Gransnet forums

Food

Grrrrrr Melons

(55 Posts)
JackK Thu 15-Aug-24 11:54:18

I bought a honeydew melon from Aldi on Tuesday and was anticipating the gloriousness of its juicy interior. I cut it up into bite size pieces and ... aaaaargh, it was hard, unjuicy and inedible for my sensitive mouth. Very disappointed 😞
Yesterday I bought another honeydew melon from Waitrose - once more feeling that anticipation ...
NOOOOOO! this one is exactly the same!
I now have two tupperware containers full of inedible melon, and a) have no idea what to do with them, b) dread my future melon purchases. Any ideas/tips/ripe melons?!

Mojack26 Sat 17-Aug-24 11:35:07

Press the ends and smell the melon. When I lived in US I was told this and generally it's true,if you can press ends in it should be ripe and also you should be able to smell it.

win Sat 17-Aug-24 11:24:32

If you have an airing cupboard leave them in there for a day or two, they do ripen eventually. Same with any fruit in particular Avocado ripen really quickly in there.

cc Sat 17-Aug-24 11:11:18

pascal30

before cutting the melon try pressing the area where the stalk was.. it should be soft.. then smell to see if it smells sweet.. I hope this helps.. I wish someone could give advise on mangoes though..

Personally I don't press fruit, if it isn't ripe it might bruise and go bad at a later stage. I'm lucky to have a good sense of smell and usually just sniff them, though this doesn't work with all types such as water melons.
I've just about given up on mangoes, you don't get much of a smell at all and even those that do smell good are often stringy inside. We usually buy them prepared in chunks or slices, though even then you can't always tell, other than that ripe mangoes tend to be a deeper colour. By the time you've peeled and stoned a mango you probably don't pay that much less per 100g compared to the packs.

Ailsa43 Sat 17-Aug-24 01:45:43

Not just supermarkets. I bought a 1/2 watermelon from a greengrocers in London a few days ago... I was really disappointed because t was hard as rock and no flavour whatsoever . I left it soaking in a little water in the fridge for a couple of days, it didn't change the texture or taste

Scribbles Fri 16-Aug-24 22:31:29

Enjoy your new melons!

JackK Fri 16-Aug-24 19:02:56

Thanks everyone, update:
I took the tupperware containers to Aldi and they gave me a replacement (which I analysed thoroughly - in the way that Pascal 30 advised ...
Then I took the other tupperware to Waitrose, and not only did they replace it - they gave me a full refund too!

pascal30 Fri 16-Aug-24 16:24:55

before cutting the melon try pressing the area where the stalk was.. it should be soft.. then smell to see if it smells sweet.. I hope this helps.. I wish someone could give advise on mangoes though..

MissAdventure Fri 16-Aug-24 14:19:02

I've just thrown the unripe melon.

Fed up with moving it from place to place, and it took up most of the fridge.

Patsy70 Fri 16-Aug-24 13:55:12

You could add more fruit and make a smoothie? I’ve really enjoyed making these for our grandsons who been with us this week.
I have the same problem with avocados, when they’re described as ‘ready to eat’.

Jaxjacky Fri 16-Aug-24 13:20:23

Probably imported, then kept in chillers to slow ripening, it’s sometimes a problem with food that’s had a lot of travel.

Marmin Fri 16-Aug-24 12:29:46

The French weigh melons in their hand to find the heaviest. Most in this country are picked too early and will never reach the stage of ripeness found in warmer climes.

JackK Thu 15-Aug-24 20:04:54

*puts Bananas on the shopping list
* leaves one tupperware container of unripened melon on the worktop for 4-5 days
*will take the Waitrose melon back tomorrow
Thanks everyone ☺️

MissAdventure Thu 15-Aug-24 18:32:48

Oh yes.
Good thinking, thanks. smile

PamelaJ1 Thu 15-Aug-24 18:18:35

Could you put them in with a banana, that should speed up the ripening process.

MissAdventure Thu 15-Aug-24 18:10:39

I bought a different looking melon from Lidl a while back, and am still waiting for it to ripen enough to be able to eat it.
£1.99 it cost me, too.

eddiecat78 Thu 15-Aug-24 18:01:43

I buy "perfectly ripe" kiwi fruit from Tesco - they usually aren't

BlueBelle Thu 15-Aug-24 17:45:08

Well maybe 4/5 days 🤣🤣🤣

Primrose53 Thu 15-Aug-24 17:33:11

BlueBelle

Leave them a day or two they ll soften

I wish! They don’t even though Our house is warm and sunny.

BlueBelle Thu 15-Aug-24 17:31:57

Leave them a day or two they ll soften

Primrose53 Thu 15-Aug-24 17:27:42

Same not seem

Primrose53 Thu 15-Aug-24 17:27:25

I hate this too. Sometimes mangoes are the seem, even those that say “ripe and ready to eat”. Very disappointing.

1summer Thu 15-Aug-24 16:08:35

I recently bought a piel de sapo melon from Sainsburys only because it was on offer. It is absolutely delicious.

ferry23 Thu 15-Aug-24 15:55:02

I would actually contact both and tell them. It may be a problem with the supplier (and it may well be the same one, surprisingly!) - it's only by getting feedback from the customer that they can identify a problem.

It's difficult with fresh goods that you can't see inside, so even though they probably randomly sample, the more negative feedback they get the more likely they will be to deal with it.

OnwardandUpward Thu 15-Aug-24 12:13:43

Haha I like watermelons best! grin but I like them to be perfect!!

JackK Thu 15-Aug-24 12:09:15

Onward and upward, I wish there was a melon-swapping service 😄