D's ex is demanding (threatening court) the re payment of all monies he's given her whilst they were trying for reconciliation. They have agreed now that this will never happen. She took these amounts for petrol and sundries whilst she was at college and living on JSA. She understood at the time that they were a gift not a loan to be repaid. My opinion is he doesn't have a leg to stand on regarding a court case. I've also told him to take it out of the £1500 he owes me for non returned deposits on two properties they rented whilst together. He had no answer to that
What do others think ?
What Would You Do in this Position?