Gransnet forums

Chat

So who will accept the poisoned chalice?

(156 Posts)
Mollygo Fri 05-Jul-24 11:08:26

Sunak will resign as soon as the leadership race begins.
His was a poisoned chalice, and nothing has changed.

Sarnia Fri 05-Jul-24 15:21:35

David49

Witzend

Aveline

He was a decent and serious young man. We were all glad of him during lockdown. I don't like to see him denigrated. There are far worse than him.

Ditto. I voted LD in a LD/Con seat (Labour come nowhere) but I do have sympathy for Rishi Sunak. Most of the shitshow that caused the Tory catastrophe was down to Boris and Truss.

I’m afraid I suspect that at least some of the slagging off of Sunak stems from racism.

Racism ???

Leading candidates are Badenoch, Braverman, Cleverley, and Patel, oh nearly forgot Hunt.

Oh how I wish we could all forget Hunt. He came within a whisker of losing his seat too. Some people have said that a leader needs charisma. Jeremy Hunt was absent the day this was given out.

David49 Fri 05-Jul-24 15:15:00

Witzend

Aveline

He was a decent and serious young man. We were all glad of him during lockdown. I don't like to see him denigrated. There are far worse than him.

Ditto. I voted LD in a LD/Con seat (Labour come nowhere) but I do have sympathy for Rishi Sunak. Most of the shitshow that caused the Tory catastrophe was down to Boris and Truss.

I’m afraid I suspect that at least some of the slagging off of Sunak stems from racism.

Racism ???

Leading candidates are Badenoch, Braverman, Cleverley, and Patel, oh nearly forgot Hunt.

Jaberwok Fri 05-Jul-24 15:07:33

Rishi Sunak was handed a poisoned chalice, he himself wasn't one! The Conservatives seemed incapable of governing owing, amongst other things, their endless in fighting and disloyalty. Listening to Robert Jennerik I agree wholeheartedly with his interview. It says it all really.

AGAA4 Fri 05-Jul-24 14:44:36

maddyone

I don’t think anyone has said that all the ills of the country are down to one demographic.

Some people actually do believe this. That's why they vote Reform. This feeling has been growing over time and is worrying.

Casdon Fri 05-Jul-24 14:42:45

I think the Tories should look at the reasons why their former supporters have left and pick an interim leader who is a team builder to try to keep the right under control whilst they plan how to rebuild - I know he’s not an MP, but Cameron may be the best short term option? The worst thing they could do would be to let the lunatics run the asylum, they need to keep Braverman and Patel on the sidelines.

maddyone Fri 05-Jul-24 14:36:00

I don’t think anyone has said that all the ills of the country are down to one demographic.

AGAA4 Fri 05-Jul-24 14:28:23

I do find it worrying that so many people voted Reform. It seems that blaming one demographic for all the ills of the country is very like what happened with a certain little man in the 1930s.

Witzend Fri 05-Jul-24 14:27:35

Aveline

He was a decent and serious young man. We were all glad of him during lockdown. I don't like to see him denigrated. There are far worse than him.

Ditto. I voted LD in a LD/Con seat (Labour come nowhere) but I do have sympathy for Rishi Sunak. Most of the shitshow that caused the Tory catastrophe was down to Boris and Truss.

I’m afraid I suspect that at least some of the slagging off of Sunak stems from racism.

TwiceAsNice Fri 05-Jul-24 14:10:20

Starmer is bland and full of promises he can’t keep. No charisma at all . I am glad Lib Dem’s got more seats In not excited about anything to be honest and I don’t think it I will get any better. The tories got a lot of things wrong but they also had to deal with a pandemic I don’t think Labour would have had a clue . I too like Penny Mordaunt I would have liked her to have kept her seat

Aveline Fri 05-Jul-24 13:51:08

Yes he's not very exciting but we've had that -Boris- so bring in the dull but hard working Starmer.

Sarnia Fri 05-Jul-24 13:47:24

MayBee70

Smileless2012

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

Charisma isn’t exactly what this country needs at this moment in time. Imo

Look where Blair's charisma got us. Look how Boris and his charisma ended up. Sir Keir Starmer comes across as a decent and principled man without any gimmicks. I didn't vote for him but he is our PM now and I hope for all our sakes, he does a decent job.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 05-Jul-24 13:41:49

Europe is turning right. The Conservatives will go further right. The numbers who voted for Reform need to be taken seriously. Way more than the number who voted LD.

fancythat Fri 05-Jul-24 13:38:12

I used to think, wrongly, that the N azis were not far right but far left.

I think I can now see that they were indeed far right.

If coservatives go more left, I dont think it would take much for Reform to fill the gap on the right, and possible go far right in a couple of years.
Some might say they are already there. I wouldnt.

4 actual MPs.
Wonder what they will do.

fancythat Fri 05-Jul-24 13:36:03

David49

With Tory voters deserting to Reform in droves where do they go, are Conservatives going to form the centre right, or are they going to move to hard right and win those voters back.

My bet is hard right.

I suspect they will go further left.
Especially if it is mainly the more left conservative MPs, um, left.

LovesBach Fri 05-Jul-24 13:35:31

Aveline

If only Penny Mordaunt hadn't lost her seat she'd have been an acceptable leader for the Tories. Oh well.

I agree. She's seems a decent, intelligent and down to earth woman. Whoever is in power, not a lot changes for the ordinary individual. Many promises, then forgotten or withdrawn, extra money in one area, higher charges in another. Ho hum. At least we won't have to listen to any more election speeches.

David49 Fri 05-Jul-24 13:33:58

RosiesMaw

^With Tory voters deserting to Reform in droves^
4 MP s is hardly “droves”
Protest vote- won’t stay the course.

Reform split the right wing vote, letting Labour or LD win many more seats.
We have Labour for 5 and probably 10yrs it’s going to be hard work for them to counter Reform policies, that appeal to many voters.

fancythat Fri 05-Jul-24 13:33:17

Whitewavemark2

Listening to Ch 4 early this morning someone said that the rump of Tory MPs left are to the left. We shall have to wait and see.

I was concerned about that.

The two moderates around our way have been ousted.

RosiesMaw Fri 05-Jul-24 13:32:55

Germanshepherdsmum

There were a lot of votes in favour of Reform. So long as immigration is a problem they will I believe stay the course.

A political philosophy predicated on a negative policy, directed against a minority of the population is all too familiar to those who recognise or have studied National Socialism in Germany in the 20's and 30's.confusedconfused

bevisp1 Fri 05-Jul-24 13:30:34

Could be worse if we had trump or Biden, who would you vote for then?
I think with Labour in, hope they stick to their promises, I think they’ll still have the same problems whoever is in

pascal30 Fri 05-Jul-24 13:27:03

RosiesMaw

maddyone

Smileless2012

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

Keir Starmer has the charisma of a wet lettuce. Mind you, Sunak was much the same.

I don’t think charisma is what we need. That has been the problem, this “presidential” approach to choosing a leader.
Blair had charisma, Macron has charisma, Trudeau has charisma, Boris (love or loathe) had charisma-
what we need is competence, strength, respect, honesty a sense of duty and service

I completely agree RosiesMaw and if Starmer can follow through on his inaugural speech and maintains his integrity we might start to heal this country..

M0nica Fri 05-Jul-24 13:21:42

Smileless2012

I agree that would be the wise thing to do Siope but it's highly unlikely.

KS is being compared to Tony Blair!!! He doesn't have anything like the charisma.

But Tony Blair was a pr constuct a clever man but not an intelligent man. All fur coat and no knickers, or the male equivalent.

Keir Starmer is a man who first reached the top of his profession and then became a politician. A man with intellectual depth, success in other fields.

We will get more thoughtful governance and less grand standing.

I do not support labour and did not vote Labour yesterday, but not because I did not trust or think the leader was up to it. In 1997, I did contemplate voting Labour but didn't, because I did not trust Tony Blair, I thought him facile, a man whose only experience was in internecine warfare in the party he belonged to.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 05-Jul-24 13:21:16

There were a lot of votes in favour of Reform. So long as immigration is a problem they will I believe stay the course.

pascal30 Fri 05-Jul-24 13:21:15

Aveline

He was a decent and serious young man. We were all glad of him during lockdown. I don't like to see him denigrated. There are far worse than him.

well he was certainly handed a poisoned chalice after Johnson and Truss.. I don't vote Conservative but I do think he did his best.. I expect he will resign and move to USA

MayBee70 Fri 05-Jul-24 13:20:31

David49

With Tory voters deserting to Reform in droves where do they go, are Conservatives going to form the centre right, or are they going to move to hard right and win those voters back.

My bet is hard right.

Oh I do hope not. But where are the MP’s that will stop that? Can’t believe that I’m hoping that Hunt becomes leader. Or maybe Tugendhat will try for the leadership again. If they don’t I dread to think how far to the right they will go.

RosiesMaw Fri 05-Jul-24 13:18:43

With Tory voters deserting to Reform in droves
4 MP s is hardly “droves”
Protest vote- won’t stay the course.