Gransnet forums

Chat

Am I being selfish?

(106 Posts)
Luckygirl3 Tue 16-Jan-24 12:25:39

I can't see why you cannot have a direct cremation, then some sort of remembrance ceremony happen in lieu of a funeral when the ashes are interred or scattered.

Mikky Tue 16-Jan-24 12:25:35

I don't think it's being selfish as you just want to take the pressure from your daughter when the time comes and if that's how you want it then that's your right. I have paid for my funeral because I don't want my family to have that financial burden when the time comes.

Theexwife Tue 16-Jan-24 12:23:24

I prefer a direct cremation and have arranged two when it was up to me to make funeral arrangements.

I do think though that it is up to the friends or family of the deceased to have what they want, they will be there you will not.

It is a good idea to have the conversation though and put money aside if you can.

NotSpaghetti Tue 16-Jan-24 12:17:05

Yes. This may be what you would have liked to do when your mum died.

I would have found it unbelievably difficult if that was what my mum had insisted on! Her funeral was deeply cathartic and healing.

Have you asked your daughter what she thinks would help her when you have died?

Doodle Tue 16-Jan-24 12:16:23

If you were planning this to make things better for her I don’t think that’s selfish. Now she has told you how she feels, if you still want to do things to help her I would discuss other arrangements with her that would please you both.

Gangan2 Tue 16-Jan-24 12:08:14

I have recently broached the subject of my funeral with my daughter ( not that I am planning on 'going' anyway just yet') and I said that I wanted a 'pure cremation' I think its called. One where I am just taken and the job done, nobody present, no flowers etc . My daughter and I are very close and I really, honestly don't want her to stand in a grim crematorium watching what for me at my mother's funeral was the worst day of my life . The atrocious cost of a full funeral is also a factor to me . I said to her that she could remember me in a much more positive way by maybe going for a walk, with her husband, somewhere we both love or something similar. Any monies available to go to a couple of charities we both support.
Well, she was absolutely devastated by the idea and was very cross with me. Am I being selfish 🤔 I honestly want to save her some of the pain of loosing a parent .