Daughters - who'd have them?

I have 2 DD the eldest has twin daughters aged 4. The youngest has no children and has decided she doesn't want any of her own but she is so besotted with her nieces and sees them as her children as well! My daughters are exceptionally close and live near each other and the little girls worship their "Aunty Dani"

Perhaps BABS 1952 , it is because !!!

I do think and I could be wrong , we do as Mothers raise our children as best we can, and love them with our heart and soul .

However , sometimes DILS can get jealous , I enjoy my relationship with my DIL.

At the end of the day she may see , how we raised our sons , made him the man she loves

IMO

My DD lives in NYC with her US husband and my lovely DGD - 5yrs. We have a good relationship despite the distance! They came to the UK to live last year but it didn't work out and they returned to the US after 6 months. I was heartbroken but they must do what's best for them. I would say our relationship is very special . When we visit each other we always have a Mum / daughter day lunch shopping or theatre.

I also have a son who is married with 2 lovely daughters they live 3.5 hours away. My DIL and I have a difficult relationship. I've had counselling to try to make sense of the problems and was told she is jealous of me. If that's the case all I can say is WHY!

Only have one DD I think we have a great relationship, I hope she'd say the same We have shopping days out together. Share the same humour etc.

She has two boys 4 and 16mths. Happily for me they moved back to this area in January, and are now 10mins away by car. I know I'm very fortunate to spend lots of time with DGS and DD I missed her as much as them before they came back.

I have two daughters. The elder lives in Europe and has two sons (6 and 4) and the younger lives 10 minutes away from me. She has a daughter (4) and a son (19mths) and is expecting number 2 son at the end of November. It would have been nice to have had another grandaughter, but she and her husband didn't mind either way.

I'm very close to both daughters and grandchildren. Obviously I don't see the one who lives in Europe as much, but I speak to her at least 2 or 3 times a week. I see the one who lives near me every week and speak every day.

A son is a son , till he gets him a wife .

I suppose basically we are raising them for some-one else .

Although I will say my son is a good chap .

Frank, My sons in law married the headteacher's daughters too!

I have two boys and a DD,all married, we are all close but eldest son is abroad with our two Grandkids! No others yet on the horizon......
DD and I enjoy having occasional days together, shopping, lunching , sometimes a show in London and we keep in touch a lot, boys are great but certainly different!!

I love my two DD"s to bits , as indeed my son.

The eldest is a girl , then I had twins , a boy and girl .

sunflowersuffolk

You said ''I think in adult life you are more likely to have a closer relationship with daughters, and of course, the grand children''.

I am not sure if I would agree there.
When my wife was alive we tended to visit her parents and mine an even number of times.
Mind you probably our relationship was unusual by the fact my mother in law was the headmistress of the school I went to and I met my late wife when we were 11.
Probably our parents almost regarded us as the equivalent to a brother and sister.

Strangely my daughters are daughters in law of their ex teachers.

I warned them what it would be like but they took no notice.

Frank

I have twin daughters (2 sons, too) who live no more than 15 minutes away, and they involve me in their's and their children's lives and routines, invite me on holiday (I don't always say 'yes' and they don't invite me every time) and we have what I think is a great mum/daughter relationship. Both have had problems conceiving, both had IVF, both have twins, and both were fortunate to be successful first time. They've faced tough times that I've felt helpless to be able to assist with, but come through them as strong women and mums, and I really admire them. They are close sisters, and close to their older brothers, who still delight in winding them both up, but are protective towards them, too.

I love them asking, when their children misbehave, 'was I ever like that?' I'm pleased to be able to reply 'oh, no - you were ten times worse!'

I would love to have a daughter. I envy you. I have 2 sons who are miles away (one literally other side of world) Generally but not always of course, I think in adult life you are more likely to have a closer relationship with daughters, and of course, the grand children. I see my freinds going shopping with daughters, spa days, days out with them and grandchildren, be grateful. I love my boys but they are gone now, apart from occasional visits.

In the interests of balance I should maybe mention my DDiL who was a single mum with two small nous when she and DS2 tenet about five years ago. She has a great relationship with her mum so I don't have quite the same interaction with her although she us lovely and a perfect partner for our son.

I have had two other daughters in law - one, I knew was no good and the other turns out to have been worse.

My 2 daughters have 2 daughters each and they are fine.
I just wish my wife had been alive to see our granddaughters.
From the point of view of the wider family I think boys have now gone out of existence.
The family name will certainly be gone in 50 years time.
2 relatives have married men with very uncommon family names and we think it is the end of that name for them.

Frank

I have 3 DDs. No.1 has 2 boys (2,3) and lives 350 miles away;No.2 has 2 boys and 2 girls (9,6,5,1) and lives 12,000 miles away and No.3 has one of each (3,1) and is 400 miles away. As they have grown up, married and had children they get on better with each other. As children they got on in twos and the eldest was always considered the bossy one. Middle one was always the difficult one and the youngest the 'spoilt' one! I am constantly amazed by them and very proud of them all and how they cope in sometimes very difficult circumstances. The youngest needs to work and holds down a very demanding job while coping with 2 very demanding toddlers - no wonder she looks exhausted . I used to worry about them all the time but have learnt to let it go now - too many probs of my own to concentrate on! I just wish we were all nearer to each other. I would have loved to have had a boy, but we had wonderful, happy times and they had an idyllic childhood by the sea with many friends, a loving family and a Dad who adored them so what more could I ask for.

I count myself very lucky that I get on really well with all three DDs (well, mostly - they can all be bossy in their own ways ). Although my mum sometimes helped with my children, we didn't have a very good relationship so I envy, and enjoy, their relationship with each other. I would have loved to have a sister or two when we were having babies etc. I now get on really well with one of my sisters in law but they lived in Canada when the children were small and I didn't know her so well.

My daughters are both a delight to me , they've had it tough over the last 20+ yrs one way and another my eldest has 4 children and my younger daughter 3 beautiful children. They are all growing up and moving out into the World now and my son has just started his journey with a new son.. I'm happy that both girls live within a short walk or drive we spend plenty of time together and they share most of their troubles with me. They are lovely girls. I think I've been where you are kitty but there is light at the end of the tunnel.

I love my DD to bits, I had her after two boys and a 9 year gap, and have a brilliant relationship with her, which I didn't have with my own sadly ,she has always confided in me, never been ashamed to be seen with me,and we have great times together, plus she gave me a delightful DGD two years ago...I just wish she lived a bit closer, although it is only 45 minutes, plus she is a fab hairdresser, so I am always well coiffured

PS I also love my 2 DS and DSS to bits as well

So sorry to hear of your daughter's miscarriage, kitty - so far our only DD to have babies (DD1) has had no trouble conceiving or having her 2, but I can imagine the grief mums go through on their daughters' behalf.
Our other 2 are as yet childless, one (youngest) married last year, but with a recent diagnosis of psoriatic arthritis and (we hope) perhaps the possibility of a drug trial will have to wait a few years before thinking of babies. Middle DD has only in the last 2 years met her ideal man and with careers in the theatre and in art I think babies will have to wait a bit too.
When I was pregnant with DD3, people said they assumed we were hoping for a boy but I can honestly say that I was perfectly happy to have a third daughter. Maybe DH had had hopes of a boy to carry on the family name, but that never mattered to me. With 2 grandsons I have had to learn what goes where at nappy time (!) and I have found that little boys really can be different from little girls!! 2 of our girls live 60 miles south of us in London and the one with the boys lives 75 miles north in Birmingham so we are about midway but I would love to live nearer to all of them - impossible though.

I realise I have got my DDs wrong in my previous post!! DD1 has 2 sons and DD2 has 2 daughters!!

Lordy! I just have 2 x DDs. But both nearby ( within a few minutes drive or a 10-15 minute walk)

DD2 has two sons 5 yrs and almost 14 mths & is a self employed consultant main breadwinner and about to move house (still local). DH is a firefighter out of the house 6:30a.m.-8p.m most days and is on call on his days off

DD1 has two daughters 7 (almost 8) and 4 1/2. She works p/t as a teacher in a nursery school but her OH has his own building firm so works long hours /weekends as he is never sure when next job will be. Holidays are not on the agenda!

My parents helped out when I went back to work p/t after DD1 and did plenty of babysitting too. But I was very lucky to have 4 yrs at home after DD2. Financially tough but we made ends meet! DH worked in the summer holidays (he was a teacher) and did extra after school work so i could be at home. Also my two brothers were around and helped a lot to supplement my child minder arrangements when I returned to work.