Gransnet forums

Dieting & exercise

Drink less fluid - another theory

(31 Posts)
Greenfinch Thu 04-Sept-14 22:26:31

Good post thatbags.I find the theory very odd that we often don't recognise thirst but confuse it with hunger ie we think we are hungry but actually we are thirsty. Weird !

thatbags Thu 04-Sept-14 21:32:00

As if we needed to invent things to worry about.

thatbags Thu 04-Sept-14 21:30:18

If thirst hadn't told us for millennia when we needed to drink, we African (hot tropical) mammals who need to keep our body fluids in homeostasis, would never have survived to be talking about it now. We feel thirst because we need to drink. We drink because we're thirsty. It's a survival mechanism. The idea really is that simple. Why complicate it with bullshit?

Tegan Thu 04-Sept-14 20:36:11

I did feel really good when I followed a regime of drinking plenty of water [albeit not litres of the stuff].

rosequartz Thu 04-Sept-14 20:33:13

It has been fashionable to tell us to drink two to three litres of water a day, which I don't think is necessary. Apparently tea and coffee act as diuretics so didn't count towards the fluid intake.
Now 'they' say that that is not correct, tea and coffee count and so does our food, much of which contains a lot of water.

I don't think thirst necessarily tells us how much we should be drinking, and I know I probably don't drink enough water. However, too much water can flush too many essential minerals out of the system imo.

Must go and make a cuppa (decaffeinated in the evening)!

overthehill Thu 04-Sept-14 20:05:07

Someone out there in internet land suggests all this excess drinking of fluids i.e water mainly, is doing us more harm than good.

They say we should drink when thirsty, our body will let us know, just like it tells us when hungry, tired and when to visit the bathroom. They also say this excess fluid interferes with our metabolism, slowing it down.

I must say I drink tea especially, like it is going out of fashion and when I drink it, I feel the need for a biscuit say.

I wanted to try out this regime for myself and did start and did indeed find I ate less because of it. However, I then developed cystitis which I hadn't had for quite a long time so, in my case decided because of that to abandon it unfortunately.

If you do not suffer with this condition as I do, maybe it is worth giving it a try and let us know how you get on.