Gransnet forums

Education

Graduates on benefits claiming too sick to work

(179 Posts)
David49 Mon 26-Jan-26 08:35:09

This is a sad indictment of our education system not providing what the state needs

www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/01/25/surge-in-graduates-claiming-benefits-too-sick-to-work/

After being encouraged by teachers to take the university route no wonder so many are suffering mental health problems. The country desperately needs technical skills.

Of my 8 grandchildren and their partners old enough, only those that took the technical route have got proper jobs, those with degrees are earning less doing casual unskilled work, so sad for them. None are claiming benefits

fancythat Sun 08-Feb-26 17:47:53

FranP

LOUISA1523

Even a degree leading to a profession does not guarantee work ....no nursing jobs going for graduates these days

My DD walked straight into a job on graduation.

She was prepared to travel a bit,
She gained some relevant experience during holidays
She worked weekends, showing a work ethic
She kept a record and produced a good CV and her school NRA
She worked at applying for jobs straight away
She bought a new smart suit for interviews
She made friends with recruitment agents
She showed her McD hygiene certificate on her CV

She did not sit around having a summer holiday after graduating; she did not wait for the better salary offer; she looked around for a job that was a step in the right direction without feeling that her excellent degree was enough

Of her graduating year only 3 got jobs straight away with others moaning that there was nothing suitable around

Bit late to this post. But whatever.

Your last paragraph is alarming.

She made friends with recruitment agents
Sory, I dont understand.
In what way?
And in what field?

fancythat Sun 08-Feb-26 13:57:06

FranP

LOUISA1523

Even a degree leading to a profession does not guarantee work ....no nursing jobs going for graduates these days

Perhaps not, but there are plenty of healthcare jobs, so there is no need for graduates to sit on benefits when they could be gaining some experience and getting pai

Are there plenty?

Is it not the case that many docotrs and nurses are being brought in from abroad, as they are cheaper to hire?

I could be wrong.

This thread disturbs me

I have read before[not on this forum I dont think] that the graduates market is not good at all.

I dont know enough about the whole subject[part ly because my gcs are not at that age yet, currently] so I sort of dont have to.

But it doesnt seem to be good, the snippets I do read.

CariadAgain Sun 08-Feb-26 10:03:29

Grandma70s

Chocolatelovinggran

Yes, David , maths is compulsory up to age sixteen, or older, if the students undertake the International Baccalaureate.

Luckily for me, I could get a university place to read English without O Level maths, provided I had Latin, which I did. This was a very long time ago. I have a higher degree in English, but I didn’t even take O Level maths. I’d have failed, anyway,

Just as well. I've never understood pushing maths - as either one can do it or one can't and it depends on what type of mind one has imo. My father was a maths teacher - but me...I couldnt even pass my O level in it - because that's not the sort of mind I have and, for some of us, our mind will only function at the lowest level on anything like maths or anything technical. So I don't see the point of pushing someone whose mind just doesn't go in that direction - as long as we can manage to work out our own budget = that's all the figurework etc we need to know and we will manage without that basically perfectly well.

Could we have it both ways? A mind that would work that way or, on the other hand, is more intuitive. I know which serves me best personally - as a shopkeeper locally found out yesterday when he let someone nip in briefly in front of me (the customer he was serving) - as this is one of the faults of this area that they do that here. Cue for when I was looking for my (expensive) possession we both knew was where we left it (ie on the counter) - and up comes my mind with "Mr Rude Man that just nipped in has stolen it - he's got it". Thanks to that mindset - doubtful shopkeeper was given no choice but to follow up and ring Rude Guys phone - and he had to walk back into the shop and hand me back my stolen possession.

In my opinion one just can't have both frame of mind and a mind that will cope with maths/technology way of thinking. They're mutually exclusive. Me - I'd rather have the mindset where I found someone's home before now - when they hadnt told me the address - but I walked straight to it and in the unlocked back door (just as well it was the darn correct house) and I knew my possession had been stolen yesterday in time to get it back again.

MartavTaurus Sun 08-Feb-26 09:20:15

FranP

Is it perhaps that having all those years of high pressure treadmill, it is just a need to drift a little, take stock and simply rest.
Seldom entitled to much in the way of dole.

Life has its pressures, work has its stresses, the treadmill is tedious, but we don't all drift a little and take a rest on benefits when things get tough.
By all means young people could take a gap year to explore their options, but it wouldn't be good to be an eternal shirker.

FranP Sat 07-Feb-26 22:34:47

Is it perhaps that having all those years of high pressure treadmill, it is just a need to drift a little, take stock and simply rest.
Seldom entitled to much in the way of dole.

FranP Sat 07-Feb-26 22:23:58

David49

Mamie

David49

The reasonat children are not inspired by maths is because at higher levels its not relevant to everyday life. We all have calculators, computers and all the other electronic devices, we dont need to know how they operare to use them, we certainly cannot repair them if they go wrong. Unless we want to be a software engineer, electronic designer, or computer hacker, its not relevant.
If basic accounting, finance and economics were taught it would benefit far more.

Are you talking about Key Stage 4 David or A level? Would be interesting to hear your view of the former. Link below:

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a7dc9dced915d2ac884d8ef/KS4_maths_PoS_FINAL_170714.pdf

I can relate to all that when I took GCE maths 60 yrs ago except we didnt have calculators to solve the problems and we were dealing with imperial measures not metric. You may remember calculations longhand took somewhat longer. A few years later we did use slide rules at college for practical calculations.

Although we did learn Logs, Trig and Algebra I have not used any since my schooldays. Its nice to know these principles but its like languages if you dont use them you loose the ability.

Is Maths a compulsory subject at GCSE ?, if so thats probably the reason grades are low, too many uninspired students taking the exam

I was lucky to have a maths teacher who encouraged me and found ways to help me gain my GCE in maths by teaching alternative ways until it sunk in.
I had a successful career in market research (lots of analysis and stats) before turning to software, where I was a systems programmer, then and applications programmer, running teams before going outward into project and programme management.
Never once was my lack of mathematical ability of any hamper to this - in fact over the years three of my best staff were actually languages graduates

FranP Sat 07-Feb-26 22:16:22

LOUISA1523

Even a degree leading to a profession does not guarantee work ....no nursing jobs going for graduates these days

Perhaps not, but there are plenty of healthcare jobs, so there is no need for graduates to sit on benefits when they could be gaining some experience and getting pai

Grandma70s Sat 31-Jan-26 08:12:10

Chocolatelovinggran

Yes, David , maths is compulsory up to age sixteen, or older, if the students undertake the International Baccalaureate.

Luckily for me, I could get a university place to read English without O Level maths, provided I had Latin, which I did. This was a very long time ago. I have a higher degree in English, but I didn’t even take O Level maths. I’d have failed, anyway,

David49 Sat 31-Jan-26 07:53:02

I enjoyed maths, physics and science too most of that was because I got on well with the teachers. They taught a lot of practical skills as well as the theoretical background, after a few years working, technical college then management college I learned how to make 2+2=6.
Self Employed from then

Allira Fri 30-Jan-26 21:05:31

Is Maths a compulsory subject at GCSE ?, if so thats probably the reason grades are low, too many uninspired students taking the exam

Yes, it is.
Maths, English Language and Sciences in England.
Plus Welsh in Wales.

Some teachers are inspiring but not all, unfortunately.

Chocolatelovinggran Fri 30-Jan-26 20:48:28

Yes, David , maths is compulsory up to age sixteen, or older, if the students undertake the International Baccalaureate.

David49 Fri 30-Jan-26 17:30:53

Mamie

David49

The reasonat children are not inspired by maths is because at higher levels its not relevant to everyday life. We all have calculators, computers and all the other electronic devices, we dont need to know how they operare to use them, we certainly cannot repair them if they go wrong. Unless we want to be a software engineer, electronic designer, or computer hacker, its not relevant.
If basic accounting, finance and economics were taught it would benefit far more.

Are you talking about Key Stage 4 David or A level? Would be interesting to hear your view of the former. Link below:

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a7dc9dced915d2ac884d8ef/KS4_maths_PoS_FINAL_170714.pdf

I can relate to all that when I took GCE maths 60 yrs ago except we didnt have calculators to solve the problems and we were dealing with imperial measures not metric. You may remember calculations longhand took somewhat longer. A few years later we did use slide rules at college for practical calculations.

Although we did learn Logs, Trig and Algebra I have not used any since my schooldays. Its nice to know these principles but its like languages if you dont use them you loose the ability.

Is Maths a compulsory subject at GCSE ?, if so thats probably the reason grades are low, too many uninspired students taking the exam

Mamie Fri 30-Jan-26 13:22:44

David49

The reasonat children are not inspired by maths is because at higher levels its not relevant to everyday life. We all have calculators, computers and all the other electronic devices, we dont need to know how they operare to use them, we certainly cannot repair them if they go wrong. Unless we want to be a software engineer, electronic designer, or computer hacker, its not relevant.
If basic accounting, finance and economics were taught it would benefit far more.

Are you talking about Key Stage 4 David or A level? Would be interesting to hear your view of the former. Link below:

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a7dc9dced915d2ac884d8ef/KS4_maths_PoS_FINAL_170714.pdf

Allira Fri 30-Jan-26 13:20:10

Thank you MartavTaurus

MartavTaurus Fri 30-Jan-26 13:17:40

I don't think so Allira. It was a new initiative by Rishi and wife, whose name escapes me.
richmondproject.org/

Allira Fri 30-Jan-26 13:09:47

MartavTaurus

Regarding Maths, I think Rishi Sunak's Richmond project is still ongoing, isn't it?
I'm sure it still supports Maths Week in schools, for example, and has the right idea ..... to get children to enjoy the subject.

Richmond Project?

Is this the Maths that was taught in my DD's Primary School years ago? Well, 40 years ago in fact!

David49 Fri 30-Jan-26 08:46:07

The reasonat children are not inspired by maths is because at higher levels its not relevant to everyday life. We all have calculators, computers and all the other electronic devices, we dont need to know how they operare to use them, we certainly cannot repair them if they go wrong. Unless we want to be a software engineer, electronic designer, or computer hacker, its not relevant.
If basic accounting, finance and economics were taught it would benefit far more.

MartavTaurus Fri 30-Jan-26 08:00:29

Regarding Maths, I think Rishi Sunak's Richmond project is still ongoing, isn't it?
I'm sure it still supports Maths Week in schools, for example, and has the right idea ..... to get children to enjoy the subject.

Mamie Fri 30-Jan-26 03:50:24

SporeRB01

In my humble ‘non intelligent’ opinion since we are discussing IQs, technical subjects are more suited to students with an aptitude towards Maths.

When I was studying for my higher technical diploma, one of the subjects is structural mechanics and structural mechanics is all Maths.

Unfortunately, 40 % of students in the UK fail to achieve a standard pass in GCSE Maths.

This problem needs to be resolved first in order to tackle the lack of technical skills.

Whoever in charge of education should go to other countries which achieved global rankings in Maths and see what methods they use to teach Maths.

My sisters' grandchildren attended kindergartens and can now speak 3 languages including English and Mandarin.

These are the 2025 results for Grade 4 and above.
In English, 70.6 per cent of grades were at grade 4 and above, down 0.8 per cent on the 71.2 per cent last year. For maths, the number was 71.9 per cent, down from 72 per cent last year. These figures are for GCSE.
Not sure where your 40% failing to get a standard Grade 4 comes from?

Allira Thu 29-Jan-26 18:30:31

Whoever in charge of education should go to other countries which achieved global rankings in Maths and see what methods they use to teach Maths.

I agree. Why is it that many British children are fearful of Maths? Is it because it is not well taught or made enjoyable?

It seems to be enjoyable in early years and then some dread it and assume they will fail. It has always been thus, I think.

Allira Thu 29-Jan-26 18:26:39

and one has to watch out for "Arafs" signs printed on tarmac when driving . I've not forgotten that one - after someone made a comment one time of how we're told to "slow down for these little creatures called Arafs" and that one comes to mind every time and I'm there thinking "Mustn't forget those Arafs".

Apologies.

I should RTT!

Allira Thu 29-Jan-26 18:24:35

Well you must know what Cariad means
Yes!

Do you drive, Cariad? If so, I hope you know what Araf means 🙂

SporeRB01 Thu 29-Jan-26 18:01:49

In my humble ‘non intelligent’ opinion since we are discussing IQs, technical subjects are more suited to students with an aptitude towards Maths.

When I was studying for my higher technical diploma, one of the subjects is structural mechanics and structural mechanics is all Maths.

Unfortunately, 40 % of students in the UK fail to achieve a standard pass in GCSE Maths.

This problem needs to be resolved first in order to tackle the lack of technical skills.

Whoever in charge of education should go to other countries which achieved global rankings in Maths and see what methods they use to teach Maths.

My sisters' grandchildren attended kindergartens and can now speak 3 languages including English and Mandarin.

icanhandthemback Thu 29-Jan-26 18:00:58

Whilst the discussion about the origins is interesting, this is now so far from the subject of the thread, it could be a different one! I didn't think that was the done thing on GN?

CariadAgain Thu 29-Jan-26 17:42:39

"Cariad" and "Hiraeth" if we're stretching it.....and one has to watch out for "Arafs" signs printed on tarmac when driving . I've not forgotten that one - after someone made a comment one time of how we're told to "slow down for these little creatures called Arafs" and that one comes to mind every time and I'm there thinking "Mustn't forget those Arafs".

I can see the point made too re Germanic languages - as I can pick out odd bits and pieces from German too and was managing to get the general gist okay when I went there on holiday.

So yep.....French/Italian/German/Scandinavian languages and there's enough to pick up the gist....but anything else.....apart (in my case) from a tiny bit of verbal Arabic (from my first few boyfriends way back when) and I've been known to leave one of their friends gobsmacked when he spoke to me in Arabic and I answered him straight back perfectly accurately - as he hadn't known I knew those words. I didn't - I was as astonished as he was that I'd understood him.

I think it's a combination of the language has a different base to any I'm familiar with - and I have seen pressure put on others/put on me about it and I got told decades ago by my mother that the best possible way to get me not to do something was to try and make me do it and in dug my metaphorical heels and that was that.....I'd never do whatever it was she wanted if I could help it.

I have felt very sympathetic towards anyone I saw being pressurised and have been seen running towards a woman I knew of when I spotted her deliberately walking up to a Council workman on duty and he clearly had no idea what she was saying and (very politely) told her so. She did hear him saying that...I know she did....but she repeated herself at him (in very angry fashion). She didn't get a third chance to do that to him - as I ran up to them and said "He's TOLD you he doesn't speak Welsh. You heard him" and she stormed off and he thanked me for saving him from her. She knew I knew this sort of episode was a speciality of hers....and she'd done it to me several times and thrown me out of communal conversations by "switching and ignoring".