Gransnet forums

Chat

Trad Wives

(33 Posts)
Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 10:00:49

FriedGreenTomatoes2

Probably only for families where the husband earns enough to have a large disposable income (mortgage to pay etc) but looking back there will be a chore on here who were SAHMs.

Mind you not sure they’d be tying a pretty pink bow in their hair waiting for the man of the house to return home after a day at work.

There’s a book we read at book club earlier this year Cossie it’s very readable, sassy with a sideways swipe at the American Trad Wife concept. It’s being made into a film right now starring Anne Hathaway (I know, she’s in ‘everything’).

That’s sounds good, I’d read that!

Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 10:00:04

Smileless2012

^God made man first so he is the leader^ Nooooo *Cossy^ tchsmile. God created Eve from the rib of Adam so she'd be neither beneath his feet nor above his head; equality tchgrin.

Sorry, I was quoting something one of the wives actually stated. It’s not my belief.

grandMattie Mon 16-Nov-26 09:40:44

I was a SAHM and, although much looked down upon by my peers, was ever the first port of call if lunchbox had been forgotten, child poorly and needed collecting, school closed early for some reason…
DH’s job meant that we moved house about every 4 years; with 3 children under 4 and not a great earner, my pay would got to childminders who would bring up our offspring.
We decided that we’d tighten our belts and bring up our children ourselves. One child said it was the best as he’d seen too many latchkey kids, as did the other boy; the girl also looked down on me and has worked through her 2 pregnancies and her disabled child. Her husband has taken lower grade jobs to help.
Horses for courses.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Mon 16-Nov-26 09:36:43

Here it is Cossie.
It provoked a lot of discussion!

THE MULTI-MILLION COPY INTERNATIONAL BESTSELLER THE #1 SUNDAY TIMES BESTSELLER THE #1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER 'NIGHTMARISH, SHOCKING, BRILLIANT' - STYLIST 'MADDENING,

www.theguardian.com/books/2026/apr/16/yesteryear-by-caro-claire-burke-review-the-downfall-of-an-allamerican-tradwife.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Mon 16-Nov-26 09:31:34

Probably only for families where the husband earns enough to have a large disposable income (mortgage to pay etc) but looking back there will be a chore on here who were SAHMs.

Mind you not sure they’d be tying a pretty pink bow in their hair waiting for the man of the house to return home after a day at work.

There’s a book we read at book club earlier this year Cossie it’s very readable, sassy with a sideways swipe at the American Trad Wife concept. It’s being made into a film right now starring Anne Hathaway (I know, she’s in ‘everything’).

Smileless2012 Mon 16-Nov-26 09:29:50

God made man first so he is the leader Nooooo *Cossy^ tchsmile. God created Eve from the rib of Adam so she'd be neither beneath his feet nor above his head; equality tchgrin.

David49 Mon 16-Nov-26 09:16:51

The religious concept of creation has no relevance today we know males and females of all animals were evolved together, most of us are not superstitious to that extent

Weve come a long way since Adam and Eve when man was the hunter gatherer and provided food, shelter and security, to today when both contribute to the families wellbeing. Today we have a welfare system that provides most with support when the family situation does not, Caring for children and the elderly is always going to cause compromises that you may not like but for practical reasons have to be made

Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 08:38:08

So I’m at my DD’s new home every day currently, for various periods of time, to help settle and comfort three confused sausage dogs, so the girls can concentrate on both work and their precious baby, who’s still in hospital.

I’ve been watching rather more TV than I normally would.

Today’s offering is a BBC hour long study, filmed entirely by an independent female journalist, called “Young, British and Tradwife”.

It’s a combination of very interesting, pretty shocking, quite sad and this life is most definitely NOT for me.

It’s well worth a watch. I don’t object at all to the faith side of these lives, but I most certainly do object to the idea that somehow God man man first so he is the leader.

Mmmmmm

If you get the chance to watch this, please do.

The biggest thing which struck me, was the three families filmed all seemed middle class, great income, lovely home families.

I simply cannot get my head around how women fought so hard for our rights, rights to bank, rights to vote, rights to be paid equal amounts for doing the same paid job roles, are then happy to throw this all away.

However, they do have a choice, which women fought so hard to get.

However, their husbands would like all their daughters to be brought up to be trad wives, that’s not a choice is it? I’d call that conditioning, coercion and control, these husbands call it protection and the right way.

🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️