Gransnet forums

Coronavirus

Friendship vs vaccination

(158 Posts)
Patsie Thu 04-Mar-21 10:29:14

I have a friend who I've known for many years. We get on very well although our views on many subjects are completely opposite. She can be very stubborn and has refused to have the vaccination although she has no medical or religious reasons. She just doesn't like to be told what to do. We had a rather heated discussion about it, at a distance, obviously, and it seems to have cast a cloud over our friendship. I know it is absolutely her choice, but I find it a bit selfish. Why do I feel so bad about the way I feel and how it's affected our friendship. Has anyone else had this dilemma.

Galaxy Fri 05-Mar-21 11:24:17

Most people make some sort of decisions that are a burden on the NHS. Smoking, drinking, obesity, sport, etc.

Dinahmo Fri 05-Mar-21 11:24:05

Rosina When I was a lot younger I didn't like to take medication for my asthma and tried other means to control. I occasionally saw a chest specialist and on my last visit he told my OH that if I didn't take my meds I'd end up in the ground.

Now I wish that I had taken them properly in the beginning and then maybe my condition wouldn't be so bad now. (I'm not as bad as some).

We haven't been in lockdown for several months where I live in France and we are meeting up with friends very occasionally. Two couples at the most and they think the same as us and haven't been meeting lots of other people.

One French friend broke the rules over Christmas and the New Year meeting up with all his children and their children and also joining a large celebration with 8 other adults plus children. He also agreed with a doctor in Marseille who was opposed to the various constrictions and believed in a different form of treatment (this friend is a retired gynae). Much as we like him we made the decision not to see him because we didn't know any of the people he'd seen and also who they had seen.

Perhaps we should just not meet up with friends, without making a big deal of it, if they haven't had a jab and/or you don't know who else they've seen.

Paperbackwriter Fri 05-Mar-21 11:21:36

"I think anyone making the choice to not have the vaccine should sign a disclaimer stating that they will not have any health care if they catch COVID. Why should they be a burden on NHS?"

Hmm.. I get what you mean but would you also apply this kind of condition to anyone who smokes or plays rugby and risks injury?

graykat Fri 05-Mar-21 11:16:25

Since when did choice trump killing other people?

SuzyP2 Fri 05-Mar-21 11:13:07

I have a friend who has had the 1st jab but got a headache for a day or so afterwards. She is now saying she won't have the 2nd one.
Finding it hard to be polite to her, just seems childish to me and nothing I say can change her mind.
I think it will ultimately affect our friendship

NemosMum Fri 05-Mar-21 11:12:22

If you are vaccinated, there is very little risk to you from an unvaccinated friend. What are the conditions of your friendship? Do you require all of your friends to vote as you do, hold the same views on the EU, China and the Uighurs, BLM? Must they like the same food, music, films, perfume? No? Do you require your friends to have had the flu vaccine each year (remembering that many thousands of people die of flu each year). No? Well, why is this difference of opinion casting a cloud over your friendship?

Nana4 Fri 05-Mar-21 11:11:51

Good reply!!! Love it!

highlanddreams Fri 05-Mar-21 11:11:16

I've had my first dose already and so has my husband. I wanted us to be protected and also help protect others that want it but for certain medical reasons maybe can't have it.
If I any of my friends or family don't want to have it then that's their choice, but until this thing is put to bed once & for all I won't be seeing them in person if they're not having it, just in case.

Quizzer Fri 05-Mar-21 11:09:32

I have an acquaintance with similar “Nobody’s telling me what to do” views. She is refusing the vaccine in spite of her DH being vulnerable.
Her most stupid refusal is that she will not wear a seatbelt. The front belts in her car are locked so that she can drape them across her lap to look as though they are buckled when in fact they are not. Luckily she has not had an accident.

Natasha76 Fri 05-Mar-21 11:09:30

I have 2 step children who have said they won't have the vaccine but are not the age to have it yet. Their mother who is my age has refused the vaccine even though her current husband is vulnerable and has been vaccinated. My own children are saying they don't want to mix with people who haven't been vaccinated because its a selfish decision. One is a nurse and is currently vaccinating as a volunteer in her down time & the other is working from home and has a new baby.
We have said its an individual's choice to have or not have a vaccinination but I would hope it is an informed choice rather than an idealogical choice and in a lot of cases that I know or have heard about it doesn't appear to be. Its a I've had C19 or I'm not at risk.....
The best way to change this is to make it socially unacceptable not to be vaccinated and that takes time to percolate through society.

Quodette Fri 05-Mar-21 11:05:39

I’ve have friends who have fallen out with other friends because they wouldn’t comply with lockdown rules. I feel annoyed and frustrated by these people. Not having the vaccine is selfish and personally I wouldn’t want to stay friends. You couldn’t meet up with them anyway as they could be carrying the virus and spreading it. I think anyone making the choice to not have the vaccine should sign a disclaimer stating that they will not have any health care if they catch COVID. Why should they be a burden on NHS?

icanhandthemback Fri 05-Mar-21 11:05:22

My DIL said she wasn't going to be vaccinated. My son asked her why and was a bit horrified to find that one of the reasons is she doesn't like to be told what to do and her work had arranged it for her. He told her that he thought that was an unreasonable excuse but it was ok, he would happily take their child on flights and to anywhere else where a vaccination passport might be required. The next day she came back to him and said that her biggest worry was that her thyroid was out of whack and she wanted to wait until she felt better. Now she does, she is pushing for it to be done. Had he tried to force her to get it done by arguing, she would have just dug her heals in. He married his mother. ?

Patsie Fri 05-Mar-21 11:05:21

Thank you all so much for your wise advice which I greatly appreciate. I don't want to lose her friendship but I must admit things have changed, for which I feel very sad. Maybe she'll change her mind, but that's up to her. Because of lockdown, we don't see each other, so maybe by the end of it, we can get our friendship back on track. Thank you all again.

Parsley3 Fri 05-Mar-21 11:04:49

I have a friend who thinks the whole COVID malarkey is a load of nonsense manufactured by the First Minister to make her look good. Needless to say, we don’t talk politics but she does have other good qualities to offset it.

Theoddbird Fri 05-Mar-21 11:00:47

I would stay friends but would always keep distance and only meet them outside.

Marjgran Fri 05-Mar-21 11:00:39

I would not respect the mind of a friend who was anti vaxx. I would of course respect their right to make the decision but the outcome of that decision is inherently selfish unless they remain isolated. I had long standing friends who passionately voted for Trump and who began repeating fact free conspiracy stuff and sounding fascist. I use the past tense. Sometimes I feel I have to take a stand.

4allweknow Fri 05-Mar-21 10:58:46

If your friend doesn't like being told what to do, will she comply with "being told" she has to go to hospital for treatment for Covid.

Gingergirl Fri 05-Mar-21 10:56:31

I’m not sure what the problem is as a few others have said. If you’re vaccinated, you’re possibly protected from serious covid symptoms and may still spread the virus to others. If you’re unvaccinated, you may spread the virus to others and may have more serious symptoms. So the transmission risk is the same (until there’s strong evidence that it isn’t)....or someone here knows different. Is this enough for friends to go their different ways?

kwest Fri 05-Mar-21 10:56:13

I think I might say or write a little note saying " You are a valued friend, but, much as I love you, I am not prepared to risk my life by physically being in contact with you if you refuse to have the covid jab. I guess we won't be meeting for the forseeable future, you have a choice here. I will respect your decision".

timetogo2016 Fri 05-Mar-21 10:55:48

I totaly agree Eloethan.
It`s not up to anyone other than the person involved to have the vaccine or not.
How would someone who bullied another person into having it feel if that person fell ill or worse after having it.

NannyDaft Fri 05-Mar-21 10:55:37

I agree wit “Leavesden” where would we be if people had refused to have vaccinations years ago ! I feel that ( and only my opinion ) that the jab is the only way out of this terrible situation .

Tiggersuki Fri 05-Mar-21 10:54:36

I think Hetty58 has the right idea: wear a mask around her and do not let her into your house or car until she is vaccinated.
I am afraid I have very strong views on this and believe we should all be vaccinated unless for some medical reason. I would support it being compulsory because it has now been shown you are not just protecting yourself but to some degree others too and it is extremely selfish to assume you are fine not being vaccinated as you could prolong this lockdown frustration and agony for others. I hope as many places as possible insist on the vaccinated for work or pleasure,

TrendyNannie6 Fri 05-Mar-21 10:52:35

Lots aren’t having the vaccine it’s their choice

PattyFingers Fri 05-Mar-21 10:51:17

What I have noticed in this chat is that no-one has taken into account that when you leave your house you can be mixing with any number of people who also haven't had the vaccine and you wouldn't even know. People come into the country all the time and who knows if they have been tested, have the virus or even a much worse strain which wouldn't be covered by the present vaccines.

Catlover21 Fri 05-Mar-21 10:51:16

I wonder how many anti vax folk will change their minds when they realise their options to go on holiday etc may be limited. It is their choice not to have the vaccine but other countries may not allow them in.