I can remember at my first secondary school, the cane and plimsoll being used quite regularly. Boys could be hit by both genders of teachers with either implement, but only girls could be hit with a plimsoll by the deputy headmistress or another senior female teacher. Never bad enough for the cane, but four whacks of the plimsoll really hurt and probably stopped me moving on to the cane.
TBH, a lot of pupils saw it as an occupational hazard, some lads saw it as a badge of honour to be slippered and caned every week, and some teachers abused their position. Corporal punishment did work on some pupils and not others, who continued to break the rules and it wasn't a real deterrent.
I think when I changed school in the third form and detentions, letters home and grade reductions were used, this worked far better. You could keep quiet at home about being hit by a teacher, but an angry letter to your parents from the headmaster was a lot harder to avoid. It certainly bucked my ideas up and I decided to stick in.