Gransnet forums

Chat

Secrets! Can you keep them!

(44 Posts)
FriedGreenTomatoes2 Mon 10-Mar-25 15:33:07

I am the soul of discretion.

Babs03 Mon 10-Mar-25 15:15:32

I keep secrets, and have kept some real corkers over the years, but never anything that could put others in danger/is illegal.
Tbh I have forgotten some of them. 🫣

Parsley3 Mon 10-Mar-25 15:02:19

I can keep secrets my own and other people's. Years ago, I had a friend who would say, " I have been asked to keep this a secret but I will only tell you". It took me a long time to realise that anything I told her in confidence was similarly being spread around.
I wouldn't keep quiet though if a child disclosed something to me that signalled abuse. That is a very different kind of secret.

Sago Mon 10-Mar-25 14:41:03

Yes but I find them a burden.

blue14 Mon 10-Mar-25 14:37:27

I've been told things in confidence and would never dream of divulging them.

yggdrasil Mon 10-Mar-25 14:28:27

I once had a friend who confided in me her husband was having an affair, but she didn't want anyone to know. I kept that secret. But her husband and girlfriend didn't and my next door neighbour heard all about it down the pub.
When she told me, I denied all knowledge, but my by then ex-friend blamed me as I was the only one she had told.

nanaK54 Mon 10-Mar-25 14:23:37

dogsmother

Absolutely, if you are asked to hold a secret you must.
However if it were a child and it was of some kind of harm I would in no way shape of form allow the child to think they were expected to hold secrets but indeed to share. I feel quite strongly about this.

Agree strongly with this.

But that aside, yes I know lots of secrets that I would never dream of sharing

Labradora Mon 10-Mar-25 14:23:06

Absolutely. Even on the less personal level of my former professional life, I know secrets about my former staff/ colleagues that will go with me to the grave.
Perhaps I'll burst someday from the pressure !!!
🤣🤣🤣🤣

Allira Mon 10-Mar-25 13:52:50

dogsmother

Absolutely, if you are asked to hold a secret you must.
However if it were a child and it was of some kind of harm I would in no way shape of form allow the child to think they were expected to hold secrets but indeed to share. I feel quite strongly about this.

Yes, absolutely!

Allira Mon 10-Mar-25 13:52:15

Yes, I can keep secrets (having signed the OSA!) but I have a friend who tells me things in confidence, I say nothing then find everyone else knows anyway.
Consequently I never tell her anything; I made the mistake years ago of telling her something then found she was telling others, embellishing it with knobs and bells.

I've only had one friend I could completely trust with a confidence but, sadly, she died and I still miss her greatly.

sazz1 Mon 10-Mar-25 13:46:13

Yes if someone tells me something in confidence I never ever share it with anyone including OH.

fancythat Mon 10-Mar-25 13:37:57

I have a few to take to my grave. Unfortunately.
I try not to even think about them.

HeavenLeigh Mon 10-Mar-25 13:17:03

Couldn’t agree more Calendargirl

dogsmother Mon 10-Mar-25 13:14:08

Absolutely, if you are asked to hold a secret you must.
However if it were a child and it was of some kind of harm I would in no way shape of form allow the child to think they were expected to hold secrets but indeed to share. I feel quite strongly about this.

Oreo Mon 10-Mar-25 13:13:49

keepingquiet

Yes, and I'm telling you what they are!

Oooh! Go on then what are they?🤭

Calendargirl Mon 10-Mar-25 13:09:40

Yes, I can (keep them).

I also subscribe to this line of thought.

“If you have a friend, keep that friend,
But never let that friend your secrets know.
For if that friend should turn your foe,
Then all the world your secrets know”.

Barleyfields Mon 10-Mar-25 13:08:35

Certainly. If I am told something in confidence it goes no further.

keepingquiet Mon 10-Mar-25 12:59:54

Yes, and I'm telling you what they are!

HeavenLeigh Mon 10-Mar-25 12:58:21

I have been told many secrets over the years and can honestly say I’ve never repeated anything that I’ve been told, some friends and I were discussing this topic and a few said oh I could never keep my mouth shut. Any posters here on gransnet had to keep secrets for years.