Gransnet forums

Food

They. Are. Not. Pancakes

(80 Posts)
Soutra Sun 02-Mar-14 20:09:24

Full page ad by Asda in today's Sunday Telegraph Stella magazine for "Scotch Pancakes" - all 9 flavours apparently.
May I make this clear
1) there is nothing "Scotch" about them under this designation
2) They. are. not. pancakes
They are drop scones - also known as girdle scones.
Not pancakes.
Got it?
As such they may well be Scottish, but I imagine other areas such as Yorkshire or Wales can lay claim to a similar baked good.

Rant over (just so long as you remember) smile

Agus Mon 03-Mar-14 14:26:02

Definitely known as pancakes here and also at school and Girl Guides where we were taught to cook them on a girdle.

rosequartz Mon 03-Mar-14 14:07:58

They make pancakes (crepes style), as you wait, with various fillings, sweet or savoury, at John Lewis restaurant. Very nice, very filling. Cheese and pineapple is my favourite.

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 03-Mar-14 13:57:37

I bought a wooden T shaped thing for spreading the batter for crepes from a kitchen gadget shop just before Christmas. Haven't round to trying it yet. hmm

Chap at the Exeter Xmas market folded them over and actually flippedthem straight into the cardboard holder. Very brave! grin

annodomini Mon 03-Mar-14 13:43:32

I love watching the cooks in a creperie swirling just the right amount of batter on a hotplate and coming up with a perfect crepe. Sorry - I can't do accents, apart from acutes, on this keyboard.

sylvia1231 Mon 03-Mar-14 13:36:14

I've watched the Baker at Ferring Asda making the pancakes. I've bought them, eaten them, and loved them. I stick to the plain variety and eat with sugar and lemon juice. They are thick like 'scotch' pancakes but does it matter? No one HAS to buy them. I will and won't have to fiddle about with the frying pan any more. Ever.
I enquired last time if they would make me some gluten free pancakes but the answer was "Sorry, No"

Gally Mon 03-Mar-14 13:32:27

'Pikelets' are a favourite snack for children in Australia (just thought I'd mention it grin)
I am hopeless at making pancakes so have bought a plastic bottle of ingredients into which you just add water, shake vigorously and use..... I never thought it would come to that!

rockgran Mon 03-Mar-14 13:25:37

I agree with grannyisland. I grew up in England with a Scottish Mum and always thought of "drop scones" as pancakes. We never had the big pancakes "crepes" and I learned to make those when I was an adult. I was brought up in Cheshire and we had barm cakes but my Scottish parents called them rolls. My Yorkshire husband has teacakes or breadcakes, and calls crumpets "pikelets". I think baked goods have the most confusing terminology! Don't get me started on Scottish "half" loaves and American "English muffins". Oh, drat, now I'm hungry!
I will be making proper tossing pancakes tomorrow - with a variety of fillings and toppings. My husband likes jam, I like lemon or golden syrup but we also like them stuffed with ricotta and spinach - not all at the same time of course. cupcake

Granny23 Mon 03-Mar-14 12:45:08

Chef in a small hotel in Ibizia, doing his show cooking, making 'scotch' pancakes on a griddle. He recognised my Scottish accent and asked for my opinion as to their authenticity, which I was pleased to confirm. Then he proudly showed me the bowl of JELLY that he was serving as an accompaniment. Yes! Jelly as in Jelly and Icecream, not Jelly as in jam. I tried to explain but he was too busy laughing at the guests trying to balance melting jelly on hot pancakes grin

rosesarered Mon 03-Mar-14 12:40:55

Galen I meant having cream with mine [golden syrup] not with the DH ones with lemon and brown sugar.

merlotgran Mon 03-Mar-14 12:33:00

Just lemon and sugar. I always too much batter mix. grin

kittylester Mon 03-Mar-14 12:28:57

Marelli I agree re pikelets though they do tend to be called crumpets by people who don't know any better!! grin

I love pancakes with lots of lemon and sugar. DH calls them pancakes but doesn't like them - all the more for me!! grin

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 03-Mar-14 12:28:18

Lemon and sugar here. Delish!!!

Galen Mon 03-Mar-14 12:24:36

Lemon juice, yes! Cream? Don't think so!

rosesarered Mon 03-Mar-14 12:20:37

Hope you will all be making 'true' pancakes tomorrow? Dh likes lemon and sugar but I have always had mine with golden syrup.Rolled up [of course.]They are even better with a pool drizzle of cream. YUM!

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 03-Mar-14 12:19:41

Pikelets are the little thin ones which you toast like crumpets. Scotch pancakes have more of the fattening ingredients. They are all very nice. smile

jinglbellsfrocks Mon 03-Mar-14 12:16:39

grannyisland there were small sweet muffins served in the London hotel we were in a week ago. Strangely enough I managed a blueberry one, on top of my scrambled eggs, sausage and bacon! shock grin

I love it in a French one we go to, where they serve slices of fruitcake. [yum]

rosequartz Mon 03-Mar-14 12:01:33

I can unsuallynspell ok but nit on this tablrt

NanKate Mon 03-Mar-14 11:43:23

When I wrote piklets I thought the spelling looked odd, thanks for showing me they are pikelets ! Hate wrong spelling.

rosequartz Mon 03-Mar-14 09:52:46

Ah yes, pikelets and how could I forget muffins with my Mum' muffin dish sitting on the sideboard!

grannyisland Mon 03-Mar-14 09:36:42

What shocked me was finding sweet (eg chocolate chip, blueberry) muffins served at the buffet breakfast in the US hotels we stayed at. I wondered if the misunderstood the idea of English muffins.

grannyisland Mon 03-Mar-14 09:32:37

They've always been pancakes to everyone I've ever known here in Scotland. I knew as a child that somewhere people called them drop scones as that's what I had to look for in the recipe book! I didn't meet big, flat crepe type until years later.

Nonnie Mon 03-Mar-14 09:29:14

My Father insisted that the only thing which could be labelled 'Scotch' was whisky!

thatbags Mon 03-Mar-14 09:07:01

I grew up in a bilingual household: one parent called crumpets crumpets and one called pikelets pikelets. We just ate 'em (not the parents).

Pancakes are pancakes whatever their size or thickness. Pancake batter. Scone dough. Scotch pancake batter is not dough.

I might bake some barm cakes today.

Marelli Mon 03-Mar-14 09:03:25

Yes they are! Baubles and I agree on that one. Mother-in-law (Ayrshire/Fife) called them that and she was renowned for her delicious pancakes. She beat up a batter of milk, flour and eggs (perhaps baking soda, too?) and flung it a tablespoonful of the mixture on a buttered griddle. I can taste them now...[greedy emoticon]....!
You can still buy pikelets (we used to call them that in Nottingham where I originated from) but as I remember them they were just the same as the crumpets that are sold now. About 3" in diameter and half-an-inch deep?

kittylester Mon 03-Mar-14 07:26:38

My DH calls pikelets 'pifelets' confused