This "quote" thing. ?

JackyB

I find the non sequiturs and incomprehensible posts which arise from people replying to comments way back up the thread more annoying than the use of the "quote" function.

However, I wish people would leave more space after a quote. I can't tell where the quote ends and the bit added by the current poster starts.

I think the spacing is automatic, JackyB

Testing by putting in several spaces between your quote box and my post.


And again.

I find the non sequiturs and incomprehensible posts which arise from people replying to comments way back up the thread more annoying than the use of the "quote" function.

However, I wish people would leave more space after a quote. I can't tell where the quote ends and the bit added by the current poster starts.

Then there's the high risk of losing your own half-written reply as you go back to C&P another sentence
Mama Caz Very annoying when your "work of art" has gone.

My work-around is to compose serious messages in "Word" then "Save' if I have to head off to check out a particular fact. So if things go wrong you've still got the original!
Then highlight, hit CTRL C (copy), then CTRL V (paste) into the GN message box. It's not tedious and beats having to remember what you said in your first go and re-typing.

Hope I'm not "teaching Grandma how to suck eggs!" ?
Good Health.

I typed that out before I rtt, btw, so I may be repeating what someone else has said.
But it had to be done before I forgot what I had to say.

Retires gracefully to the norty step to drink my

you wouldn't repeat someone's comment/remark before responding to it in conversation

I was thinking about this (nothing better to do!) and my thoughts were:

If you were in a group of people having a fast-moving conversation and the conversation had moved off-track slightly, you might well say "*phoenix*, getting back to your point about the quote facility - you said .........." to set the parameters for your reply.

Well, I might, by which time everyone else is talking about something else entirely or start to ???

It's not the quote facility that is the problem. It's the multiple and often unnecessary quotes within a reply, which take up half the page which irritate me.
No-one is asking anyone not to use it, if it puts them off posting, but please just use it wisely.

That's my opinion, I'm not asking anyone to agree, just stating how I feel.
There are more important things to worry about at present.

I am guilty of using the quote facility, I am using my iPhone at the moment and it doesn’t like cut and paste.

Cutting and pasting several separate sentences from posts that are on other pages, plus the poster's name, then adding the necessary formatting, is very time-consuming at best.
Then there's the high risk of losing your own half-written reply as you go back to try to C&P another sentence or double-check something that has been said - well, that's what often happens to me, anyway, but maybe I am just too careless.

I like the quote option for the reasons already given by other posters.

Blame Gransnet for the overly-long quotes. Many other sites have a version that allows you to edit the quote, so you can crop it down to just the parts that you are commenting on.
Gransnet has for some reason opted to give us the most basic, all-or-nothing version!

I think the quote thing works well for short comments. It is not at all effective for longer posts. Far more sensible to highlight the bit you agree/disagree with and then use the italics ^ ........ ^
There is one particular poster who quotes my entire thread everytime as being snobby, patronising, incorrect, blah, blah just because she can. That loses all meaning .

Lollin, it does work on a tablet. I start at the end of the words /phrase I want to quote, drag my finger along to the beginning of the phrase and then a menu pops up, with copy etc. Choose copy, go to where you want to insert the quote and press hard and the menu with paste appears. It takes seconds.

Lollin

I always try to avoid using the quote facility as i know it really upsets some people. However it can mean I end up not joining in as I do not have enough time to refer back to what someone has said or my fingers stumble typing the poster name in bold. To me it can be like pushing the heavy side door instead of alking through the revolving door. Now that's sparked a memory (Oh how I loved those old wooden framed revolving doors!)

You use the quote button, Lollin

It's there for many reasons and if you feel unable to join in, because you might upset people, well that's awful.

I loved the old revolving doors as well

Also, I can't seem to get to but in bold or italics more than one word at a time , it really does not seem to work on my tablet so the idea of being able to use the quote facility was wonderful but I don't or have v v rarely.

I always try to avoid using the quote facility as i know it really upsets some people. However it can mean I end up not joining in as I do not have enough time to refer back to what someone has said or my fingers stumble typing the poster name in bold. To me it can be like pushing the heavy side door instead of alking through the revolving door. Now that's sparked a memory (Oh how I loved those old wooden framed revolving doors!)

But you don't have to read the quote

Just scroll on down

Sodapop, thank you. You have explained it far better than I did about the requoting!

The quote facility is useful when the post referred to is a few pages back. However it seems to be used a lot by some with only a short comment of their own at the end, I agree with Phoenix about that. I don't want to keep reading the same thing over again especially when another poster then 're quotes the quote.

Ah, now I know how it's happening there will be no stopping me.......maybe NOT.

Thanks Merlot, I’ve found the quote thing now.

Spangler, I do appreciate the use of itallics.?

Rufus, it won't be me reporting anyone on this thread, I wouldn't waste my time.? I hope you are in good health.

I agree Lucca.

You scroll down ‘Active’, and it seems to be endless Games, or if not, the same old, same old threads that’s been on for what feels like days.
I sometimes start a new one, not always a brilliant one, but just to see something different.

Not to mention competitive.

Well some may criticise this thread for being repetitive but it knocks spots off the interminable washing cloths one I genuinely could not believe how interesting “some posters” (sorry Suziewoozie) found that .......

I think the ‘quote thing is very useful in general, however the GN version is basic .
On other forums they have quote things that can be edited within the quote before posting . Thus reducing the quote to a few words if wanted and saving space!

I suspect it will eventually be deleted, if the barbs continue
Marydoll Yes please! Delete It!

We already have a similar thread called "Let's see if we can make each other laugh!", it's barb-free!; but desperately short of contributions.
Thank you!
Good Health OoRoo