Gransnet forums

Culture/Arts

CREATIVE WRITING AND AI

(3 Posts)
friendlygingercat Sun 09-Aug-26 14:54:50

Not sure if this is the right forum but here goes.

As a retired academic I always thought of myself as a non fiction writer but often wondered if I had a novel in me.

A few days ago I wrote a short passage off the top of my head, About a dozen sentences. It was a fictional situation about a woman who is married to a very powerful man.

I decided to run it through my usual LMM (co-pilot) for ideas and the results were really scary. The AI generated the outline of a complete chapter or short story with character outlines, names etc from my piece. I asked if it had it taken the material from some online literature, book, series etc and it said no. The response was that AI cannot create. However they can build on what someone has already created and extrapolate a plot line, which is what it had done. It was written in my literary style and read like something I could well have written.

I tutor post grad students as a job. Mostly international, they know their subject but fall down sometimes when it comes to writing in formal academic style or structuring arguments. Sometimes they need help with referencing and constructing a bibliography. In other words I help them polish their thesis for formal examination.

This is more or less what the AI was doing with me. I am now very divided over my use of AI to write fiction although I use it daily in my work with the students.

How do those of you who write creative fiction feel about this?

mum2three Sun 09-Aug-26 15:04:38

I am not an author but I do use co-pilot a lot and I have been amazed at what it is able to do. It obviously does take inspiration from what you write but it does make mistakes. Mine started writing a story for me but I told it to stop. Human beings write based on their own experiences and ideas. Robots don't. Anything it writes feels second-hand. It cheapens the human experience.
I must admit I feel sure it isn't purely AI...I'm sure there is a certain amount of input from a human. 'Give your little furry vandals a headbutt from me'.....would a robot say something like that?

friendlygingercat Sun 09-Aug-26 15:24:36

The scary thing was that the AI writing was in my style. If I had sat longer and thought about the piece and developed the characters it could easily have come out like that. It took words and phrases out of my head as if by magic. Or perhaps because I interact with the AI on a daily basis it has become familiar with the way I write when I am in literary style - which is nothing like the way I write in chat forums.

I ran a short story I had worked on through it. It was a true and deeply emotional experience. It changed scarcely a word of it. I asked it why and it said there was nothing else to build on. The story was already complete.