm not a teacher but would have said by the time children can actually understand what Hitler was about relating that back to their pre school days books and Mr Men is patronising.

Ana Thu 09-May-13 23:23:14

I agree - I think the whole idea is bizarre!

merlotgran Thu 09-May-13 23:24:59

That's what I thought, Sel. One of my grandsons is in yr 6 and would be mortified if he was presented with a book portraying Hitler as a Mr. Men character.

Sel Thu 09-May-13 23:33:03

You've got to laugh merlot grin

merlotgran Thu 09-May-13 23:36:38

I am, Sel. You must have thought I was bonkers comparing Mr. Tickle with Hitler. grin

Sel Thu 09-May-13 23:44:38

No, I was puzzled - wondered if I'd made a name for myself grin My fault for not spotting the blue link - I often do, especially if it's just a one word one. Must get to Specsavers.

Mamie Fri 10-May-13 05:57:59

Have to say it seems like a strange and rather inappropriate idea to me. It is for the international GCSE and I read somewhere that it was produced by a teacher in an independent International School abroad.

Lilygran Fri 10-May-13 12:17:51

It's a very effective, traditional strategy to ask a learner to teach someone else what they have just learned. But to choose this medium, the Mr Men vehicle, is so wrong in so many ways! confused

feetlebaum Fri 10-May-13 13:18:37

"heptarchy : a hypothetical confederacy of seven Anglo-Saxon kingdoms of the seventh and eighth centuries"

j08 Fri 10-May-13 13:58:57

Yes feetlebaum - King Arthur days. (sigh!) smile #onceandfutureking

Elegran Fri 10-May-13 14:05:05

With any luck they will tie the King Arthur stories to the solid history to make it real to the younger ones. But I don't see where the Mr Men can be tied in.