Gransnet forums

Chat

Manual or automatic?

(57 Posts)
Trisha57 Mon 02-Nov-20 18:51:23

My daughter is in her late 30s with two young children. She does not drive, although she had lessons in her late teens but never bothered to apply for her licence, as we lived in London then and it was easy to use public transport.

Now she has decided that she really needs to drive, both for the convenience (she now lives in a small town with fewer transport links), and it would also improve her prospects at work.

She is thinking that she should have lessons in an automatic car rather than a manual, as she has been told it is much easier. Has anyone here had experience of both, and what would you advise?

Many thanks.

Trisha57 Tue 03-Nov-20 09:43:14

Thanks all - very helpful. I also learnt to drive in a manual car and have never actually driven an automatic, so it was interesting to hear other's experiences.

Aldom Tue 03-Nov-20 09:43:53

Spangler I know a photo of the Riley car existed, but have not seen it in years. The car after it was sold was used in a film. Sorry, I don't know what film!!

henetha Tue 03-Nov-20 10:35:16

I definitely prefer manual and feel more in control. That said, it's whatever you prefer. But you are limited if you only pass automatics.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Tue 03-Nov-20 12:37:54

I've told this story before but here goes.

I learned in a manual in my mid fifties and thought I'd never get the hang of gears and as for getting 'the bite' - I found that very difficult due to my hearing not being A1. I eventually got the hang of it and passed my test at the sixth attempt.

I now drive a semi-automatic which is the best of both worlds. When I see a hill or a bridge coming up I swap to fully auto by pressing a button on the gear lever, go down a gear and Bob's your Uncle. Back on the level I swap back into fully auto. It makes life easier as you have less to think about. I would dread going back to a manual.

Davidhs Tue 03-Nov-20 12:46:21

There is two disadvantages to a small automatic car, if you use it for short journeys fuel consumption will be high and road tax high.
Manual is better

Spangler Tue 03-Nov-20 12:56:21

Aldom Tue 03-Nov-20 09:43:53
Spangler I know a photo of the Riley car existed, but have not seen it in years. The car after it was sold was used in a film. Sorry, I don't know what film!!

There is a picture in my mind's eye of The Riley RME. It is much sought after, a classic to behold.