Gransnet forums

Estrangement

6 sources of tension between adult children and parents

(329 Posts)
VioletSky Tue 26-Jul-22 14:28:43

Would you add anything?

www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/tech-support/202207/6-sources-tension-between-adult-children-and-parents

Summerlove Tue 02-Aug-22 11:44:40

Americans are exceptional at sarcasm.

I’ve always found the UK does better at so called “dry wit”.

I wonder if this is a case Of translation gone wrong

Smileless2012 Tue 02-Aug-22 08:55:33

Remember that one too DL and couldn't believe how much we had in common with themgrin.

DiamondLily Tue 02-Aug-22 04:36:11

Smileless2012

Oh yes Victor Mildrew. Me and the boys always laughed at the lyrics of the song, we would sing along and look at Mr. S. and that was way before he was oldgrin.

There used to be light hearted programmes on TV called Grumpy Old Men/Women.

I think we realised we were getting older when we agreed with most of the "moans" lol ?

VioletSky Mon 01-Aug-22 23:09:37

Must have had sarcasm mode switched on continually to come up with that generalisation

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 23:00:08

I guess the ones we met just didn't imaround.

imaround Mon 01-Aug-22 22:51:24

Funny, I have yet to meet an American who doesn't understand sarcasm. Everyone I know is fluent. Odd that you had that experience Smileless.

VS: my mother is fluent in triangulation. I do not participate and when I hear it happening, even now, I shut it down.

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 21:00:38

Oh yes Victor Mildrew. Me and the boys always laughed at the lyrics of the song, we would sing along and look at Mr. S. and that was way before he was oldgrin.

DiamondLily Mon 01-Aug-22 18:36:56

Smileless2012

Mr. S. and DS are huge Blackadder fans (ES was too) and often use what I call 'Blackadder speak' DL. For 10 years we had a villa in Florida so spent quite a bit of time there and the main I noticed was they didn't 'get' scarcasm.

Our ES's wife used to do that icanhandthemback try playing one off against the other, always found it rather embarrassing TBH as it was so obvious.

I must admit Blackadder does make me laugh. ?

But, when he’s having one of his “put the world to rights” days, I call DH the ba**ard child of Basil Fawlty snd Victor Mildrew., so I can see the funny side of those as well. ??

VioletSky Mon 01-Aug-22 17:51:42

lovebeigecardigans1955

Something my late ILs did was to try to play one person off against another, "you understand, don't you, beige so-and-so doesn't". My SIL was disliked and there wasn't a lot of diplomacy to hide it. It was awkward as we didn't want to get involved but they wanted us to take sides.

I always felt that I wasn't quite up to scratch either, not being sociable or gushy enough iyswim.

I notice this a lot in troubled families.

There is often a "good" child and a "bad" child. Or a "good" family and a "bad" one. With all the gossip and the "why cany you be more like x"

I grew up watching how differently the child of my mother and stepfathers marriage was treated to me and it did hurt.

But what I didn't know and never suspected until the end of the relationship was just how much I had been badmouthed to my own brother. All the lies he had been told about me. Every situation where she had hurt me had been later respun into the opposite and told to my brother unknown to me.

I really don't think it is ever OK to try and get siblings involved in that way.

Or any other family members.

It's called triangulation.

If a family member is doing that, playing relatives off against each other, getting one family member on sode against another...

I can't even begin to express how wrong that is.

Whatever the family situation

Siblings especially should be kept out of the drama and encouraged to have a good relationship with each other no matter who else doesn't get on.

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 17:23:24

sarcasm not scarcasm and I read it through before I posted it.

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 17:22:08

Mr. S. and DS are huge Blackadder fans (ES was too) and often use what I call 'Blackadder speak' DL. For 10 years we had a villa in Florida so spent quite a bit of time there and the main I noticed was they didn't 'get' scarcasm.

Our ES's wife used to do that icanhandthemback try playing one off against the other, always found it rather embarrassing TBH as it was so obvious.

DiamondLily Mon 01-Aug-22 15:40:45

lovebeigecardigans1955

Something my late ILs did was to try to play one person off against another, "you understand, don't you, beige so-and-so doesn't". My SIL was disliked and there wasn't a lot of diplomacy to hide it. It was awkward as we didn't want to get involved but they wanted us to take sides.

I always felt that I wasn't quite up to scratch either, not being sociable or gushy enough iyswim.

No, I'm not gushy, and I never want to get involved in other peoples disputes.

I used to just say "best sort out with them" and shut the conversation down.

No point in taking sides when you don't have to.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Mon 01-Aug-22 15:28:55

Something my late ILs did was to try to play one person off against another, "you understand, don't you, beige so-and-so doesn't". My SIL was disliked and there wasn't a lot of diplomacy to hide it. It was awkward as we didn't want to get involved but they wanted us to take sides.

I always felt that I wasn't quite up to scratch either, not being sociable or gushy enough iyswim.

DiamondLily Mon 01-Aug-22 15:18:19

Smileless2012

DS in Aus. is divorced (no children thank goodness) and lives alone so when there's a problem we're the first ones he contacts. Being estranged from his brother and knowing how important our relationship is to him, really does mean the worldsmile.

Yes, I can imagine. DS phones or FaceTimes every week to see how we are, and to chat about politics, life over the pond etc.

He made me laugh yesterday, as he'd spent some time watching old comedy DVDs he took with him to the States, sort of Fools and Horses, Blackadder, One foot in the Grave, the Office etc.

He said he spent more time explaining the humour than watching them. I can see why, when we export comedy, so much has to be changed for an American audience.?

Both sides of the pond have a sense of humour - just different.

On the positive side, last time they came over, in October, DD, the grandkids, and I did manage to teach them the Lambeth Walk, Knees up Mother Brown, and the Agadoo "dances" lol

Not sure how much help that was, but the wine had been flowing....??

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 15:02:11

DS in Aus. is divorced (no children thank goodness) and lives alone so when there's a problem we're the first ones he contacts. Being estranged from his brother and knowing how important our relationship is to him, really does mean the worldsmile.

DiamondLily Mon 01-Aug-22 14:11:31

We don't get too many dramas from my son and family in America, he's very laid back.

It's only when they come over, we get the drama.

They usually bring friends and neighbours with them, so we end up with a crowd of Americans - great to see and meet them, but it gets a bit hectic.?

My DIL is lovely, but she can create a drama out of nothing, even happy stuff. Nothing is ever quietly said or discussed lol

It's endless tears of happiness or upset, bit like Jerry Springer, I always think (silently!). DD and I spend a lot of time discreetly rolling our eyes.

I get on very well with her, but I wonder how it would be if she lived over here - we are very different. She doesn't "get" irony, self deprecation or droll and takes everything very seriously. Perhaps Americans just have a different sense of humour to English people.

Still, son is happy and that's all that matters. I can cope with her and the drama once every year or so.

I do need a rest when they're gone though lol ?

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 12:26:46

Tell me about it. DS is 39 and living in Aus. but we still get drama bless him.

DiamondLily Mon 01-Aug-22 12:09:31

Smileless2012

Good grief DSL I struggled when the boys were teenagers, just the two of them so can't imagine what it must have been like with four, and all at the same time.

3 boys and a the youngest a girl....jeez, it was chaos at times. All worked out well, they are all lovely young adults now. ?

Still a lot of dramas though.?

VioletSky Mon 01-Aug-22 11:32:25

Whoops lol

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 10:59:30

Sorry I meant you DL.

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 10:59:04

Good grief DSL I struggled when the boys were teenagers, just the two of them so can't imagine what it must have been like with four, and all at the same time.

VioletSky Mon 01-Aug-22 10:50:15

I'm just as capable of ignoring the world with a book in my hand but at least I won't get judged for it

VioletSky Mon 01-Aug-22 10:49:30

Do people think we have a whole generation glued to phones and gadgets all day?

Those phones and gadgets appear to be in everyones hands...

I suppose its easy to be judgemental about something that didn't exist while others were parenting.

Even though most recent generations have been hugely interested in new gadgets that give them more down time

DiamondLily Mon 01-Aug-22 09:21:10

Smileless2012

I think that's lovely DL that they knew they could come and stay and have a break. Your AC must have appreciated that too. Those teenage years aren't easy are they.

Not with four of them doing it at the same time...it was all hormones, dramas, door banging and shouting.?

Staying here did just calm the waters. It gave them and my DD/SIL a bit of space.?

Smileless2012 Mon 01-Aug-22 09:11:02

I think that's lovely DL that they knew they could come and stay and have a break. Your AC must have appreciated that too. Those teenage years aren't easy are they.