According to what I've read, we should also be asking all overweight men to shield but encourage smokers (although the evidence that any protection provided by nicotine, is outweighed by weakened lungs if covid does get in).
It seems covid can trigger an extreme immune reaction so perhaps those with weak immune systems are safer.
Those who have had BCG vaccination are pretty safe too. And, of course, anyone who lives to tell the tale after trying an injection of bleach will definitely be OK, although one would question their mental state.
Trying to prove your point about mortality rates by using a set of statistics when scientists still don't understand the disease is a bit like taking the rules of cricket and applying them to rugby.
Yes, it makes sense to protect the most frail in our society but we don't really know who they are as far as Covid19 is concerned. I'm willing to wait my 12 weeks out (to flatten that sombrero!). But no, I want better reasons than anyone has provided so far to stay locked up just because I was born before 1955.
I'm hoping good science will get us all out of this mess.
Defiant, spoilt, selfish and ignorant I may be, but I'm not the only one questioning arbitrary decisions based on date of birth.