Gransnet forums

Chat

Benefits cheats, do you know one?

(153 Posts)
Sago Fri 17-Jan-25 15:36:13

20+ years ago a family moved into our village, they were shall we say not backward in coming forward.

Like bulls in a china shop they wheedled their way into our lives.

My hackles were up immediately and I now know with good reason, they were major trouble.

She would fill out student loan forms for people, benefits forms etc, she knew the system well.

She bragged about all the houses they owned and how her parents lived in one but she used it as her address.
I realised she was pretending she and her partner ( also father to some of her children) lived separately.

She caused some major trouble me for me so I made a phone call to the DHSS.
In the space of 3 months she was at work and the house was for sale!

I do not regret my decision.

Unfortunately she is not the first person I have known to be a benefit fraudster and I’m sure she won’t be the last.

Do you know anyone and would you make the phone call?

ViceVersa Fri 17-Jan-25 15:45:36

Not now, but there used to be a neighbour of my in-laws who often boasted of 'gaming the system'. Never worked a day in his life, claimed to be disabled and unable to walk, yet it didn't stop his daily trips to the local pub or bookie. I know for a fact he was reported by more than one person, but in his case, it seemed to make no difference at all.

Barleyfields Fri 17-Jan-25 16:04:51

Yes I did know someone who fraudulently claimed benefits and I reported them, successfully. If I came across a similar situation again I wouldn’t hesitate to.

petra Fri 17-Jan-25 16:13:59

Off the top of my head 4.

Sago Fri 17-Jan-25 16:53:27

Petra

4 is shocking!

I once caught a ferry over to the Holland, ther was a middle aged couple struggling with sticks and baggage so myself and husband helped them.

That evening they were practically pirouetting around the dance floor!

Maya1 Fri 17-Jan-25 17:03:39

Yes a couple who lived in the next close but moved away and another couple with 2 children who lived next door. They were not married and she pretended he didn't live there. I knew this because l worked for the LA at the time.
No I didn't report either of them.

Bungle22 Fri 17-Jan-25 17:04:49

In a job I met several people clearly exaggerating symptoms to try to get benefits.
I didn’t report them, but I queried their stories and warned them of not being honest in their applications

Indigo8 Fri 17-Jan-25 17:32:11

There are also thousands of people who could claim benefits but don't, either because they have been wrongly advised, don't know how to or don't want to.

I gather applying for pension credit is a difficult process and simply being eligible is not enough, you have to go to some lengths to prove it.

Barleyfields Fri 17-Jan-25 17:41:01

Yes, I understand the pension credit application is very long and I expect that puts off a lot of people who are desperately hard up and have nobody to help them. That is really appalling and the process should be made easier.

I have no time for those who are dishonest and fiddle the benefits system. It’s fraud and theft. I would like to see a big crackdown to weed them out. That would be good use of taxpayers’ money.

aggie Fri 17-Jan-25 17:45:01

As I was struggling , my manager suggested I get a sick note for a couple of months , which would take me up to retirement
I mulled it over till she added that I could stay on it at full salary for six months !
I’d never been on sick leave , but the very thought of it made me see red , I wrote my resignation letter that night
Everyone thought I was daft , but I knew I would never be fit to go back to full time work
Not everyone is work shy , but seemingly everyone knows somebody on benefits , I don’t

welbeck Fri 17-Jan-25 17:46:33

Someone who is able to go to the pub or the bookies mayhave a long term disability.
Seems in the case stated he did as no action was taken when reported.
Is he expected to cower away inside his flat forever in order to justify his status ??

Barleyfields Fri 17-Jan-25 17:48:31

If someone can go to the pub and the bookie why can’t they go to work?

welbeck Fri 17-Jan-25 17:51:44

Aggie
I don't understand.
Wouldn't it have been advantageous to do as your manager suggested.
It would have helped your occupational pension contributions as well as receiving full salary until you could retire.
What was your objection?

ViceVersa Fri 17-Jan-25 17:55:11

welbeck

Someone who is able to go to the pub or the bookies mayhave a long term disability.
Seems in the case stated he did as no action was taken when reported.
Is he expected to cower away inside his flat forever in order to justify his status ??

That was just one example of his lies. He used to boast quite openly of how he conned the system and tell others how to do the same. I'm well aware of how not all disabilities are visible, but in this case, believe me, there was very little wrong with this man. He knew the system inside out and knew exactly how to work it to his advantage.

aggie Fri 17-Jan-25 17:58:08

It was the suggestion I stay on “ the sick “ for months after my retirement date , I was probably too sensitive , I didn’t feel poorly enough anyway , and I could have worked on for a couple of months

Whingey Fri 17-Jan-25 17:58:48

Another scam! Barclaycard did not send a statement. As I pay by direct debit I got a text saying they would take more than I owed. Called them and they will send another.

eazybee Fri 17-Jan-25 18:02:19

I know a whole family and the cheating is now is now apparent in the grandchildren Sub-letting the council property, not living together 'because you get more points that way', feigning illness to avoid school and building a sickness profile to avoid work, threatening neighbours who see the nefarious activities, likewise shopkeepers when pilfering takes place.
Yet in each generation there is at least one child who refuses to join in and strikes out independently and lives by their own honest efforts.

Delila Fri 17-Jan-25 18:02:46

I wouldn’t have any idea whether someone is on benefits or not, nor would I be interested, or have any way of knowing enough about their circumstances to arouse suspicions anyway.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 17-Jan-25 18:08:32

I suppose cheaters will always game any system ‘if they can’. Maybe we just need more robust safeguards (aka ‘face to face’ checks) in place? Actually in the long term their employment costs would be self financed by the cheats they expose.

foxie48 Fri 17-Jan-25 18:24:16

I'm not aware that anyone I know is a benefit cheat and if I did I would report them. Having looked at the maximum rates paid it would sustain a pretty poor lifestyle unless the cheating included working for cash in hand. We never pay anyone who works for us in cash, we need an invoice and pay by bacs. We employ two people on a regular weekly basis, a cleaner and a gardener, both get paid by bacs and I pay them holiday and sick pay. Too many people moan about benefit cheats but don't report them and pay cash if it saves them money. If you do, you are enabling people to cheat the system. I feel sad for anyone having to manage on state benefits because of disability, genuine unemployment or the need to care for a loved one, the rates are appalling and if we got rid of the benefit cheats perhaps we could afford to look after the vulnerable members of our society better than we do.

Ilovecheese Fri 17-Jan-25 18:27:07

It can happen in a sort of opposite way. People sometimes boast about gaming the system because they think it makes them look clever, when actually they are perfectly law abiding.

kittylester Fri 17-Jan-25 18:34:02

Oh yes! The Idiot to avoid paying maintenance for his children.

petra Fri 17-Jan-25 18:37:29

FGT
Once upon a time they did check. When you applied for housing benefit someone would come to view the room/ property.
Then this thing called ^cuts* came along. False economy like many other cost cutting ideas.

MissAdventure Fri 17-Jan-25 18:38:07

I know someone who drinks and goes to the bookies; he is an addict to both, as well as cannabis.
He gets a full array of benefits and help, and begs too.

That's alongside his diagnosed bipolar, and, I would say, a learning disability.

He has broken his pelvis and both legs, thinking he was given the ability to fly by god (quite common in bipolar)

So, who would like to employ him?

Anybody here?

Sago Fri 17-Jan-25 19:01:38

foxie48

I'm not aware that anyone I know is a benefit cheat and if I did I would report them. Having looked at the maximum rates paid it would sustain a pretty poor lifestyle unless the cheating included working for cash in hand. We never pay anyone who works for us in cash, we need an invoice and pay by bacs. We employ two people on a regular weekly basis, a cleaner and a gardener, both get paid by bacs and I pay them holiday and sick pay. Too many people moan about benefit cheats but don't report them and pay cash if it saves them money. If you do, you are enabling people to cheat the system. I feel sad for anyone having to manage on state benefits because of disability, genuine unemployment or the need to care for a loved one, the rates are appalling and if we got rid of the benefit cheats perhaps we could afford to look after the vulnerable members of our society better than we do.

The whole point of being a benefits cheat is someone with an income stream but still claiming.

Benefits should be a safety net not a lifestyle option.