Gransnet forums

Chat

Would you lend your car to your daughter.

(132 Posts)
travelsafar Wed 20-Jul-22 15:25:57

My dd rang today to say her car had packed up. I couldn't believe it as about 2 months ago I bought her a new battery and last weekend gave her 100.00 towards a new exhaust as hers fell off!!! Now the garage think her clutch has 'gone'. She has decided to go for another car and needs mine till she finds one. I have doubts about lending my car,she has no drive or allocated parking space, but I know she is stuck. I will have to pay for her to be put on insurance as well as currently it me only on the insurance. She knows I won't be driving for a least 6 weeks due to op next week so I had no 'get out clause' am I doing the right thing.

watermeadow Wed 20-Jul-22 19:18:20

I read that as, “Would you lend CAT”
Yes I’d lend my car. No I wouldn’t lend my cat!

Katyj Wed 20-Jul-22 19:15:17

Yes of course. We always try and help out where we can. We once took my mums car, which me and her shared to my DIL 250 mile away because she was struggling to get our DGS to nursery and her to work on time. Me and mum did lots of walking ?

FlexibleFriend Wed 20-Jul-22 19:05:05

I not only lent mine to my Son I ended up giving it to him. It's not easily replaceable either and he appreciates that. I had my doubts at first but he has lavished love on it, gets it fixed as soon as anything goes wrong etc etc. I have no regrets and just as well because there's no chance of me getting it back now.

Harris27 Wed 20-Jul-22 18:59:32

You asking this means you have doubts. Is she reliable or not? I would probably lend mine to my sons as I couldn’t say no to them or see them stuck.

Sago Wed 20-Jul-22 18:47:49

I did a temporary swap with my son as he needed to keep his mileage down prior to selling as he had a new car on order.
He took my car, valeted and full of fuel, I took his on empty and full of Starbucks cartons.
He drove from London back down to Yorkshire 3 months later and delivered it back with the red fuel light on and 4k extra on the clock, his car had 300 miles extra on the clock and a full tank!

Smileless2012 Wed 20-Jul-22 18:39:54

He's 37 and has been driving since he was 18 Callistemon so I'm thinking our friends woz robbed!!

Hithere Wed 20-Jul-22 18:32:28

Yes, I am in a parallel universe compared to some posters

MawtheMerrier Wed 20-Jul-22 17:53:28

Hithere

Constant need of money is a trigger for addictions, I never said it was what happened in this case.

Are you in a parallel universe?
Poor rates of pay, rising cost of living, extortionate rent, expense of commuting - whether season ticket or fuel - energy bills, would all occur to me long before any suggestion of addictions!

LtEve Wed 20-Jul-22 17:53:00

Both myself and DH are named drivers on my daughters car and I have just put her on mine when we were away as she was looking after our dogs and my boot is bigger than hers. I've now added her permanently. She's been driving for 12 years and never had an accident.
As she doesn't drink she's very useful as the occasional taxi if we go out to dinner as a family.
I cannot imagine not trusting her, I would trust her with my life.

pandapatch Wed 20-Jul-22 17:52:58

Times are hard, we all need a little help from time to time, it's called being a family

Hithere Wed 20-Jul-22 17:50:10

Constant need of money is a trigger for addictions, I never said it was what happened in this case.

GagaJo Wed 20-Jul-22 17:48:46

Not all AC are the same.

I wouldn't lend my car to mine. I've had too much experience of my belongings being treated cavalierly, being damaged and at times, destroyed. Accidentally of course, but nevertheless...

It isn't selfish to expect that if something is loaned, that it is returned in good working order. If there is a suspicion that won't be the case, it is just common sense not to lend it.

Callistemon21 Wed 20-Jul-22 17:36:54

MawtheMerrier

^Could that money to fix it go to addictions, gambling, etc?^

Why on earth has that occurred to you hithere?
It’s not a connection I would make unless you know something about OP the rest of us don’t.

Yes, very strange!

Enabling much?
Yes, I would enable my DC if they were in need.
It's called helping out - with love.

nadateturbe Wed 20-Jul-22 17:34:04

Your daughter should be able to address her transportation needs w/o her parents doing it for her

Strange attitude. Sometimes our children just can't manage everything. It's good being able to help.

Bakingmad0203 Wed 20-Jul-22 17:28:01

Yes, my daughter has just taken out insurance to drive my car whilst she is staying with us for 2 weeks. Hiring a car is so expensive at the moment, and the cost of the insurance is nowhere near the cost of hiring a car, though the compulsory excess is a bit steep. She has agreed to pay for any damage and running costs. She is a confident driver, though I’m still keeping my fingers crossed !

MawtheMerrier Wed 20-Jul-22 17:26:05

Could that money to fix it go to addictions, gambling, etc?

Why on earth has that occurred to you hithere?
It’s not a connection I would make unless you know something about OP the rest of us don’t.

Callistemon21 Wed 20-Jul-22 17:25:06

DD willingly lends us her car when we stay with them.
It's worth a darn sight more than ours!
Although she might not lend us her new one hmm

crazyH Wed 20-Jul-22 17:08:47

That reminds me pandapatch - when I had my old faithful HondaJazz, my granddaughter used to slide down and hide in the footwell so her friends couldn’t see her. ?(When I picked her up school)

MerylStreep Wed 20-Jul-22 17:08:25

We always have a spare car. OH loves cars. We have often lent to friends.
This reminds me of a time about 40 years ago when a work colleague was without a car because of money problems.
He had it for 3 months and on return he gave us 3 premium bonds. We won £1,000 on one of them.

nadateturbe Wed 20-Jul-22 17:08:21

My daughter is on my insurance even though she's rarely here. It's not as expensive as you think. If my daughter needs something and I can give it I do.
When they were very young I might have thought differently.
They are all mature adults. I do everything I can for them.

pandapatch Wed 20-Jul-22 17:02:55

I offered to lend my son my car (old Corsa) and he turned me down! {grin}

notgran Wed 20-Jul-22 17:02:19

Yes I would lend either of my kids my car, any time. Both are very responsible.

Hithere Wed 20-Jul-22 17:00:48

If dd is an adult who works
1. That car is a money pit and worth investing more money on it?
2. Could that money to fix it go to addictions, gambling, etc?
3. Is the car even worth fixing this much vs getting a new one?
4. How is her driving record
5. If you lend her the car, she must pay for insurance

Your daughter should be able to address her transportation needs w/o her parents doing it for her

Enabling much?

crazyH Wed 20-Jul-22 16:59:11

Ofcourse - you’ve got to help her out even if it means paying a little extra to have her as a named driver. You say you won’t be driving for a few weeks, and she will soon be buying another car. So why not just let her borrow your car and if money is the issue, ask her to pay the extra on the insurance.
Btw I have given my car to my children, when they were stuck.

AGAA4 Wed 20-Jul-22 16:56:00

You know your DD best so will know if she is responsible.
I wouldn't hesitate to lend my car to any of my ACs as I know they are good drivers and would look after it.