I found The Notebook so badly acted by Gena Rowlands, the Director's mother and so ludicrously schmaltzy, that I laughed rather than wept. I only wtched it for James Garner.
There's an Indian version which I think is better. Zindagi Tere Naam
The films which made me cry:
Shadowlands
Watership Down
Brokeback Mountain
Old Yeller (but I was 11 when I saw this)
Goodbye Mr Chips (Robert Donat and then Peter O'Toole)
The Snow Goose
Ring of Bright Water
Even hearing (or even imagining it seems) the theme from Watership Down can make me cry My husband used to sing it to our baby.
Tears now in fact. 