Gransnet forums

Chat

Which actors do you consider over rated?

(217 Posts)
Oldwoman70 Sun 21-Feb-21 10:27:12

Flicking through channels last night I came across an actor who I think is vastly over rated and I can't understand those who think he is talented. I am talking about Mandy Patinkin. His movements are wooden, he rarely speaks with any inflection and has only one expression - miserable, even when trying to smile!

TerriBull Sun 21-Feb-21 11:54:45

Tabbycat

Mandy Patinkin is the actor who played Saul Berenson in Homeland.

I agree with you about John Wayne, TerriBull, he always looked and sounded like - John Wayne. I particularly remember him playing a Roman soldier at the foot of the Cross in the film The Greatest Story Ever Told. He only had one line:
Truly, this man was the Son of God
and said it with a drawl, no expression - as if he was playing an American cowboy!

Yes I do remember that line Marmight, Oh my God he was awful even with just a few words, he still managed to ruin the whole scene, something about new world accents, not good when playing a character from an ancient civilization. Russell Crow and Joaquin Phoenix manged to do it though.

Just scanning other comments, yep! Hugh Grant, only does posh, couldn't see him playing a geezer say, leave that to Danny Dyer who can be relied on to turn in an excellent impression of himself, strange! him being royal 'an all grin . Although I do think Hugh Grant can be quite good in some roles, he was excellent hamming it up in Paddington 2, almost upstaged the Bear! he's such an irascible sod though, HG that is not Paddington hmm

Sorry GG can't agree about Leo De Caprio I do think he is an excellent actor ever since I saw him playing mentally disabled brother of Jonny Depp in What's Eating Gilbert Grape. Thought he was very very good in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Certainly not one dimensional.

Also don't agree about Olivia Colman or Jude Law, think they can both be very good depending on the role.

Michael Caine, as mentioned up thread, yes I think he's always Michael Caine and don't think he does a very good American accent. Don't dislike him though.

I can't say anything too rude about Keira, she went to my kids school and was a local girl.

Quaver22 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:54:29

Letitia Dean in Eastenders!
I agree about Olivia Coleman especially in The Crown. I thought Claire Foy was wonderful though.

Curlywhirly Sun 21-Feb-21 11:53:22

I was also of the opinion that Hugh Grant wasn't a good actor, as he just appears to play himself in all his films. However, I changed my opinion after watching him play Jeremy Thorpe in a mini-series of his life- he was mesmerising and really captured the essence of the MP, who couldn't be more unlike all the other characters
that Grant's has played.

I also agree that Daisy in Corrie is very wooden and think Kirk is nearly as bad. Neither character is believable.

At the risk of being slated - I never understood Humphrey Bogart's appeal - from the few films I've seen him in he was so wooden and seemed to play the same character in all of them!

Grannybags Sun 21-Feb-21 11:52:10

Ray Winstone is another one who just walks around being himself whatever the character is supposed to be

Grannynannywanny Sun 21-Feb-21 11:46:18

Danny Dyer is top of my list. Having seen him in interviews I’m not convinced he’s even acting in Eastenders.

As for that awful game show he presents and can’t even pronounce the name! The Waww!

GillT57 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:41:58

Frank Skinner was my A level English teacher!
Goodness me! I don't dislike him, I just don't see why he is where he is, very average at everything although undoubtedly quite clever. So, what was he like?

FannyCornforth Sun 21-Feb-21 11:36:47

GillT57

Sean Connery is always Sean Connery. I don't 'get' Frank Skinner either; I know he isn't an actor as such, and I don't dislike him, I just don't get why he is where he is. He is at best, average.

Frank Skinner was my A level English teacher!

Sara1954 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:36:10

Kestrel
He’s one of my favourites, just something about him

Babs758 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:35:53

Daniel Craig!

One person I would have loved to see do more real acting was Kenneth Williams. I heard a radio play he did re someone who descended into madness and it was quite chilling.

Michael Caine gave a television master class on acting once and it was really interesting.

Kestrel Sun 21-Feb-21 11:35:05

Bill Nighy - he only ever seems to play himself in films which isn't really acting. Saying that I think that his was the best performance in 'Love Actually' which was a fairly grim film all round imho.

GillT57 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:34:34

Sean Connery is always Sean Connery. I don't 'get' Frank Skinner either; I know he isn't an actor as such, and I don't dislike him, I just don't get why he is where he is. He is at best, average.

Sara1954 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:34:33

Bluebelle
I really can’t stand any of the builder family, whose name I can’t even remember, and Grace is certainly not a good addition.

Sara1954 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:32:36

Marmight

I agree about Hugh Grant, but what he does, he does so well.

GrannyGravy13 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:31:44

Leonardo DiCaprio just do not get how people think he is handsome and I also do not think he is a particularly good actor.

I have seen him interviewed and he does come over as a really nice person though.

FannyCornforth Sun 21-Feb-21 11:31:10

Nannan2

*him, i mean, not you.

grin

BlueBelle Sun 21-Feb-21 11:30:31

The black builder in Corrie is about as wooden as a pallet Dev s pretty dreadful too Gail not much better
I m another who s no idea who Mandy Patinkin is
I can’t stand Danny Dyer or his daughter

Marmight Sun 21-Feb-21 11:29:37

Brian Blessed
Keira Knightly who is just KK in whatever role she plays
Same with Hugh Grant, but I do rather like him nevertheless!

Nannan2 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:27:21

I suppose he thought mandy would get him more notice, as an actor..But Mandel is unusual too, and sounds more dignified for him.

Nannan2 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:25:23

*him, i mean, not you.

Nannan2 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:24:34

Fanny-why not just say Mandel then, its not much shorter is it??

Nannan2 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:22:50

Danny Dyer used to be better i think, when he started, but when he alighted on Eastenders, he began to change, like he didnt think he had to do much, as he was now 'famous'- but i think all the long- timers on the soaps get like that these days, but that could just be the scriptwriters because they don't know where else to take their characters?- lets hope Danny Dyer's new abuse storyline brings him back down to earth so he can play it with real feeling & compassion to do the story justice?

FannyCornforth Sun 21-Feb-21 11:22:37

Nannan2

Why has Mandy Patinkin got a girls name???

It's short for Mandel.

eazybee Sun 21-Feb-21 11:20:51

Daniel Craig; he is simply one dimensional. I had to look his name up as I couldn't remember him other than as the worst Bond.

Nannan2 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:14:38

Why has Mandy Patinkin got a girls name???

Nannan2 Sun 21-Feb-21 11:12:48

I agree about Daisy in corrie- and add also Gabby in Emmerdale, in fact most of the young females in all the soaps are a bit mundane!