So I’m at my DD’s new home every day currently, for various periods of time, to help settle and comfort three confused sausage dogs, so the girls can concentrate on both work and their precious baby, who’s still in hospital.
I’ve been watching rather more TV than I normally would.
Today’s offering is a BBC hour long study, filmed entirely by an independent female journalist, called “Young, British and Tradwife”.
It’s a combination of very interesting, pretty shocking, quite sad and this life is most definitely NOT for me.
It’s well worth a watch. I don’t object at all to the faith side of these lives, but I most certainly do object to the idea that somehow God man man first so he is the leader.
Mmmmmm
If you get the chance to watch this, please do.
The biggest thing which struck me, was the three families filmed all seemed middle class, great income, lovely home families.
I simply cannot get my head around how women fought so hard for our rights, rights to bank, rights to vote, rights to be paid equal amounts for doing the same paid job roles, are then happy to throw this all away.
However, they do have a choice, which women fought so hard to get.
However, their husbands would like all their daughters to be brought up to be trad wives, that’s not a choice is it? I’d call that conditioning, coercion and control, these husbands call it protection and the right way.
🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
Gransnet forums
Chat
Trad Wives
(33 Posts)The religious concept of creation has no relevance today we know males and females of all animals were evolved together, most of us are not superstitious to that extent
Weve come a long way since Adam and Eve when man was the hunter gatherer and provided food, shelter and security, to today when both contribute to the families wellbeing. Today we have a welfare system that provides most with support when the family situation does not, Caring for children and the elderly is always going to cause compromises that you may not like but for practical reasons have to be made
God made man first so he is the leader Nooooo *Cossy^
. God created Eve from the rib of Adam so she'd be neither beneath his feet nor above his head; equality
.
Probably only for families where the husband earns enough to have a large disposable income (mortgage to pay etc) but looking back there will be a chore on here who were SAHMs.
Mind you not sure they’d be tying a pretty pink bow in their hair waiting for the man of the house to return home after a day at work.
There’s a book we read at book club earlier this year Cossie it’s very readable, sassy with a sideways swipe at the American Trad Wife concept. It’s being made into a film right now starring Anne Hathaway (I know, she’s in ‘everything’).
Here it is Cossie.
It provoked a lot of discussion!
THE MULTI-MILLION COPY INTERNATIONAL BESTSELLER THE #1 SUNDAY TIMES BESTSELLER THE #1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER 'NIGHTMARISH, SHOCKING, BRILLIANT' - STYLIST 'MADDENING,
www.theguardian.com/books/2026/apr/16/yesteryear-by-caro-claire-burke-review-the-downfall-of-an-allamerican-tradwife.
I was a SAHM and, although much looked down upon by my peers, was ever the first port of call if lunchbox had been forgotten, child poorly and needed collecting, school closed early for some reason…
DH’s job meant that we moved house about every 4 years; with 3 children under 4 and not a great earner, my pay would got to childminders who would bring up our offspring.
We decided that we’d tighten our belts and bring up our children ourselves. One child said it was the best as he’d seen too many latchkey kids, as did the other boy; the girl also looked down on me and has worked through her 2 pregnancies and her disabled child. Her husband has taken lower grade jobs to help.
Horses for courses.
Smileless2012
^God made man first so he is the leader^ Nooooo *Cossy^
. God created Eve from the rib of Adam so she'd be neither beneath his feet nor above his head; equality
.
Sorry, I was quoting something one of the wives actually stated. It’s not my belief.
FriedGreenTomatoes2
Probably only for families where the husband earns enough to have a large disposable income (mortgage to pay etc) but looking back there will be a chore on here who were SAHMs.
Mind you not sure they’d be tying a pretty pink bow in their hair waiting for the man of the house to return home after a day at work.
There’s a book we read at book club earlier this year Cossie it’s very readable, sassy with a sideways swipe at the American Trad Wife concept. It’s being made into a film right now starring Anne Hathaway (I know, she’s in ‘everything’).
That’s sounds good, I’d read that!
FriedGreenTomatoes2
Here it is Cossie.
It provoked a lot of discussion!
THE MULTI-MILLION COPY INTERNATIONAL BESTSELLER THE #1 SUNDAY TIMES BESTSELLER THE #1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER 'NIGHTMARISH, SHOCKING, BRILLIANT' - STYLIST 'MADDENING,
www.theguardian.com/books/2026/apr/16/yesteryear-by-caro-claire-burke-review-the-downfall-of-an-allamerican-tradwife.
Thank you 🙂
I was also a SAHM. We had 5 children, a full set of elderly parents and DH worked in a very intense job. I occasionally worked for him if necessary. Luckily, he was paid enough for us to afford this. We made the same decision as GM. And, as she said, I was often the first person my working friends would call in an emergency. I also worked as a volunteer.
So far so trad. But only so far. No one who knows me would suggest that I obeyed my 'leader'.
grandMattie
I was a SAHM and, although much looked down upon by my peers, was ever the first port of call if lunchbox had been forgotten, child poorly and needed collecting, school closed early for some reason…
DH’s job meant that we moved house about every 4 years; with 3 children under 4 and not a great earner, my pay would got to childminders who would bring up our offspring.
We decided that we’d tighten our belts and bring up our children ourselves. One child said it was the best as he’d seen too many latchkey kids, as did the other boy; the girl also looked down on me and has worked through her 2 pregnancies and her disabled child. Her husband has taken lower grade jobs to help.
Horses for courses.
SAHM are not the same as Trad-wives.
I worked, not through choice, but through necessity. My DM chose to work part time once I started Secondary School and whilst I was at Primary School she did various voluntary work like Wheels on Meals. Sometimes I went with her in the holidays, often I was left with Granny.
I have no issue whatsoever with SAHM, other than the occasional twinge of envy. It’s all about choice, and if you have that choice and make it, all power to you.
Being a Trad-wife is about so much more than being a SAHM, it’s about allowing your husband to make all decisions in the relationship.
Many Trad-wife families are “radical Christians”, (their words), so here is the husband making all the decisions about the household, including finances, giving her wife “allowances” for shopping etc, decisions about the children’s upbringing, how the wife spends their limited leisure time, the friends the wife might have, who comes to their homes and she has had to undertake all and every household task with just the help of female children.
I’d last less than a week!
But actually stay at home mothers were the ones running playgroups, coffee mornings for charities and many charities. So most of us were not floating around flicking dusters!
When we have as many SAHD as SAHM then I think we can relax, but until then there is a clear issue.
midgey
But actually stay at home mothers were the ones running playgroups, coffee mornings for charities and many charities. So most of us were not floating around flicking dusters!
Exactly this, in the few years that I was a SAHM I was a school governor, volunteer reader in school and also volunteer lunchtime supervisor.
I set up a toy library with help and was on the PTA committee.
Until women achieve economic parity with men, including equal pay, equal access to promotion, equal pension provision, protection from economic exploitation and affordable childcare, then the the power balance is all one way and not good.
When our last 3 were very little I worked evening shifts in a local bank call centre.
Which left me free to do school runs, get involved in the PTA, I was a school governor for 14 years and had the joy of being with my little ones through Mum and Toddlers, Nursery and Infants.
Once the youngest moved up to juniors I took a daytime job, and had a brilliant childminder who collected them after school and I dropped them off at breakfast club on the way to school.
I was lucky not to miss their early years, but couldn’t keep this up for too long as I’d get home well after midnight, DH left at 6:00am so he’d be home in time for me to go out, and I was literally permanently exhausted.
I had a very hands-on husband, happy to shop and cook and every Saturday morning he got up first, got all the little ones dressed and fed and then along with the dogs walked them off into our local park, giving me a much needed lie in.
We had our shopping delivered (very new, not many did at this point) and housework was very very limited!
And, I agree with GM's other point about lots of my peers looking down on me for being a SAHM.
My understanding is that being a trad wife is much more than being a stay at home mother. It means accepting that your husband is of superior status to you, and doing everything in the home in order put as little burden on him as possible outside his breadwinner role. Blow that for a game of soldiers.
David49
The religious concept of creation has no relevance today we know males and females of all animals were evolved together, most of us are not superstitious to that extent
Weve come a long way since Adam and Eve when man was the hunter gatherer and provided food, shelter and security, to today when both contribute to the families wellbeing. Today we have a welfare system that provides most with support when the family situation does not, Caring for children and the elderly is always going to cause compromises that you may not like but for practical reasons have to be made
Weve come a long way since Adam and Eve when man was the hunter gatherer and provided food, shelter and security, to today when both contribute to the families wellbeing.
May I point out that in those distant days men were the hunters, women were, in the main, the gatherers of other foods and water. Archaeological evidence does also show that women were known to use tools and were hunters too.
Traditionally, it seems both played equal and important roles which were interchangeable.
kittylester
And, I agree with GM's other point about lots of my peers looking down on me for being a SAHM.
I was a SAHM during the children’s early years - until teenager I suppose, but I never ever felt looked down on by mums who worked. Tbh it would not have worried my in any case. Attitudes were very different then but society was on the cusp of change where two salaries became a necessity in order to survive, but where good quality affordable childcare was/is out of reach of many families and so children and women have had to put up with the pressure of holding down a job, bringing up children and doing the bulk of the housework. There is no equality in that.
I am afraid that I am definitely not Trad Wife material 😹
I worked whilst we raised 5 children, we did have an au-pair at one point which was disastrous . Moved on to a live out nanny which worked well for all us. The children loved her and we are still in touch.
Having the funds to employ a nanny of any sort is beyond most people’s budget, so your experience is not typical gg13
Whitewavemark2
Having the funds to employ a nanny of any sort is beyond most people’s budget, so your experience is not typical gg13
It was far cheaper than nursery and after school care at the time.
We had no family close by to help (nearest was a three hour drive or a 2 1/2 hour plane journey)
GG13 I was a single mum for 8 years with my first child, I worked full time in London, a 55 minute commute. I did have two live out Nannie’s, but when he started school (Montessori Nursery, almost full time at 3), and I moved and had a spare room (moved from 1 bedroom flat to a four bed house), I rented a room out to my male cousin, gave my son his own room for the first time, and installed a series of au pairs into my only spare bedroom. Some were amazing, some were appalling! I’m still in touch with the two last ones, who were just amazing. They were all found via an agency and could only do a certain amount of childcare each week, attend English classes and do very light homework.
I was not wealthy, but this and back up from my Mum who lived very close by, kept things going.
I would love to have been a SAHM or at least have worked part time but my marriage broke up when my son was little so I had to work full time. Luckily, I found a very good local childminder who was a great support. In those days, childcare was more affordable, I don't know how families manage now, with such high childcare and rent/mortgage payments.
I could never be a Tradwife, I'm too independant and outspoken!
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »
