Gransnet forums

Chat

Could you?

(94 Posts)
grannyrebel7 Mon 28-Feb-22 17:01:58

Talking with my DIL on the weekend we were discussing Ukranian citizens being told to make Molotov cocktails to attack the Russians. I said I could never do that as I abhor all forms of violence. She said that she would do it if she were in their position to protect the children. I suppose she had a different slant on it to me not having any little children now. What does everyone else think?

GrauntyHelen Tue 01-Mar-22 22:28:59

I'd make Molotov cocktails quaue up for anAk47 and given the chance shoot Putin right between the eyes and in most things I'm a pacifist Evil must be stopped "if you tolerate this your children will be next !"

ALANaV Tue 01-Mar-22 19:21:43

The citizens of Ukraine are being extremely brave ...they have a very good leader but I doubt sadly that they will be able to stop Putin ....he is a megalomaniac who does not want to be stopped at whatever price. So sad .....he threatens a nuclear war if he is opposed .........very dangerous ...I feel for all ordinary citizens of both Russia (who, I am sure did not want a war) and of Ukraine whom we are unable to assist as they are not members of the EU or of NATO .....IF they were, then the whole of the NATO organisation, including the UK would be obliged to join in . Very very difficult

Pinnywinch Tue 01-Mar-22 18:34:02

If my home and country were at risk, I could be counted on to do almost anything. I would be one of the first to join in.

varian Tue 01-Mar-22 18:00:03

I was so affected by an interview on tv with a nineteen year old Ukrainian girl who was at the border trying to get into the EU.

She said that the rest of her family - Mum, Dad, sister and brother were still in Kiev but they had insisted that she should try to leave Ukraine because "one of our family must survive"

Dolly3010 Tue 01-Mar-22 17:55:49

I had this discussion with husband last weekend, in conclusion when I was a lot younger I would have been in the front line shooting all comers, now I’m a bit more fragile and understand we’re not inviolate I’m more likely to be manning the first aid and fund raising efforts. I would pull a trigger if really needed to protect nearest and dearest.

M0nica Tue 01-Mar-22 17:39:16

Coco51 I think the Russians have air supremacy, which makes bombing the convoys difficult, the Russians will also have them protected by anti-aircraft guns

I understand, that the bridges across the River Dnieper, that cut the country in half have been charged ready to be blown up, but I have not seen confirmation of that.

We are supplying the Ukrainians with hand held heat seeking anti tank weapons, But it is a bit like Brtain deciding to invade the Isle of White, the sheer size and power of the invader, will in evitably overwhelm them in the end.

Coco51 Tue 01-Mar-22 17:31:40

I would do anything to protect my ACs and GCs. With that massive Russian convoy bearing down on Kyiv, I’m wondering why the Ukranians don’t bomb the convoy and destroy road access.

Jess20 Tue 01-Mar-22 17:09:42

Yes, and as I'm old and expendable I'd be a better volunteer to fight than my children who have lifetimes ahead of them.

grandmac Tue 01-Mar-22 16:26:27

Many years ago we were caught up in a revolution in the country we lived in then. We had the revolutionaries setting up a machine gun in our drive {they didn't ask permission!} and when we looked out of the window our very sedate, elderly and inoffensive neighbours were making Molotov cocktails in their garden!! I don't know if they ever used them. But having 2 small children to protect I would have accepted some if they had offered them!

Dee1012 Tue 01-Mar-22 16:07:16

I know without any doubt whatsoever, that I would do whatever I needed to do to protect those I love.

I can't imagine what it would be like and what it would do mentally but I think it would be the reaction of most people.

Blondiescot Tue 01-Mar-22 16:01:13

jaylucy

Bit concerned that it was on the internet for everyone and their aunt to watch and just hope that some dipsticks don't take it upon themselves to make and use them in this country.

You can learn to make a lot worse than a Molotov cocktail from the internet!

katy1950 Tue 01-Mar-22 16:01:09

Yes I would take up arms to protect my family and my country we have freedom in Britain and that shouldn't be given away without a fight

Mummer Tue 01-Mar-22 15:59:36

jaylucy

Bit concerned that it was on the internet for everyone and their aunt to watch and just hope that some dipsticks don't take it upon themselves to make and use them in this country.

Like in Northern Ireland or polltax riots.....we know fine how they work thanks

Mummer Tue 01-Mar-22 15:58:39

Keeper1

Slightly off topic I can't understand why a huge target 40 miles long can't be blown up.

By whom exactly? Ukraine has not the technology of drones as some do, and what then? Creep up and fire? Think about it, these are armed to the teeth soldiers, the Ukrainians are doing fantastic job of defence the best they can with arms available, being simplistic and naïve isn't the best look for us safe over here without a clue now is it?

Mummer Tue 01-Mar-22 15:51:07

I think your talking hypothetically, probably never even had a slap fight with ANYONE and definitely not had to stand your ground with an agressor -ever. You don't know what you'll do until you have to do it!

Blondiescot Tue 01-Mar-22 15:23:33

Let's hope none of us ever find ourselves in that situation! But if it came to it and I was in a situation where I had to protect my family and it was a case of kill or be killed, then you can bet I'd take whatever means necessary to defend them. Isn't it a mother's instinct to protect her children, come what may?

4allweknow Tue 01-Mar-22 15:11:58

Don't know if service in armed forces is obligatory in Russia, can't imagine it not being so. There must be many serving who are against the invasion and who don't want to use violence but other than probably being shot for subversion, not much they can do. Even Russians are fleeing apparently. Yes I would throw a bomb. The situation is just awful.

jaylucy Tue 01-Mar-22 14:34:38

Bit concerned that it was on the internet for everyone and their aunt to watch and just hope that some dipsticks don't take it upon themselves to make and use them in this country.

Sue450 Tue 01-Mar-22 14:01:40

We are not in that dreadful situation but I think I would do exactly the same, let’s hope he doesn’t get to us, you never know.
Evil despot.

Matelda Tue 01-Mar-22 13:52:40

In this country, soldiers are "called up". In Russia, they are "taken". That's what freedom is about.

Baggs Tue 01-Mar-22 13:51:22

My paternal grandma worked in munitions factory during WW1 as did a lot of other young women. She was 22 when WW1 started and had worked as a laundress (skivvy for years of course, not even paid enough to feed herself after she'd paid for her bus fares) since the age of twelve. The munitions factory was an improvement.

Mind you, she was an excellent laundress all her life - all by hand plus starching and ironing.

grannyrebel7 Tue 01-Mar-22 13:50:28

War is always so futile. Death, destruction and lives completely disrupted and for what? It always ends in talks and peace negotiations, so why can't they do that in the first place? I can't believe that history has taught us nothing. So sad to see the slaughter and innocent people's lives destroyed.

Mamma7 Tue 01-Mar-22 13:47:47

Yes I hope I would - I’d like to think hundreds of oldies singing the National anthem and waving sunflowers at the Russian convoy, blocking their way would probably stop them in their tracks - but then again who knows?
Ukraine is dealing with a irrational aggressor so sadly anything could happen .

MissAdventure Tue 01-Mar-22 13:45:27

It's impossible to know, really, unless you find yourself in a situation.
I could shoot someone from a long distance away, I think.

nipsmum Tue 01-Mar-22 13:45:20

I was in tears watching people on the news making petrol bombs. To think anyone has to do that, it must be a last resort. I have no idea what I would do in their situation. I hope I would be brave enough to do the same. That is a desperate situation to have to make your own bombs