Gransnet forums

Chat

Who cares?

(49 Posts)
escaped Thu 29-May-25 07:12:47

I am interested in the usage of the expression, Who cares? here on GN. We see it posted quite frequently with no further discussion.
I'm trying to work out whether a poster is being lazy, dismissive or just rude like putting others' opinions down?
(Examples range from discussing real people to talking about a fashion or trend, and lots in-between.)

escaped Thu 29-May-25 07:13:19

PS now I'm awaiting a Who cares? answer!

Carenza123 Thu 29-May-25 07:17:32

No explanation really! It’s like the expression when you have met someone you know, and they say “See you later”, knowing full well you won’t literally see each other later. Just an expression.

BlueBelle Thu 29-May-25 07:17:56

Well I m never sure why someone who doesn’t care has bothered to read the post in the first place or even answered it
Thats a complete opposite statement isn’t it ?

TerriBull Thu 29-May-25 07:23:38

My thoughts, if someone posts 'who cares' on a thread, if they don't care, why even bother to post that, or is it a lazy way of saying 'why has this trivial subject garnered such a response it's of no interest to me?'

kittylester Thu 29-May-25 07:45:44

I'm following * Bluebelle* around this morning agreeing with her.

Who care what those people think.

Casdon Thu 29-May-25 07:53:50

I can’t see the point of saying it, I agree with BlueBelle, why read a thread if you don’t care enough to make a contribution which adds to the discussion. It doesn’t drive me quite as mad as those silly clap signs after you have reposted somebody else’s comment though, I think they are really dumb.

Doodledog Thu 29-May-25 08:01:12

The clap emojis are shorthand for saying ‘My thoughts exactly’ without typing or cutting and pasting someone’s post. Maybe with a ‘well said’ thrown in.

‘Who cares?’ on its own is like a teenager saying ’woteva’, IMO. It’s rude and dismissive. As others have said- why post if you don’t care and can’t understand that others might?

TerriBull Thu 29-May-25 08:05:08

There's one person who sometimes posts on an RIP thread with a 'who?' Often the person who has died would have been pretty well known. That one word comes across as not only pointless but dismissive.

Doodledog Thu 29-May-25 08:10:34

TerriBull

There's one person who sometimes posts on an RIP thread with a 'who?' Often the person who has died would have been pretty well known. That one word comes across as not only pointless but dismissive.

Particularly as the person asking is on the internet 😀. A quick google would tell them who is being discussed, so they don’t have to look foolish.

TerriBull Thu 29-May-25 08:20:25

Exactly! Google is at our fingertips. If the deceased hadn't resonated in anyway little point in posting. 'Who' comes across as very dismissive imo.

mokryna Fri 30-May-25 14:22:46

When I was small in the 50s, my phrase was, Don’t care.
My grandmother told me the rhyme

Don’t care was made to care,
Don’t care was hung,
Don’t care was put in a pot
And boil till is was done

mokryna Fri 30-May-25 14:23:14

And boiled

mabon1 Fri 30-May-25 15:29:28

Simple answer. It just means that you do not care about or for a person or thing.

Ilovecheese Fri 30-May-25 15:46:45

Hanging and boiling sounds a bit of an over the top response!

AuntieE Fri 30-May-25 15:48:09

In my school-days, but that of course is long ago now, "who cares" was considered a very rude way of closing a conversation, as you were indicating if you used it that you had no interest in the subject the other person had mentioned. It also had an undertone of the topic being totally stupid.

The usage may well have changed since I was ten, but when I see the expression used here or anywhere else, my reaction is "how rude!"

Ilovecheese Fri 30-May-25 15:48:17

Or to quote Snoopy " there is far too much appathy in the world, but then who cares"

Ilovedragonflies Fri 30-May-25 15:58:21

My mum used to sing the same ditty, Mokryna, if I muttered 'don't care'.

AGAA4 Fri 30-May-25 16:27:42

Ilovecheese

Or to quote Snoopy " there is far too much appathy in the world, but then who cares"

😂

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 30-May-25 16:46:35

I think it’s just plain rude escaped.

Cossy Fri 30-May-25 18:19:08

Casdon

I can’t see the point of saying it, I agree with BlueBelle, why read a thread if you don’t care enough to make a contribution which adds to the discussion. It doesn’t drive me quite as mad as those silly clap signs after you have reposted somebody else’s comment though, I think they are really dumb.

Oh!

Cossy Fri 30-May-25 18:20:47

AuntieE

In my school-days, but that of course is long ago now, "who cares" was considered a very rude way of closing a conversation, as you were indicating if you used it that you had no interest in the subject the other person had mentioned. It also had an undertone of the topic being totally stupid.

The usage may well have changed since I was ten, but when I see the expression used here or anywhere else, my reaction is "how rude!"

I don’t think people are being rude (on here), I think they are genuinely expressing that they don’t care!

There are things posted on here asking questions, what is wrong with saying “I don’t care” or “I’m not bothered”

Cossy Fri 30-May-25 18:21:32

Ilovecheese

Hanging and boiling sounds a bit of an over the top response!

😂😂😂😂

escaped Fri 30-May-25 18:34:35

Thanks, I think I agree with many of the comments here.

There are things posted on here asking questions, what is wrong with saying “I don’t care” or “I’m not bothered”
I 100% see that, in fact I think we all mutter "Why would I care" under our breath from time to time on GN!!

It's the rudeness in writing who cares? that gets to me a bit, after a poster has gone to the trouble of creating a post. Very often it's those who don't start posts who are quick to ridicule those who do. It also feels a bit like saying, "who on GN would be interested", almost like speaking for everyone else.

But I might be overthinking it here.

I too remember "don't care was made to care" as a child.

Doodledog Fri 30-May-25 19:48:22

I think if someone says ''would it upset you if someone failed to remove their opera gloves when taking a drink in the theatre bar" it would be reasonable to answer with 'I'm not bothered' or 'I don't care' (unless, of course such an oversight would give you a fit of the vapours). A straight answer to a straight question.

If someone says 'Cosi fan tute' is on BBC 2 this evening they are giving information to posters who might be interested, and in that case, a reply of 'who cares?' would, IMO be rude, as it dismisses the attempt to be helpful.