Gransnet forums

Education

Phonics

(165 Posts)
GrandmaKT Tue 12-Jan-21 22:42:38

Exactly Esspee! Thank you.

Esspee Tue 12-Jan-21 22:37:52

Surely that type of pronunciation is a speech impediment.
I know of no one who adds an r in words as on the school worksheet. The parents need to get in touch with the school to point out this error as the children could find themselves ridiculed in the future.
I could also see it affecting their job prospects.

dragonfly46 Tue 12-Jan-21 22:25:48

I can accept rarft and plarnt but not plarstic and Doncarster!

GrandmaKT Tue 12-Jan-21 22:21:12

M0nica

Why do you not want your children speaking like that? It is standard pronounciation across nearly half of England.

Really?
As I say, 'arfter' and 'arfternoon' I can accept, but 'rarft' and 'plarnt' just sound plain 'darft'!

Missfoodlove Tue 12-Jan-21 21:41:25

My daughter perfected a Geordie accent after only a few weeks living in Newcastle, she was 4.
I collected her from school and asked her if she wanted a snack when we got home.
“ Why aye mammy “ was the reply.
She soon dropped it when we moved sarf.
Children are chameleons they will adapt.

M0nica Tue 12-Jan-21 21:30:44

Why do you not want your children speaking like that? It is standard pronounciation across nearly half of England.

Sarahmob Tue 12-Jan-21 21:19:21

In answer to your question about resources, yes regional accents are recognised and respected in phonics teaching.
My DGS changes his accent depending on who he’s talking to ... he goes in the Barth with daddy/Grandma who are from Essex, but goes in the bath with mummy/Grammy who are from Lincolnshire. (He’s only just 3)

SueDonim Tue 12-Jan-21 21:15:35

Oh, I see, you meant your GC. Well, it’s really not up to you how your GC speak. If they live in the south, they probably will have that accent, that’s to be expected, surely?

GrandmaKT Tue 12-Jan-21 21:01:48

Lisagran

^I really don't want my DC speaking like that!^
I think the confusion was this - did you mean to say DGC%?

Ah yes, of course I meant DGC. Thanks Lisagran!

MissAdventure Tue 12-Jan-21 20:59:59

I say barth, parth, and all that jazz. Or jarzz. smile

Lisagran Tue 12-Jan-21 20:59:39

Don’t know where the % came from !

Lisagran Tue 12-Jan-21 20:58:41

I really don't want my DC speaking like that!
I think the confusion was this - did you mean to say DGC%?

GrandmaKT Tue 12-Jan-21 20:56:01

Not sure what you mean SueDonim. My DH and I have northern accents as does my son. My Dil has a Southern accent which the children also have as they are growing up in the SE, which is obviously fine.
What I was querying is whether anyone, even in the SE says 'rarft' and 'darft' and whether they should be taught that this is correct. Also whether worksheets are differentiated regionally.

SueDonim Tue 12-Jan-21 20:48:49

Surely if you have grandchildren your own children have already formed their own accent. Why would adults be affected by a work sheet?

GrandmaKT Tue 12-Jan-21 20:45:18

We live in the NE and my DGC are in the SE. My son sent me one of their home schooling sheets this week....

It is about when 'a' says 'ar'. Examples given were 'after' and 'afternoon', which I can just about live with, but then

'daft', 'raft', 'dance'!

I really don't want my DC speaking like that!

It also made me think - do teachers use different resources depending on the area they are teaching in? I really can't see this worksheet being used in our area.