Gransnet forums

Chat

Will you watch tonight’s debate on BBC at 7:30pm?

(154 Posts)
Urmstongran Fri 07-Jun-24 16:37:40

I’m going to give it a go but to be honest 7 pundits might be a bit much. Not sure 90 minutes of shouting and getting in digs and sound bites will be in any way particularly informative.

What do you think?

Urmstongran Fri 07-Jun-24 19:06:59

I’m not interested in the smaller parties. They (SNP and Plaid) have their own elections in (?) two years. What they think/say will be irrelevant to me. Same for the Greens they can promise all sorts but will never need to be held accountable. LibDems and Reform neck & neck in overall irrelevance but obviously their parties want a handful of seats in the HoC to hold Starmer’s feet to the fire.

As ‘entertainment’ it won’t be boring. Rayner is feisty. Farage is a great communicator and Mordaunt held her own against Rayner on several occasions during PMQs.

Pass the popcorn…

Casdon Fri 07-Jun-24 19:01:59

M0nica

I do notintend to watch any debating matches on tv, call them what you will.

I have a life, and anytime wasted on listening to politicians, is time I can neve recover.

That’s a strange comment Monica. We’ve all got lives, but those of us who are interested enough in politics to do so make time for these things, whereas your interests lie elsewhere. Both equally valid.

Siope Fri 07-Jun-24 18:59:28

Whereas I, sadly, have a week old hip and too much time on my hands. Besides, I can’t quite think that weighing up the potential government is exactly a waste of my time.

M0nica Fri 07-Jun-24 18:56:58

I do notintend to watch any debating matches on tv, call them what you will.

I have a life, and anytime wasted on listening to politicians, is time I can neve recover.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 07-Jun-24 18:19:15

Yes, I will watch.

maddyone Fri 07-Jun-24 17:56:26

I totally disapprove of Sunak’s behaviour yesterday. I never believed he was PM material, and this simply confirms my view. However I don’t hold his poor judgment against Penny Mordaunt. It was his decision, not hers.

maddyone Fri 07-Jun-24 17:53:41

Thanks for explaining Galaxy.
I thought, but could be wrong, that her brother is trans and that’s why she was/is supportive. I maybe wrong.
I believe her father was in the military, probably navy, as Portsmouth is a naval base.

Casdon Fri 07-Jun-24 17:49:28

I’ll be watching. I just hope Mishal Husain will make a better stab at controlling the debate, and will stop people dominating and talking over each other than happened in the Sky debacle. I want to hear what the smaller parties have to say too (and I don’t mean just Nigel Farage blustering on).

nanaK54 Fri 07-Jun-24 17:42:35

I will watch and live in hope that it might be interesting

Galaxy Fri 07-Jun-24 17:38:06

She tried very hard to push through self ID and recently when the tide has turned pretended she didnt believe that at all. I dont think she cares about either group involved in that debate.
However her constituency has strong military links and she is having to go on a TV debate hours after Sunak messed up DDay. I doubt it's going to be much fun for her.

maddyone Fri 07-Jun-24 17:25:51

Is it because she supports trans rights?

maddyone Fri 07-Jun-24 17:25:04

That’s interesting Galaxy. What is it you don’t like about Penny Mordaunt? I think she comes across as genuine and sincere, unlike some of tonight of them on tonight.

maddyone Fri 07-Jun-24 17:21:48

Yes, I’m planning to watch it. I was surprised to see seven participants though, it might well be too many for proper discussion. We’ll see, I’ll watch and see. There’s always the off switch if it’s boring. I like Penny Mordaunt, she’s from the area she represents, but looks as if might lose her seat. She’s not my MP but represents part of the Portsmouth area and we live about ten miles from her constituency. I believe she’s a good local MP, according to my friend, who is a constituent of PM.

Galaxy Fri 07-Jun-24 17:21:17

It's a funny world. To say I am not a fan of mordaunt is an understatement but I almost almost feel sorry for her.

Urmstongran Fri 07-Jun-24 17:16:12

It is 7 Sparklefizz but I think you’re right in assuming the main focus will be on those three!

Sparklefizz Fri 07-Jun-24 17:14:11

Urmstongran

I’m going to give it a go but to be honest 7 pundits might be a bit much. Not sure 90 minutes of shouting and getting in digs and sound bites will be in any way particularly informative.

What do you think?

Is it 7? I thought it was only 3 - Mordaunt, Rayner and Farage.

Siope Fri 07-Jun-24 17:14:10

I will give it a go. There are a number of intelligent, articulate politicians who, when Ive seen them speak, seem to be on top of their brief, involved: Flynn, Rayner, Cooper & Denyer, in particular.

I hope the format allows for informed debate, and that the moderation is high quality.

Urmstongran Fri 07-Jun-24 17:14:02

Must admit I’m a bit curious so yes, I’ll take a peek.

fancythat Fri 07-Jun-24 17:04:27

Gosh no.

Jaxjacky Fri 07-Jun-24 17:01:22

No, until each party have published their manifesto I’ll bide my time.

welshgirl2017 Fri 07-Jun-24 17:00:59

No thanks.

Sparklefizz Fri 07-Jun-24 16:57:37

I plan to watch it but if it gets too shouty, I shall give up.

Nicenanny3 Fri 07-Jun-24 16:52:54

I'd like to see it but I'm away and Internet flakey, hopefully on YouTube tomorrow. I hope Nigel Farage does dominate and puts the others to shame. God knows how Angela Rayner will cope with the likes of Penny Mordant who is very articulate and also Farage. Will be interesting I think, all depends on what the format is and what questions are asked.

Urmstongran Fri 07-Jun-24 16:43:35

I suppose that’s best Whitewave or we could just read the papers tomorrow. Mind you they put their own spin on things so perhaps better to judge for ourselves, not edited clips on tv tomorrow or articles written by journos with their own agenda.

Sarnia Fri 07-Jun-24 16:41:07

I will give it a try but if it's shouting over everyone and character assassination then I will switch over to something else.