Gransnet forums

Chat

Pregnant at 59, is this a miracle or a selfish act.

(23 Posts)
Hithere Mon 16-Nov-26 13:26:02

The question is, should anybody (male or female) be a parent at 59?

If a man does this, nobody bats an eyelash and it happens several times a year.
Granted, they pick younger women but the principle is the same.

As long has this mother has a good support system around her and it was her choice - let her be.

Graphite Mon 16-Nov-26 13:11:38

Unless a woman is forced to have a child or acts as a willing surrogate, all children are born as a result of a selfish act. Whether the mother is 19 or 59, a child is born because the woman wants a child not because the child wants to be born.

There’s no age limit for fostering children in the UK, so long as someone is fit and healthy enough to meet the needs of the child in their care.

Nobody knows what life has around the corner for them. Poor health and death can strike at any age. My husband died age 55. A friend's parents both died in their early 50s. He was a young teen when his second parent died and was cared for willingly by other family members after that.

Provided a child is loved and parent(s) make contingency family and financial provision I don’t see what age has to do with it.

The care argument doesn’t work either nor least because those needing care often have it provided by someone who is not a family member. Someone who has not had children (around 1:4 now) or has outlived them has to make independent provision.

MollyNew Mon 16-Nov-26 13:02:52

She might be really fit and healthy now but I should imagine that after a few sleepless nights at her age she'll be flipping knackered. I had my son when I was 33 and he didn't sleep for about 5 months, it was exhausting.

Unless of course Dr H employs a very good nanny who will do all the actual childcare while she goes back to work.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 16-Nov-26 12:59:48

Oldnproud

I hope she doesn't expect the grandparents to do the childcare.

Or indeed a young person to care for an elderly mother. Bit harsh to saddle someone so young.

Oldnproud Mon 16-Nov-26 12:55:16

I hope she doesn't expect the grandparents to do the childcare.

Rosie51 Mon 16-Nov-26 12:50:19

While I tend to the side of she's wrong or foolish to do this isn't every deliberately conceived child a selfish desire? We have children because we want them not as some altruistic act, the world is not short of children.
A relative born in 1874 had a baby when she was aged 50 in 1924 which would have been even 'older' in terms of health and life expectancy back then. Those who have children in their 20s and 30s cannot guarantee good health although obviously the odds are more in their favour.

Fallingstar Mon 16-Nov-26 12:31:49

It is selfish because although this woman might be really fit and healthy at 59 there is no saying she will be the same at 69 or 79, so if she becomes ill as she ages her child will have to care for her rather than vice versa at an age where he or she should be out enjoying life.
It can only be her own selfish desire that has led to this without considering the child.

Casdon Mon 16-Nov-26 12:29:15

I do think the menopause is the natural end of childbearing years for a biological reason, so I would say anything beyond early fifties is really too late to be having a baby, for both your own health and the baby’s. Having said that, now she is expecting I wish her a healthy pregnancy and child.

NotSpaghetti Mon 16-Nov-26 12:26:45

I wouldn't do this but my husband's cousin had twins naturally at 53.
She had remarried after her first husband had died very young. She already had children who were adults.

Not everyone naturally stops being able to conceive in their 40s Visgir1.

As regards fertility treatment - I think each case is different.
I am less hostile to older parents than I used to be.

Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 12:20:32

dogsmother

I really don’t like it, not natural and say what you like difficult for the children.
However how old was EltonJohn when he bought his children to become a father? Is this double standards ?

You have a point, I believe EJ is now 79 or 80, his husband is 64, their children are around 13 and 15.

dogsmother Mon 16-Nov-26 12:15:40

I really don’t like it, not natural and say what you like difficult for the children.
However how old was EltonJohn when he bought his children to become a father? Is this double standards ?

BlueBelle Mon 16-Nov-26 12:12:44

Personally I wouldn’t want it but it s not my body, not my money, and not my choice.
I m sure she’s got money to employ a nanny if she’s not up to it all

Dickens Mon 16-Nov-26 11:26:38

Whitewavemark2

There is a reason why women become infertile at a certain age.

Nature is wise, and knows a thing or two.

I tend to agree.

Though we do appear to tolerate eighty-year-old, or in some cases, ninety-year-old, individuals being round-the-clock carers, along with, in some instances, very young children.

I think 'nature' would have a thing or two to say about that, if she could speak.

Tenko Mon 16-Nov-26 11:04:26

It’s not for me but it’s her choice . She’s obviously intelligent and she’s had children , so she knows what’s ahead and presumably has given it a lot of thought . Plus she’s fit and healthy .

Primrose53 Mon 16-Nov-26 10:48:33

Her son is 37 and is now a father himself. She had him when she was 21.

Dr Renee is super bright, super fit and a working GP so I’m sure is perfectly capable of deciding whether to have a third child. She says that having her daughter (now 7) in later life was the best thing she ever did.

I wouldn’t want a child at her age but it’s her choice.

Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 10:20:27

Also, personally, I think she’s totally bonkers 😂🤣😂🤣

Sarnia Mon 16-Nov-26 10:20:16

Selfish. Mother Nature decrees the ages where a woman conceives naturally.

Whitewavemark2 Mon 16-Nov-26 10:18:50

There is a reason why women become infertile at a certain age.

Nature is wise, and knows a thing or two.

MaizieD Mon 16-Nov-26 10:11:40

I seem to recall that this same thing happened years ago, though I can't remember the detail.

I think it;s just idiocy.

Chatgtp found me three instances of British women in the 1990s having babies in their late fifties, 2 were after fertility treatment, 1 was 'natural', It couldn't find anything further.

Cossy Mon 16-Nov-26 09:56:37

I had my last three children at 39, 42, 44, all completely naturally.

I worked full time too and was literally permanently exhausted for years!

My grandson (first one) is 12, his mother is 42, his father, 62, 6 years younger than I.

I think, as this lady already has children, 59 is really pushing the boundaries.

It’s her choice, but yes, I think it’s incredibly selfish.

Visgir1 Mon 16-Nov-26 09:49:40

She will be nearly 70 yrs when that child reaches 10yrs, I'm 72, and atm I am staying at my sons house for a week looking after my DGG's aged 5-9 yrs just getting them to school can be a nightmare. There was a major truma with the 5yr old this morning over a sock. I think nature is correct under 40 max for having children.

grandMattie Mon 16-Nov-26 09:41:36

Don’t think so. Selfish imho.

Sago Mon 16-Nov-26 09:36:56

Dr Renee Hoenderkamp announced on GB news that she was expecting a miracle baby girl.

She is a mother of two children 21 and 8.

She had previously frozen her eggs and after treatment in Poland has successfully become pregnant.

I have to say she looks amazing for 59 but is it morally right?