Gransnet forums

Chat

So who will accept the poisoned chalice?

(155 Posts)
Mollygo Fri 05-Jul-24 11:08:26

Sunak will resign as soon as the leadership race begins.
His was a poisoned chalice, and nothing has changed.

Siope Fri 05-Jul-24 11:12:04

They would be wiser to either persuade him to stay, or appoint a caretaker, for a lengthy period to oversee a carefully considered strategy for how the Tories can best be an effective opposition and position themselves for a credible chance of re-election in 5 years.

But I bet they don’t.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 05-Jul-24 11:13:17

There will be massive recriminations, arguments and jostling so they won’t be much up to opposition for a while.

maddyone Fri 05-Jul-24 11:15:14

Agree Mollygo

Crossstitchfan Fri 05-Jul-24 11:21:41

I only vote because it is my duty to do so. Like many others, I vote to keep certain people out, not to get anyone in particular in.
I don’t think it makes much difference who wins. They are all full of promises they don’t keep. I fear for this country that it seems impossible to find anyone who can actually lead. It’s frightening!

Mollygo Fri 05-Jul-24 11:25:08

Crossstitchfan
They are all full of promises they don’t keep. I fear for this country that it seems impossible to find anyone who can actually lead. It’s frightening!

I’ve just heard in the news that KS is being likened to Tony Blair. That didn’t end well!

AGAA4 Fri 05-Jul-24 11:31:19

The Tories have been doomed for a while. I agree that Sunak was handed a poisoned chalice. Nothing he could do to stop the downward spiral.

fancythat Fri 05-Jul-24 11:31:50

Whitewavemark2

There will be massive recriminations, arguments and jostling so they won’t be much up to opposition for a while.

They need to decide which direction they should go in, first.

I am hoping they go right.

If they dont, Reform may just take over from them.

Is there room in UK politics, for Labour, conservative[a bit left], Lib Dems, and Reform?

fancythat Fri 05-Jul-24 11:32:32

AGAA4

The Tories have been doomed for a while. I agree that Sunak was handed a poisoned chalice. Nothing he could do to stop the downward spiral.

I feel he did next to nothing at all.
I do think he had enough time.

M0nica Fri 05-Jul-24 11:33:32

Mollygo

Crossstitchfan
They are all full of promises they don’t keep. I fear for this country that it seems impossible to find anyone who can actually lead. It’s frightening!

I’ve just heard in the news that KS is being likened to Tony Blair. That didn’t end well!

I absolutely agree with you.

The problem is that policies drawn up in constituencies and discussed in meeting rooms are fine, until they have to be implemented in the real world.

You start to implement your policies and wham, there is a world pandemic. Over that? Watch out, here comes a major war that you cannot avoid. Then, no matter how virtuous your fiscal management is, the USA, or Europe, or somewhere causes a financial crisis.

The next stage is Realpolitik.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 05-Jul-24 11:36:46

Listening to Ch 4 early this morning someone said that the rump of Tory MPs left are to the left. We shall have to wait and see.

25Avalon Fri 05-Jul-24 11:37:55

Whitewavemark2

There will be massive recriminations, arguments and jostling so they won’t be much up to opposition for a while.

It’s been like that for the past 5 years.

Aveline Fri 05-Jul-24 11:45:21

If only Penny Mordaunt hadn't lost her seat she'd have been an acceptable leader for the Tories. Oh well.

Siope Fri 05-Jul-24 11:45:54

I agree that Sunak was handed a poisoned chalice

He wasn't handed anything. He fought tooth and nail - twice - to get the leadership/become PM, presumably because he thought he’d be good at it, which shows a remarkable lack of self-awareness.

Aveline Fri 05-Jul-24 11:47:14

He was a decent and serious young man. We were all glad of him during lockdown. I don't like to see him denigrated. There are far worse than him.

Joseann Fri 05-Jul-24 11:47:21

A woman would be good.
A bit of personality, but sensible, if that's possible.

AGAA4 Fri 05-Jul-24 11:47:44

Fancythat Sunak isn't the Conservative party and he had to contend with a party in disarray for the whole time he was PM. I'm not a fan of Sunak and he may have been the best of a bad lot at the time. The Tories were too busy fighting amongst themselves to actually govern.

Smileless2012 Fri 05-Jul-24 11:47:51

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 05-Jul-24 11:49:49

I agree Aveline.

MayBee70 Fri 05-Jul-24 11:55:53

Smileless2012

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

Charisma isn’t exactly what this country needs at this moment in time. Imo

Galaxy Fri 05-Jul-24 11:58:16

He doesnt have Blairs goodwill either which might be a problem. People are cautious in their hope I think.

Smileless2012 Fri 05-Jul-24 12:01:10

That's a good point Galaxy.

I disagree MayBee charisma is important when dealing with other world leaders.

cc Fri 05-Jul-24 12:05:36

Mollygo

Crossstitchfan
They are all full of promises they don’t keep. I fear for this country that it seems impossible to find anyone who can actually lead. It’s frightening!

I’ve just heard in the news that KS is being likened to Tony Blair. That didn’t end well!

I don't see KS as being like to Tony Blair, he was charismatic, charming and clever. KS is a very different kettle of fish.

maddyone Fri 05-Jul-24 12:08:57

Aveline

If only Penny Mordaunt hadn't lost her seat she'd have been an acceptable leader for the Tories. Oh well.

Aveline I so agree. She wasn’t my MP, but was the MP for the constituency where I used to work. She’s a strong and responsible woman. I knew the person who has replaced her and I’m not impressed. She was all talk and no action when she worked as the NUT representative in the area where I worked, and was useless when there was a problem in my school.

maddyone Fri 05-Jul-24 12:11:22

Smileless2012

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

Keir Starmer has the charisma of a wet lettuce. Mind you, Sunak was much the same.