Gransnet forums

Chat

🎶 You need hands …..or do you?

(19 Posts)
MawtheMerrier Thu 16-Feb-23 22:30:02

Watching the News tonight I was struck by the number of hand gestures accompanying what some of the reporters and interviewees were saying.
Does it enhance or emphasise what you are saying? How much do gestures matter or do they distract?
Young adults seem to rely on gestures more than I remember in the past, at least in English. It used to be a cliché that if you tied a Frenchman’s hands behind his back you rendered him mute!
So are you aware of using your hands or do see it as unnecessary flapping about?
It has certainly made me more aware of my own hands -and resolve to try to keep them by my sides!

VioletSky Thu 16-Feb-23 22:41:04

I'm not usually aware of my own hand gestures but I did accidentally throw a fork full of cake across the room the other day during conversation

Mollygo Thu 16-Feb-23 22:43:48

Talking with children or to friends, your hands help to make a point or demonstrate something. Talking to DH I rarely use my hands.

downtoearth Fri 17-Feb-23 07:26:33

I am a hand talker,I used to be told if my hands where tied I would be rendered speechless.

Iam not French.

My friends laugh at my facial expressions also,apparently I have a naughty twinkle,but can remain straight faced.

Chestnut Fri 17-Feb-23 09:21:36

I do use my hands a bit when talking but I hope not too much. What I find most annoying are women on TV panels with very long nails. There is a woman on Question Time with horribly long nails, often green or blue, and she waves them around in such a showoffy way. You really can't focus on what she's saying because it's all about the nails (or claws I should say). I would love to tie her hands down.

biglouis Fri 17-Feb-23 09:31:53

Im a hand talker and never even think about it.

Many years ago I was speaking to a man I had only just met when he siezed both of mine and said "Dont talk with your hands."

I pulled them free and used my right hand to slap him across the face.

He would not have done that to a man.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 17-Feb-23 09:33:20

I hate seeing talons waved around too. I don’t think I use my hands much when speaking. I find it distracting when people use their hands too much.

Rosie51 Fri 17-Feb-23 09:46:34

I used to be 'hand talker' and got told I'd be speechless without them, and I'm not French either. Not extravagant movements and no talons involved. I trained myself to reduce my hand involvement and don't think I use them noticeably more than most people.

Kalu Fri 17-Feb-23 09:50:48

I don’t mind hand gestures but I find it very annoying and distracting watching news readers and politicians repeatedly use the two hand waving means of communication, up and down, up and down!

I have never fully understood the meaning of French and Italian hand gestures but facial expressions give me an idea of what is being expressed.

Kalu Fri 17-Feb-23 09:51:43

King Charles does it too!

NotSpaghetti Fri 17-Feb-23 10:03:19

I do it.
I love being in Italy where I feel I fit right in grin
My family tease me about it though lots of my gesture smaller than the whole "arm waving" thing - and in my defence, I don't have talons.

Callistemon21 Fri 17-Feb-23 10:21:49

I use hand gestures and so does my DB, perhaps it is our French ancestry! Or it could be a legacy from ancient times when hand gestures formed part of language.

It can be embarrassing, especially if there is a glass of red wine or a coffee in front of you.

I don't have talons 😁

hulahoop Fri 17-Feb-23 10:27:07

My m-in_law was a hand talker my oh used to grab her hands then all she could do was laugh😂

Chestnut Fri 17-Feb-23 10:55:16

Chestnut

I do use my hands a bit when talking but I hope not too much. What I find most annoying are women on TV panels with very long nails. There is a woman on Question Time with horribly long nails, often green or blue, and she waves them around in such a showoffy way. You really can't focus on what she's saying because it's all about the nails (or claws I should say). I would love to tie her hands down.

I've found her! It's Ash Sakar, poster girl for the far left and the most annoying person ever! Here she is seen waving her talons around although I've seen worst when they are green or blue and she waves them quite wildly sometimes.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=VintNfvv0Js

M0nica Fri 17-Feb-23 11:01:26

My family say that the best way to stop me is talking is to tie my hands behind my back.

SusieB50 Fri 17-Feb-23 11:35:25

This reminds me when some years ago we were staying in Italy on holiday. We watched a man talking on his mobile, he was next to a wall and was waving his arms about whilst talking . He realised that his movements were restricted being next to the wall and to our amusement ,he moved into the middle of the square to continue his lively conversation! I use hand and arm movements whilst talking it doesn’t bother me at all .

LadyGracie Fri 17-Feb-23 11:59:43

My DH uses his hands whilst talking, I notice it most when we’re in bed in the dark and he’s wafting the blooming covers about.

Rishi Sunak is also one, he’s always boasting about the size of the fish he’s caught!

GrannySomerset Fri 17-Feb-23 13:27:06

My mother used her hands in conversation and DD, born seven years after her death, uses exactly the same gestures. I don’t, so it must be an inherited trait.

Oreo Fri 17-Feb-23 14:22:13

Chestnut

Chestnut

I do use my hands a bit when talking but I hope not too much. What I find most annoying are women on TV panels with very long nails. There is a woman on Question Time with horribly long nails, often green or blue, and she waves them around in such a showoffy way. You really can't focus on what she's saying because it's all about the nails (or claws I should say). I would love to tie her hands down.

I've found her! It's Ash Sakar, poster girl for the far left and the most annoying person ever! Here she is seen waving her talons around although I've seen worst when they are green or blue and she waves them quite wildly sometimes.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=VintNfvv0Js

Oh yeah, her! Can't stand her, a smug know-all, and yeah her nails are horrible, claws, prob not her own either.

I use my hands in conversation, not too much I hope and after reading this thread may try and reduce this in future.No claws tho.😄