Gransnet forums

Chat

Labour has come under fire after refusing to hold a public inquiry into historic sexual abuse by grooming gangs in Oldham.

(566 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 13:35:45

Scandalous I think.
I’m with Elon Musk on this re his comments to Jess Phillips.

Elon Musk attacked the decision as “disgraceful” and Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, said a full national inquiry into rape gangs was “long overdue”.

Jess Phillips, Labour’s safeguarding minister, insisted it was “for Oldham council alone”.

Really Jess?

GrannyGravy13 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:49:41

Maggie Oliver ex police, has worked tirelessly with victims.

Some of the stories of these children are just so horrific and sad.

There is absolutely no denying that the establishment let them down on every level.

TerriBull Thu 02-Jan-25 17:44:53

Andrew Norfolk a Times investigative journalist exposed the Rotherham Child Sex Scandal which won the Paul Foot and Orwell Prize for journalism.. That four page splash appeared in 2011 prompted the government Inquiry. He was attacked at the time by both those who felt he was unfairly targeting a minority community and also by the far right who felt he should have written more about anti white racism. The police he believed, while fearful of appearing racist, adopted double standards. I think I read at the time, he was warned off the subject as it was suggested that it was a topic too hot to handle given the cultural aspects. That was apropos of first hearing the allegations in a speech by the then Labour MP, Ann Cryer in which allegations were made by mainly white girls against Pakistani perpetrators - he didn't want to follow it up immediately on the assumption that he "thought it was a dream story for the far right" The Inquiry that followed found that 1,400 children had been abused by these men over a 16 year period.

That was all a while ago, what's depressing is how many subsequent cases around the country have come to court which poses the question, is it still going on?

petra Thu 02-Jan-25 17:43:31

GrannyGravy13

Letter from Jess Phillips, safeguarding minister.

JP was so very vocal against the Conservatives for not doing enough, something I agree with, now she is backtracking.

I’ve read her explanation but I would like more information.
I can only assume she has more information into how Oldham Council will conduct the enquiry.
The only person i have 100% faith in to get to the truth would be Nazir Afzal.

MissAdventure Thu 02-Jan-25 17:42:12

Agreed.
It STINKS!!!

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:40:36

Basically, it just stinks doesn’t it?
How DO people sleep at night?

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:39:51

More:

“ He detailed his concerns in a 2017 letter to Prof Alexis Jay, the chairman of a previous inquiry into child sexual abuse.

He wrote: “The current MP for Rochdale, Tony Lloyd, who then represented Manchester Central, made attempts within Parliament to disassociate the grooming scandal from the Asian Muslim community – that is a matter of public record. He also said privately to me that the links should not be highlighted.

“When Tony became Greater Manchester police commissioner and I continued to raise the poor performance of the local police (and calling for the resignation of the Chief Constable, in an article for the Mail on Sunday) with regard to grooming and publicly called into question Tony’s performance, he phoned and threatened me.

“He said that if I ever repeated such comments he would ‘bounce me from Rochdale to Westminster’. My wife at the time was present when I took the call.

“I am of the view that Tony did not want the abuse of children linked with the Asian Muslim community because it could have an adverse electoral impact for him in the election for police commissioner, and Labour more generally.”

Mr Lloyd was elected as the Greater Manchester police and crime commissioner in 2012 and returned to Parliament as Rochdale MP in 2017. He died in January last year. Mr Dobbin died in 2014.

In his letter, Mr Danczuk also said: “When the grooming scandal hit the town, Jim Dobbin MP also told me not to link the issue to the Asian Muslim community because it would have an adverse electoral impact.

“It is also worth you being aware that when the Rochdale grooming scandal did break I was forthright in stating the link between the Asian Muslim community and in pressing Greater Manchester Police to take more action to secure arrests.”

‘There should be a national inquiry’
Speaking to The Telegraph, Mr Danczuk echoed Kemi Badenoch’s call for an inquiry into grooming gangs.

He said: “The child abuse inquiry in 2017 had a primary focus on historical and Westminster-related type abuse.

“I do think there should be a national inquiry into the grooming gangs also with the ability to prosecute those who turned a blind eye, or stopped and discouraged investigation. My only fear is that if a Labour government set the remit for any such inquiry, they would construct it in a way which provided few meaningful results.”

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:37:45

This has been swept under the rug for too long. The former chairman of Labour’s parliamentary party warned that drawing attention to the ethnicity of grooming gangs could harm the party’s electoral chances, the ex-MP for Rochdale has claimed.

Simon Danczuk, who represented the town from 2010 to 2017, said he was “threatened” by Tony Lloyd, who was campaigning to be the Greater Manchester police and crime commissioner at the time.

Source today’s Telegraph

JaneJudge Thu 02-Jan-25 17:36:15

White tribal men?

Jeanathome Thu 02-Jan-25 17:33:20

It is almost as if this hideous scandal is being used to fuel an agenda by Musk and his fans. Surely they would not stoop so low.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:32:12

Silverling48

FGT it’s already been asked a few posts up but can you tell me what the conservatives did about this.? They had 14 years. Shouldn’t you be even the teeniest bit critical of them?

I am indeed. I make NO apology for them either. I have no alligence to the Tory party. I believe Theresa May was presented with a file on this. The ninny let it gather dust on the shelf for years. Totally inexcusable.

But as someone pointed out to me recently (correctly) two wrongs don’t make a right.

Now the ball is in Labour’s court.
I hope for better things (with some prodding by Elon Musk at Jess Phillips).

If it takes American influence to shame us into action then so be it.

MissAdventure Thu 02-Jan-25 17:31:17

I can think of a bigger elephant.

Iam64 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:29:23

The elephant in the room is men and how many if them are capable of sexually abusing women and children when the opportunity presents itself

GrannyGravy13 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:28:39

Silverling48

FGT it’s already been asked a few posts up but can you tell me what the conservatives did about this.? They had 14 years. Shouldn’t you be even the teeniest bit critical of them?

I posted the beginning of the report from the Governments website (far too many pages to post and my phone is link averse)

As soon as Rishi Sunak became PM he set up a task force which arrested upwards of 500.

Iam64 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:27:43

There have been enquiries, Wyllow links to one into the Gtr Manchester force area, which pulls no punches in apportioning criticism to /police, children’s services and other agencies.

The independent inquiry into child sexual abuse was set up in 2015 and encompassed 15 separate investigations, heard accounts from 7300 victims and published its final report in October 2022. It was tasked with considering the extent to which state and non state institutions ‘failed in their duty of care to protect children from sexual abuse and exploitation

I’m not clear why Oldham wants a public inquiry. Huge cost and why would its conclusions be different than those of every other inquiry. Rotherham had an extensive inquiry, one of the conclusions was police were reluctant to act because of ‘cultural sensitivities’.

I was first aware of taxi drivers and take away workers sexually exploiting children in my area in 1998. These areas of employment predominantly involved men who had Muslim Pakistani origin. Organised sexual and other exploitation of children involved men working the doors at clubs, they were largely of white British heritage. My experience was of judgemental attitudes to the victims who were predominantly young white girls whose backgrounds left them vulnerable to child sexual exploitation. The assumption was that criminal prosecutions of the men would fail because the victims would be seen as ‘unreliable witnesses’ because they were taking drugs and alcohol (given by their abusers).

. In 2011 Nazir Afzal was chief crown prosecutor for north west England. He over turned a previous CPS decision not to charge suspects. He brought prosecutions against nine men who were convicted and jailed in 2012 for the sexual exploitation of 47 girls. What a hero.

MissAdventure Thu 02-Jan-25 17:26:02

I've just today watched a video by Emma Kenney, about a young mum who was "raped to death" after a night out.
A freedom of information request into whether the person who did it should even be in this country was denied, as well as the police force who had been informed what was going on and decided not to bother going to investigate being found not to have done anything wrong.

It was all caught on cctv, and her mother sat in court and watched the footage of her daughters last minutes, and her rape(s)

Its about time women were given respect and protection from predatory perverts.

Silverling48 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:24:18

FGT it’s already been asked a few posts up but can you tell me what the conservatives did about this.? They had 14 years. Shouldn’t you be even the teeniest bit critical of them?

love0c Thu 02-Jan-25 17:18:59

That is Labour for you. They are a danger! I hope they are out before next Christmas.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 17:17:41

We all recently discussed how brave Gisèle Pelicot was. People need to know the absolute horror of what was allowed to go on here in the UK.

Countless girls (Children) repeatedly raped , harrowing accounts from the trials , one 14 year old was raped by 32 Pakistani men on a single evening…. Just think about that.

MissAdventure Thu 02-Jan-25 17:15:57

That's still in place, isn't it, with a list of arrests and prosecutions.
So, we're on the right track, at long last.

GrannyGravy13 Thu 02-Jan-25 16:59:59

Beginning of the report on Government website regarding the action taken when Rishi Sunak became PM.

Up till then the Conservative leadership tippy toed round the racial and cultural implications.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 16:56:00

Quote:
Sir Keir gave the green light to prosecuting the Rochdale grooming case, the first of its kind, and said in 2023 he was in favour of “anything we can do to crack down on these cases".
“Punishing criminals, protecting communities and securing justice for victims will be at the forefront of my Labour government.”

Well that's clear: so let's see his Labour government do it. Leaving it to a local council is a complete cop out and disgraceful.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 16:55:15

That is shocking Sago.

Jeanathome Thu 02-Jan-25 16:54:59

" I'm with Elon Musk" God help us.

Sago Thu 02-Jan-25 16:54:03

The child grooming was country wide.

Our daughter witnessed it 20 years ago, she lived in an upstairs flat in a Lancashire market town.
Her flat was opposite a take away, she and her house mates realised what was happening and contacted Police.

Nothing was done so she wrote to her local MP (Conservative) and cc’d the Police Chief , Police investigated but said there was no evidence.
They saw young girls arrive every evening in cars followed by a series of much older men.
The evidence was there every night.

At this stage we had never heard of grooming gangs it seemed incredible in such a lovely area.

About 5 years ago our daughter resubmitted all her evidence and email trail to a researcher, she was interviewed on national radio but still nothing was ever done.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Thu 02-Jan-25 16:51:26

Rosie51 I agree with you about the terminology being used. Asian grooming gangs? Don't insult the good people in Japan, Korea, Vietnam etc. Let's start calling them by their real name.

Pakistani, paedophile, raping gangs.
Stop the B S.