Gransnet forums


Help! - salt in Christmas cake!!

(24 Posts)
Luckygirl Sun 02-Dec-18 22:17:17

I made a large Christmas cake for the whole family the other day with the "help" of my 3 year old GS. He loved it! However, after I had put in the "pinch" of salt stated in the recipe, I turned round to put some utensils in the sink and when I turned back DGS was clearly intrigued by how the salt comes out of the packet.

I thought nothing of it till I was eating the scrapings from the tin after it was cooked - there was a hint of salt in the taste! What to do now? Lots of expensive ingredients in there!

Do I bung lots of brandy in and hope this will mask the taste? Do I simply say it is part of the salt/sweet trend in foods nowadays? Do I give up and start again!!??

MissAdventure Sun 02-Dec-18 22:21:44

You could cover it in a caramel coating of some sort - salted caramel!
Take no notice of me, I'm no cook.
Hope you can salvage it.

Bathsheba Sun 02-Dec-18 22:23:15

Oh heavens, not the kind of "help" you were hoping for 😧. But if there was really only "a hint" of salt, then I would go for the lashings of brandy, which surely will mask it 🙏🤞

Bathsheba Sun 02-Dec-18 22:33:34

I've just read online that acid can help neutralise salt in food. It was really talking about savoury food, if you'd over seasoned it, but I wonder if it might be worth adding some lemon juice along with the brandy?

mumofmadboys Sun 02-Dec-18 22:46:33

Could you take a slither off the cake and try it and see how it tastes?

Jalima1108 Sun 02-Dec-18 22:57:15

A clean knitting needle and brandy.

But don't let him eat the finished cake!

Nelliemoser Sun 02-Dec-18 23:02:29

I use my Dairy cook book for my christmas cake.
About two years ago I put in far to much chocolate powder when it should have been one level teaspoonful it was quite strange in taste but not as bad as salt would be.
This year I hope I was more careful.
Stuff happens.

Nelliemoser Sun 02-Dec-18 23:05:09

Oops..... Trouble is a rich fruit cake has a lot of quite expensive ingredients.

Jalima1108 Sun 02-Dec-18 23:08:57

As Momb suggests, try a sliver. You could level the top off and taste that.

EllanVannin Mon 03-Dec-18 08:04:00

Oh heck. Had it been an ordinary cake it could have been dumped, but------
There's not a lot that can be done really and if it's really noticeable in the cake then that's that. What a shame.
You'll just have to hope that the fruit absorbs it.

Greyduster Mon 03-Dec-18 08:25:11

You might start a new trend! Who knew that salted caramel would become so popular!

Luckygirl Mon 03-Dec-18 09:22:29

Yes - I am hanging on to that idea - I could be on trend!

I think I will cut a small amount off from the edges and see how it tastes. Fingers crossed!

Nannarose Mon 03-Dec-18 10:05:00

No good deed goes unpunished!
I think that a small sliver won't give you the answer - you really need a good mouthful so you can taste all of the ingredients together.
This is what I would do:
If a round cake, cut it into a square- if a square or oblong, easier to take a slice off.
If OK, then definitely feed with brandy, and wrap very tightly.
If it really isn't right, then I would crumble it, mix with enough melted margarine to roll into balls (you can also add some ground almonds to help it all stick together) and make mini Xmas cakes. Decorate with little fondant holly leaves.
I also remember my mother using a stale fruit cake, crumbled, and mixed with diced apple & suet to make 'fake' Xmas pudding!
good luck!

Caledonai14 Mon 03-Dec-18 10:51:21

Great advice from Nannarose and others. I was wondering whether you could take a "core" sample from the side or bottom, using an apple corer?

This is probably no help at all but I once added salt to a soup (senior moment) when I don't normally add salt to anything and a friend suggested adding tatties to the soup because they would take up the salt. It certainly worked! I can't think what similar neutralising agent you could add to a cake - or how you would do it - but I like the idea of the caramel icing. That's such a modern and popular twist. Good luck. wink

grandtanteJE65 Mon 03-Dec-18 11:32:30

You could add lemon juice to the icing when you get that far, as well as adding it and brandy to the cake. If you make your own icing, I would stir it up with lemon juice instead of water, and use tart jelly under the marcipan, crab apple or rowanberry and apple for preference.

If your cake is still too salt, it will go down in family history, as the year GS helped Grannie make the Christmas cake, and as some Roman soldier, stuck in mud to his knees said to his companion, "Perhaps one day this memory will make us laugh" What he actually said was, "Forsan, olim et haec meninisse juvabit!" in case anyone was wondering.

Fennel Mon 03-Dec-18 11:46:46

At least he didn't substitute salt for sugar completely, as I once did when making a sponge cake. I was about 12 at the time, I think.
I agree with those who say try to compensate with a sweet icing, marzipan etc.

sarahellenwhitney Mon 03-Dec-18 11:56:42

mumofmadboys. Agree as this will determine is it ok hmm or should we 'count our losses' and start again

Luckygirl Mon 03-Dec-18 12:16:37

I have the idea to take a small "core" from the centre and use that as a test. I can always fill that with icing later.

Telly Mon 03-Dec-18 15:27:37

Good idea to taste it, better to cut your losses rather than finish a cake with more expensive ingredients that is inedible.

toscalily Mon 03-Dec-18 15:31:50

What you could do is to use a sweet liquor to soak it in instead of the brandy. Would still help it mature with the alcoholic content but would give added sweetness.

SiobhanSharpe Mon 03-Dec-18 18:31:02

Or sweet sherry (cheaper too!). Mix it half and half with the brandy then feed it with the mixture. If you are going to finish it with marzipan and icing you may not notice it at all. Well, you might because you know it's there but your guests might well not -- especially if you give them a generous glass of sherry or Madeira to wash it down with!

Luckygirl Mon 03-Dec-18 18:41:24

DD and I cut the edges off the cake and did a taste test today! You can detect it - it is saltier than one might expect - but will be fine with lots of icing etc. And of course lots of brandy/sherry!

In future I will make sure that the salt is moved back to the cupboard instantly when cooking with DGS! - and thank you for all your useful suggestions.

GabriellaG Tue 04-Dec-18 08:43:29

Rum, whisky, brandy...the lot. Just make sure that nobody is driving after eating it (seriously) blush

aggie Tue 04-Dec-18 09:32:35

Make sure no one with salt problems eats it , personally I would start again . My SIL is having BP problems and salt is banned in their house