Gransnet forums

Coronavirus

Christmas break?

(194 Posts)
Daisymae Wed 18-Nov-20 09:18:23

The government seem to be putting signals out for a possible 5 day lifting of restrictions over Christmas. Can't see this being a good idea bearing in mind the situation that the country is in at the moment. What can possibly change over the next few weeks that would make this government policy? I can see they are in a very difficult position but I would have thought that there's a need to keep a lid on things until the spring. The idea of a near normal festive season doesn't seem reasonable.

grannyrebel7 Thu 19-Nov-20 09:24:11

The vaccine is just around the corner now. I think we should all just celebrate Christmas at home. I haven't seen my kids/grandkids since August but am prepared to wait maybe a few more months until I get my jab. I'm glad to see most posters on here have got the same opinion. I urge everyone to just WAIT we're almost there!

Daisymae Thu 19-Nov-20 09:23:18

I think that the mixed messages from the government are making it more difficult to do the right thing. For instance mix over Christmas then wait for the consequences in January. Some people may feel disappointed if people choose to stay at home, others torn between the real longing to be with others but fully understand the risks. The guidance should be clear, stay at home.

Iam64 Thu 19-Nov-20 08:44:55

I apologise for having only read the first and last page of this thread, usually I read the lot before commenting.
It's reassuring that the consensus seems to be we need to continue to be very cautious, no matter what the government says.
I read this morning talk of a five day break in the guidance against meeting indoors, in groups. A suggestion that groups of 10 will be 'allowed' to meet. Like many others here, my age and medication meant I was told to shield in the first stage and had a 'be very careful, don't go shopping, only leave the house for exercise' letter this time round.
I love Christmas, the getting together with loved ones, the religious backdrop reminds me of its central importance to many. I haven't done our usual day of child care since February. My four young grandchildren haven't stayed here and have been inside the house briefly on about four occasions. I miss them so much and miss the very regular times we would all spend together in a large family group. It's really tough isn't it. I want to see those little ones grow up if I'm lucky enough. I do not want to get the virus. The grim suggestion by one of the scientists interviewed this week was that those of us in the clinically vulnerable group are likely to die if we get the infection. I knew this but it sounded even more harsh when spoken out loud.
The bubble idea is a non starter for us and I suspect for many. If you are honest and factor in the various contacts one of your adult children has, you'd be mixing with 20 people very quickly.
Keep safe everyone. Things will improve.

joanna12 Thu 19-Nov-20 08:30:00

I was wondering what people would do this xmas.My mothers first words to me yesterday were we can visit my son and his family now at xmas and go inside,my son and his family have said outdoors only they will not budge he has two children under three.So this xmas for us will be hard i worry it maybe my dads last age 83 but i respect my sons wishes,my parents find it so hard to understand i have had my son is mad from my mum everyone else is etc,and i am stuck in the middle.I feel for my parents,dont they think i want to touch my only child and his family only outdoor meets since march,but my son says they have had no contact since march with anyone there is no way he is messing it up for xmas,so it will be xmas day with my parents and then the 4 of us if we are allowed in Wales by then sat in my sons garden watching my grandchildren for as long as we can take the cold,but they are safe.Happy Christmas all.x

MawBe Thu 19-Nov-20 08:21:06

Good posts both DaisyMae and Cassandra - and many upthread, too many to name.
I feel we have come this far and if a Christmas “break” were to put us back to the stats of the spring or this Autumn, what was the point of it?
Perhaps that’s why Lockdown 2 feels more depressing than 1 - then we were optimistic that it would do what it set out to achieve , only it wasn’t enough of course and here we are again.
Think of pushing a snowball up a hill - and what happens if you ease off.
Anyway we still have 5 (?) weeks to go and who knows what may have happened by then. I’m not looking forward to it if I do have to be alone but if needs must...

Daisymae Thu 19-Nov-20 07:52:23

Think that the government are out of step with this. The trade off on the table seems to be 5 days off over Christmas then lockdown in January. On balance the majority would prefer to keep safe rather than increase the risk of passing the virus on to those they care about the most. Most people are prepared to do what they know in their heart of hearts is the right thing. What will probably happen is that most will not have the Christmas they want then have to go through the lockdown so that a few can have a normal time.

cassandra264 Thu 19-Nov-20 07:34:33

I've come late to this thread, but agree with the majority that we need to accept that this Christmas will and should be different to protect others and keep hospitals functioning. This will be hard as we now live a long way from all family members and this is not always easy anyway, especially as two are now seriously ill (not Covid19).

But our generation has in many ways been so lucky up until now. I think of my grandmother whose husband went missing for years while on active service during WW2, and who brought up 4 children alone during this time. And her brother, who was imprisoned in a Japanese PoW camp for a similar period, and came back to his family weighing 6 stone. I daresay some Christmases weren't up to much for either of them. However they endured, and so can I.

Priviliged Wed 18-Nov-20 23:04:34

I am hugely encouraged by most of the posts here. I also believe that we have a duty to have a very different Christmas this year. If we don't, there will be additional deaths which could have been avoided and that is inexcusable. I heard Christina Pagel (Professor of Operational Research & Director of the UCL Clinical Operational Research Unit and member of Independent Sage) on the radio and say something along the lines of Christmas normally being visits to one house on Christmas day, another on Boxing day, 3 or more generations, alcohol ... which will lead to more deaths. Many of our hospitals are close to being overwhelmed. Leicester hospitals have stopped some non-urgent operations today.
People will look for loopholes whatever the rules and I simply don't understand that. Missee I agree so much. They are risking everyone.
I will be very sad not to be with my children and grandchildren who we always see at Christmas but we need to make it a different Christmas this year. We need to make the best of it. Hopefully, with a vaccine on the horizon, this will just be for this year and next year will be extra special.
And Ajdswan, open your eyes - your attitude endangers everyone.

Summerlove Wed 18-Nov-20 22:44:52

Daisymae

The government seem to be putting signals out for a possible 5 day lifting of restrictions over Christmas. Can't see this being a good idea bearing in mind the situation that the country is in at the moment. What can possibly change over the next few weeks that would make this government policy? I can see they are in a very difficult position but I would have thought that there's a need to keep a lid on things until the spring. The idea of a near normal festive season doesn't seem reasonable.

What a ridiculous idea ??‍♀️

Whether families choose to break the rules or not, the government should not be supporting it.

Nothing like a free for all.

But then again, I feel the same way about giving a weeks warning before a lockdown.

MissAdventure Wed 18-Nov-20 22:16:57

I feel as if I'm trapped on a roller coaster ride as it hurtles off the tracks.
No choice but to use public transport to go to work, and work with extremely vulnerable people.

Just hope it's a mild case, when I do get it, and that it doesn't last long.

SaraC Wed 18-Nov-20 22:12:45

The UK has the highest per capita/population ratio infection and death rate from COVID-19 in the world. Johnson has shown a woeful lack of consistent leadership in strategic planning and management. A ‘five day break’ - really? I’m absolutely flabbergasted.

GrauntyHelen Wed 18-Nov-20 21:40:30

It's a stupid idea that will just leave us with higher infection rate in January

PamelaJ1 Wed 18-Nov-20 20:37:12

We live in a small village, about 200 homes, in an area that has a very low infection rate. We go out shopping and for walks very happily because everyone seems to have got the idea how to social distance. But one of our neighbours got COVID when she went into hospital for a small procedure and passed it onto his wife.
We walk round the village once a day and it’s interesting to see the different cars in people’s drives. They are already visiting. Of course some will be carers or bubbles.
If we get a carte blanche from the government I think it will be seen as permission to party with all and sundry for some.
Thankfully I do have faith in the majority.?

MayBee70 Wed 18-Nov-20 19:48:59

My village has 12+ cases (two hospitalised) because someone waiting for a test result went to three pubs in one night. So a village can go from COVID free to a COVID hotspot in the blink of an eye. And it’s been proven that people meeting up in other people’s homes is the main cause of the spread of the virus. So to relax rules for households meeting indoors even for one day will result in many deaths. Added to which hospital staff are not being allowed leave over Christmas I believe. It really isn’t worth it.

Granny23 Wed 18-Nov-20 19:43:30

Back in the 90s we had a year when 5 of our family died (1 Dad, 2xMums, 2 maiden aunts. I could not face Christmas day with so many empty spaces at the table. So, 2DDs Dh & I picked up a very late deal and spent Christmas in Spain, while my Dad went to my sister's, and the DD's boyfriends went home to their parents. We carried on doing this or similar for 5 years, until both DDs had babies within months of each other, and we returned to whole family + the Inlaws Christmases together.

This year, with our 3 DGC all young teenagers, who no longer believe in Santa, stockings, piles of presents, and my DH, their Grandad, no longer with us we had planned a different Christmas anyway, probably booking 3 lodges in the Highlands to accommodate us all. Now it looks as though, weather permitting, we may meet up in a garden for a Christmas Barbecue, perhaps building Snow Men? otherwise it will be a 3 way skype or Zoom call & Quiz.

What is the point of this long post? Only to say that Christmas Celebrations are not set in stone and vary according to changes in circumstances. We have had a wonderful time every year and many happy memories, eg swimming in the sea on Christmas Day, seeing Santa arrive, with presents, in a helicopter, or on a ten foot high bicycle. This year we will be starting a new format for our celebrations. I am sure it will be as enjoyable as all the others.

MagicWriter2016 Wed 18-Nov-20 19:36:38

If people live in small towns/villages that have no Covid infected folk, letting them get together with family who live near each other shouldn’t hurt for one day only. My two daughters live very near one another and have always celebrated Xmas day together with their children. They are both following the rules, so think letting them spend one day together should be ok. Am sure there are lots of families in similar situations.

I am not advocating folk travelling to be with families from all corners of the UK/world. Just those living within the same town/village.

Jaxjacky Wed 18-Nov-20 19:32:42

I think we’ll be just two, maybe garden exchange of presents with blankets and chiminea. DS in a shared house with 4 others, DD single parent with two GC’s, she works in school, so all three in schools. Will any of us like it, no, we’ve had Christmas at ours for all of them since birth, will we survive? far more likely with no mixing.

Caro57 Wed 18-Nov-20 19:04:15

We are very busy raising awareness that we are a multi racial diverse country yet there didn’t seem to be much relaxation for other religious festivals

icanhandthemback Wed 18-Nov-20 18:51:54

But MawBe, it is all one big hoax, don't you know. The Governments around the world have trashed their economies, purchased humongous amounts of PPE and buried thousands of people just so they can control us. Quite why they want to control us, I don't know but there must be a reason because there are people on here who tell us so. confusedconfused

Sadly, I think that the Government will let people mix more at Christmas, not because the science says we can, but they know too many idiots won't comply and it will be obvious they are losing control. It's a sad state of affairs when people will "die" if they can't have a normal Christmas because that is exactly what they risk if they do.

earnshaw Wed 18-Nov-20 18:51:34

covid does not recognise christmas, its not like in the war were warring sides stopped for christmas day, unfortunately covid does not do that

Hetty58 Wed 18-Nov-20 18:48:02

I'm glad that the vast majority of posters now realise the risks they'd run for celebrating a 'normal' family Christmas. It's just not worth losing lives for is it?

Those selfishly saying 'My life, my choice' just don't take into account the potential transmission to others, the overwhelmed NHS.

Next year when, hopefully, this dreadful virus is gone, and we've survived, we'll have such a brilliant, extra happy, OTT big family party to compensate!

MawBe Wed 18-Nov-20 18:26:11

My apologies Lancslass I didn’t mean you!
That’s the problem with timing, crossed posts etc.
I was referring to the conspiracy theorists and Covid deniers.
I find it absolutely incredible that there are people who are totally insouciant about the risks to themselves and to others.
Like the anti-vaxxers, they make me shake my head in sorrow.
Yes, they may escape or have escaped so far but to defeat this virus we need a concerted approach.

MayBee70 Wed 18-Nov-20 18:16:47

I think the government are just worried that if they don’t let people think they won’t have a semi normal Christmas they won’t go out and spend lots of money. And, just as eat out to help out has pushed the infection/death rate up so will a semi normal Christmas. This pandemic is our WWII. We will party like there’s no tomorrow when it’s over so let’s just wait till then. It isn’t as if the vaccines aren’t giving us hope that there is an end to it. Just as the first lockdown made a lot of people appreciate different things so will this different Christmas. All I want for Christmas is for my family to be safe and healthy.

Curlygirl Wed 18-Nov-20 17:59:26

I think the reason a lot of us have decided not to spend Christmas with family this year has nothing to do with Government restrictions but more to do with using our own common sense. Unless by some magical means the
Goverment can make the virus disappear over Christmas we are as likely to either infect or become infected on Christmas or Boxing Day as on any other. What is the point in being careful for nine months only to risk it particularly when the vaccine is just around the corner.Unless all family members can isolate for the 2 weeks before Christmas this is just asking for trouble. Weather permitting it will be lovely to meet up outside, socially distanced, and even open Christmas presents in the garden. We have bought a fire pit and have plenty of logs. Again if it’s fine a family walk on Boxing Day, socially distanced with maybe a hot toddy! God willing we can have a celebration when things are much better and hope that won’t be too long.

JenniferEccles Wed 18-Nov-20 17:18:47

I think the government has accepted that a large number of people fully intend to be with their families over Christmas, so the current lockdown will enable them to allow gatherings of up to a certain number.

Obviously we can all decide for ourselves whether or not to see our families, and as many on here have stated, some will decide to continue shielding this year.