Gransnet forums

Chat

So who will accept the poisoned chalice?

(156 Posts)
Mollygo Fri 05-Jul-24 11:08:26

Sunak will resign as soon as the leadership race begins.
His was a poisoned chalice, and nothing has changed.

MayBee70 Sat 06-Jul-24 14:33:43

I rather hope that any Conservative Party supporters on here who aren’t actually part members will join up and use their vote to enable the party to choose a good, decent leader and not one on the far right of the party. For the sake of British politics.

Iam64 Sat 06-Jul-24 08:28:14

RosiesMaw

maddyone

Smileless2012

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

Keir Starmer has the charisma of a wet lettuce. Mind you, Sunak was much the same.

I don’t think charisma is what we need. That has been the problem, this “presidential” approach to choosing a leader.
Blair had charisma, Macron has charisma, Trudeau has charisma, Boris (love or loathe) had charisma-
what we need is competence, strength, respect, honesty a sense of duty and service

Thanks - this is1 exactly what we need and what Starmer has demonstrated.

keepingquiet Sat 06-Jul-24 08:22:26

Well the Rwanda scheme has already been scrapped and that complete waste of money can be spent on processing the terrible backlog of applications, that will relieve the pressure on the hotels for a start.

Witzend Sat 06-Jul-24 08:10:12

Germanshepherdsmum

I’m not bothered about the economic literacy of those who voted for Reform HPQ as I am not one of them nor do I know any of them. However, Farage will I think be very useful in keeping uncontrolled immigration at the forefront of the issues faced by Labour. It’s not something to be swept under the carpet while they deal with more palatable issues.

Yes. I loathe Farage, and would never vote Reform, but uncontrolled immigration will continue to be a huge issue for many people - as long as we still don’t have anything like enough reasonable, affordable housing for all the people - native and otherwise - already here.

Putting so many new arrivals in hotels costs billions.

fancythat Sat 06-Jul-24 08:01:44

I think the people who should be asked are the disaffected previous tory voters in particular.
But cant see that happening.

I presume tory MPs will move fast as they will all break up soon for their hols and want things in place for the autumn conferences?

Personally I think a leader of a Party should be able to cope with anything.
Doesnt seem to be the case nowadays. Sadly.

Rekarie Sat 06-Jul-24 07:59:46

I thought Sunak grabbed the chalice with both hands, very eagerly.

He wasn't capable of being leader of a political party but clearly thought he was.

No clue who should lead them now. Those being mentioned in the press would surely be the kiss of death.

hoomee29 Sat 06-Jul-24 07:49:29

Yes, Sunak got the poisoned chalice. I felt he was a beacon of decency amongst a rabble of squabbling unprincipled egotists and with Hunt got us out of a catastrophic situation after Truss (and WHY did people think she would be any good??). They have steered a steady course through the shambles the world is in at the moment and get chucked out for it. The Tories have no credibility at all for me. No sooner do they vote a leader in than they are plotting to oust them again. It's worse than football management!
I'm not sure Starmer will last long either, with the loony left still lurking in the sidelines. He couldn't control Diane Abbott and that says it all for me.
Let's see.

David49 Sat 06-Jul-24 07:30:16

The members are important to any political party provide campaigners and of course donations, so they want a say in who is leader. The Tories I know are really quite hard line and still think Johnson should not have been removed, they will support similar candidates that were in the last leadership election, less Mordaunt of course.

To have any chance they need to win back the voters that Reform won, so I really don’t see a moderate leader being chosen.

MayBee70 Fri 05-Jul-24 23:26:30

Casdon

I heard a Tory who had lost his seat earlier (I think it was Robert Buckland) saying he questioned the wisdom of allowing the constituencies to be involved in choosing the leader because they didn’t know the candidates well enough to know who had the right personal qualities to lead, and as you say, are more right wing, which results in poor choices.

Rory Stewart says the same. I’m ashamed to say that I can’t place who Robert Buckland is but it sounds like it is unfortunate that he will no longer be in the party. I wonder if Tugendhat will stand again?

M0nica Fri 05-Jul-24 22:55:52

The problem with both parties is that the leaders are chosen by the party members and these tend to forget that when it comes to elections it is the broader electorate, who do not belong to any party who decide who gets into power or not.

Unfortunately the party members choice and what would be the electorate choice, do not necessarily coincide. The party choosing Jeremy Corbyn, on one side, and Liz Truss on the other, are classic examples of this.

HousePlantQueen Fri 05-Jul-24 20:09:06

keepingquiet

I think the Tory party should heed Robert Buckland's words and treat them with consideration and seriousness.

I thought it was a great speech and if the Tory party don't note what he said they are surely doomed.

I agree.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 05-Jul-24 17:52:54

I’m not bothered about the economic literacy of those who voted for Reform HPQ as I am not one of them nor do I know any of them. However, Farage will I think be very useful in keeping uncontrolled immigration at the forefront of the issues faced by Labour. It’s not something to be swept under the carpet while they deal with more palatable issues.

keepingquiet Fri 05-Jul-24 17:50:14

I think the Tory party should heed Robert Buckland's words and treat them with consideration and seriousness.

I thought it was a great speech and if the Tory party don't note what he said they are surely doomed.

Casdon Fri 05-Jul-24 17:47:29

I heard a Tory who had lost his seat earlier (I think it was Robert Buckland) saying he questioned the wisdom of allowing the constituencies to be involved in choosing the leader because they didn’t know the candidates well enough to know who had the right personal qualities to lead, and as you say, are more right wing, which results in poor choices.

David49 Fri 05-Jul-24 17:43:03

The Tory members out in the constituencies will have a large influence choosing leader, they are known to be pretty right wing. So a caretaker leader then an election after the summer holidays seems likely.

Sunak has gone, I would not expect him to contest another election - why would he, might even resign sooner, leave the UK and pay taxes elsewhere.

HousePlantQueen Fri 05-Jul-24 17:34:58

RosiesMaw

Germanshepherdsmum

There were a lot of votes in favour of Reform. So long as immigration is a problem they will I believe stay the course.

A political philosophy predicated on a negative policy, directed against a minority of the population is all too familiar to those who recognise or have studied National Socialism in Germany in the 20's and 30's.confusedconfused

I won't write on here my full opinion of those who vote Reform, but I will say that economic illiteracy is an essential.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 05-Jul-24 17:27:35

The tories are now completely divided, and I don’t think that they no longer know what they stand for.

Until they get their act together they remsin divided and it is difficult at the moment to see them coming together to form a credible opposition.

Ilovecheese Fri 05-Jul-24 17:13:37

Can't have any more of that nasty clean air!

Dickens Fri 05-Jul-24 17:09:21

MaggsMcG

Sadiq Khan will be the next Prime Minister its obvious.
God help all us car drivers then. We'll be ULEZed out of the market.

Sadiq Khan will be the next Prime Minister its obvious.

Is it?

How so? confused

MaggsMcG Fri 05-Jul-24 16:58:15

Sadiq Khan will be the next Prime Minister its obvious.
God help all us car drivers then. We'll be ULEZed out of the market.

Dickens Fri 05-Jul-24 16:44:18

Allsorts

Id let them worry about that, in due course, they need to reflect and decide what they want Conservatives to be. No rush, get rid of the bad wood in the pile, luckily you
have the government in power you wanted Molly, rejoice in that.
Anyone could be an improvement on Blair lying to take us into a war with so many young men were butchered.

Yes, but I think some of us who are pleased at the Labour win also feel to a degree a tad of sympathy for Sunak.

I do, although others will disagree.

I think he gave a civilised speech during his resignation, took the blame like a gentleman (though I would lay much of it elsewhere), and gave a gracious welcome to Starmer and I, for one anyway, thought he added a touch of gravitas to a party that has been much lacking in that department.

Compared (IMO) to Boris Johnson's resignation speech, it was a masterclass in civility and manners. For all his failings, I believe he is a decent man.

... who, basically, had an impossible job.

Casdon Fri 05-Jul-24 16:22:51

Allsorts

Id let them worry about that, in due course, they need to reflect and decide what they want Conservatives to be. No rush, get rid of the bad wood in the pile, luckily you
have the government in power you wanted Molly, rejoice in that.
Anyone could be an improvement on Blair lying to take us into a war with so many young men were butchered.

They have to have a leader pdq though Allsorts, unless Sunak carries on - otherwise who will lead on challenging the government, as presumably it will be normal parliamentary business from next week? That’s why I wondered if Cameron would step in for the interim.

Allsorts Fri 05-Jul-24 15:37:23

Id let them worry about that, in due course, they need to reflect and decide what they want Conservatives to be. No rush, get rid of the bad wood in the pile, luckily you
have the government in power you wanted Molly, rejoice in that.
Anyone could be an improvement on Blair lying to take us into a war with so many young men were butchered.

Ziplok Fri 05-Jul-24 15:27:50

Many people who voted haven’t forgotten what happened during lockdown, the way certain politicians behaved whilst we did our best to not mix, not party, were kept away from loved ones in order to try to stop the spread of the disease, lost loved ones, etc. Meanwhile, some of them partied, mixed, travelled, lied. The shear hypocrisy of these people left a very bitter taste in the mouths of many decent people, who haven’t forgotten. This, I personally feel, has contributed hugely to the demise of the conservative government - people have had enough. Of course, Covid alone isn’t responsible - so many variables have come along to impact the economy, Brexit, wars, other countries political situations, to name just three more things.

Unfortunately for Mr Sunak, he took the helm of an already dysfunctional and untrusted party, the damage had been done.

Casdon Fri 05-Jul-24 15:25:34

There are no leading candidates yet surely? They are at this stage just those who have previously expressed an interest in the leadership who the media surmise may be interested again.