Gransnet forums

Chat

Milk Tray - what happened?!

(56 Posts)
Kate22 Sat 31-Dec-22 13:10:21

Dear Gransnetters, I was given a large box of Milk Tray at Christmas. I haven’t had one for decades so I was delighted and without parents to tell me not to eat them all at once I tore off the lid and began to eat ( well, gobble my gut be a truer description) but realised by about the sixth that not only did they all taste the same but that gorgeous Cadbury flavour was missing. My adult children helped in my taste test and they all thought the same. I appreciate that like Roses and Quality Street the quality and quantity have changed in order to keep them at a reasonable price point but these really were incredibly bland. Has anyone else found this? Or have we been spoiled by eating chocolate with a much higher percentage of cocoa solids than we had in the past?

Harris27 Sat 31-Dec-22 15:13:49

Always loved milk tray and thought it was just me the chocolate this year in the box tasted old. Less flavoursome and I thought it was my taste buds that had changed. Glad I read this.

Oopsadaisy1 Sat 31-Dec-22 15:15:03

An American recipe now I believe.

We don’t eat Cadburys products any more.

Greyduster Sat 31-Dec-22 15:19:31

An American recipe now I believe. The first time I ate a Hershey Bar I couldn’t believe they thought they could pass it off as anything resembling chocolate!

SiobhanSharpe Sat 31-Dec-22 15:35:36

I may be wrong but i think Cadbury's Flake is still made to the old, pre-takeover recipe. It seems the new greasier formula just won't work with the process needed to make Flake bars well, flaky -- I can certainly believe it. I hope so, anyway. (Flakes are my fave.)

GagaJo Sat 31-Dec-22 15:38:13

Greyduster

^An American recipe now I believe^. The first time I ate a Hershey Bar I couldn’t believe they thought they could pass it off as anything resembling chocolate!

Me too. Vomit chocolate. Disgusting.

Blondiescot Sat 31-Dec-22 15:42:27

Aldi's chocolate is lovely - their Moser Roth varieties are really nice (especially the truffles), but even the cheap bars of dark, milk and white chocolate are good. I had to do some research for you all. I used them to make fudge to give as gifts this year and everyone raved about it.

Katyj Sat 31-Dec-22 15:54:50

We were given a box of milk tray too they were so disappointing, but even worse were the quality street they were truly horrible !

Aveline Sat 31-Dec-22 16:02:44

Oh no! I used to love Milk Tray. They used to make a large bar consisting of a variety of their chocolates. It was a massive treat. Sadly gone.
Another of life's disappointments sad

hulahoop Sat 31-Dec-22 16:20:50

There has been a call back of milk tray something to do with them tasting of chemicals I think.
I got some handmade chocolate bought it's not very good .

Fleurpepper Sat 31-Dec-22 16:37:08

Previous regulations also ensured safety and strict controls on polutants, heavy metals and other possible contamination by chemicals. No such rules now- anything goes for British 'chocolate'

'There is a broad spectrum of legislations that EU food manufacturers have to follow throughout all production processes. The EU has developed standards that ensure food hygiene, animal health and welfare, plant health, and control contamination from external substances.

Safety is maintained even when the production materials come from outside of the EU. Imported goods must meet the same standards and go through the same checks as food produced within the Union.

Wheniwasyourage Sat 31-Dec-22 16:40:37

I like Ritter's Sport - lots of varieties and they all taste good!

Oreo Sat 31-Dec-22 17:58:16

Oopsadaisy1

An American recipe now I believe.

We don’t eat Cadburys products any more.

We don’t either, greasy bland and all taste alike.

M&S are ok and also Beech which is a Lancashire firm I think.

Oreo Sat 31-Dec-22 18:00:19

Fleurpepper Nothing to do with the EU as Cadbury chocs have been sugary and greasy for a long time now when we were in the EU.

Oreo Sat 31-Dec-22 18:01:53

Anyone know what happened to Thorntons toffee? Also all the Thorntons shops?

Daisymae Sat 31-Dec-22 18:05:50

One Christmas as a child I was given a huge box of Milk Tray with a picture of a thatched cottage on the box. I even shared them!

Katyj Sat 31-Dec-22 18:11:57

Wheniwasyourage. If you ever see any yogurt Ritter would you let me know please. I haven’t seen it for years .

Georgesgran Sat 31-Dec-22 19:02:15

Thorntons fell victim to the Covid crisis and closed all 61 of their shops in March 2021, making 600 staff redundant Oreo. Some of their confectionary is still being produced and sold in many
Supermarkets.

No longer a fan of Cadbury’s at all now - greasy or waxy seems an appropriate description.

Fleurpepper Sat 31-Dec-22 19:10:02

Oreo

Fleurpepper Nothing to do with the EU as Cadbury chocs have been sugary and greasy for a long time now when we were in the EU.

Well yes, but it has got much much worse recently- as most above say. The proportion of palm oil has increased hugely.

ayse Sat 31-Dec-22 19:12:36

My daughter discovered Friary chocolates. I can only speak for the dark chocolate but it’s yummy. I prefer it to Hotel C. As for Cadbury chocolate it’s awful. It all changed when it was sold off. I’d rather pay more for less and eat beautiful tasting chocolate.

Happy New Year to all

Hymnbook Sat 31-Dec-22 19:39:47

I had a gift of a small box of Cadbury Milk Tray there were 7 chocolates in the box. Out of the 7 l ate 3 the other 4 were salted caramel and fudge. What a waste of money. Whatever happened to Diary Box? But as you say chocolate is nothing like it used to taste.

sandelf Sat 31-Dec-22 19:51:19

American ersatz recipes - someone else said - they have been taken over by Mondelez, Cadbury is a name only now. The Family as were have no control and it shows. There have been complaints and boxes withdrawn from sale. I'd be tempted to 'give feedback' on their website.

Fernbergien Sat 31-Dec-22 20:24:52

Bought Nestle Dairy Box. Not impressed. Best chocolates to date are the ones in a Tesco box. Inexpensive too.

Oreo Sat 31-Dec-22 20:58:27

Thanks Georgesgran👍🏻

Redrobin51 Sat 31-Dec-22 21:32:48

Not that keen on chocolate apart from those with mint in them but husband js a chocoholic and he has remarked on how the usual suspects don't taste the same. I always buy a box of Lindt for part of his Xmas present and at the moment he is happily tucking in without a word of complaint. I wish they wouldn't mess with the tried and tested formulas of things as they onky lose customers in the long term.

Kate22 Sun 01-Jan-23 17:03:34

Oh thank you so much for all your comments, you’ve reassured me that I’m not losing my sense of taste but isn’t it sad? The taste of Cadbury’s was always so marvellous, wasn’t it?