Gransnet forums

Food

What Classic American Comfort Food Do You Wish Was Easier to Find Here?

(107 Posts)
Mrbenjamin Tue 09-Dec-25 15:47:13

I've been on a bit of a mission lately trying to recreate some of the classic American dishes I grew up loving, but I’ve found that some ingredients or even the exact methods just aren't common here in the UK (or wherever the majority of Gransnet users are).

I'm thinking of things like perfect, fluffy biscuits and gravy, real slow-cooked barbecue pulled pork, or a proper Chicago deep-dish pizza.

What American comfort food do you adore, but struggle to find or make correctly? And does anyone have any secret tips or recipes for getting that authentic American flavour using ingredients available here? I'd love to hear your experiences!

glammagran Wed 10-Dec-25 11:11:53

Hershey’s “chocolate” - an absolute abomination and smells of sick.

Grantanow Wed 10-Dec-25 11:16:35

I enjoyed pancakes with maple syrup in the US as a treat but I wouldn't make them a breakfast staple now - far too much sugar.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 10-Dec-25 11:21:20

I always think the southern seafood sounds pretty good.

Sueinkent Wed 10-Dec-25 13:41:41

Burritos.

orly Wed 10-Dec-25 13:55:04

JamesandJon33

We don ‘t eat biscuits and gravy. Biscuits are sweet and go with a cup of tea. Perhaps that is why you are having difficulty .

...."back home we call biscuits "crackers" and jam "jelly" so stick that in your "fanny pack"

.... divided by a common language as they say

Shel1951 Wed 10-Dec-25 14:07:49

Only difference is some additives available in the USA are banned in Ireland and the UK.
That would make a difference in taste

Gfplux Wed 10-Dec-25 14:19:36

Neve ever and none. America is now our enemy

Bazza Wed 10-Dec-25 14:55:01

The first time we went to Florida in the late seventies and stayed with my aunt who had a holiday home there, we couldn’t believe that any bread we bought from supermarkets contained huge amounts of sugar, and eating out if you didn’t want anything deep fried you were unlucky. We were all desperate for some fresh vegetables and fruit when eating out. Maybe things have changed now, but we’ve certainly inherited the obesity now which at the time wasn’t often seen in the uk.

Bestgrammaever Wed 10-Dec-25 14:56:09

The problem is the terminology. What are biscuits in the UK are cookies in the US. The Betty Crocker online cookbooks will have recipes for baking powder biscuits. And the gravy is simply made with sausage and milk added to the roux.

Slow cooked pulled pork you make in a slow cooker/crockpot. Make your own sauce.

Colls Wed 10-Dec-25 14:57:20

Gfplux

Neve ever and none. America is now our enemy

Very true, sadly.

Witzend Wed 10-Dec-25 15:04:04

I’ve never tried American ‘biscuits’. The only thing I can think of is clam chowder, but a couple of those on our last visit weren’t the best I’ve ever had, Visits are mostly to Cape Cod, New England, where CC is very much a Thing.

Witzend Wed 10-Dec-25 15:05:30

Cabbie21

I have a bottle of maple syrup if anyone wants one?
It’s about six years old, unopened, came in a Christmas hamper.

Maple syrup is lovely with pancakes!

BlessedArt Wed 10-Dec-25 15:08:02

Smileless2012

I miss American pancakes with maple syrup and their milk shakes.

Ditto.

I also miss American barbecue. It’s unmatched.

FranP Wed 10-Dec-25 15:24:17

JamesandJon33

We don ‘t eat biscuits and gravy. Biscuits are sweet and go with a cup of tea. Perhaps that is why you are having difficulty .

Their biscuits are not like ours, they call ours cookies and biscuits are more like a dry savoury UK scone.

As for gravy they make what goes with this with milk!

knspol Wed 10-Dec-25 15:25:57

Having lived in the US I don't miss any of their food at all, when I did live there I missed quite a few UK foods.

4allweknow Wed 10-Dec-25 15:26:17

Mollynew Don't know about Lidl having English ingredients, I do know ingredients from all over the UK indeed the world are available in Lidl stores near me. If OP is directed to only English ingredients, she may
struggle.

FranP Wed 10-Dec-25 15:28:19

We now have a Wendy's and I do love their US food, but the portions are HUGE! I can eat for England, but their breakfast baconator was enough for 3

BlessedArt Wed 10-Dec-25 15:29:35

Biscuits in the US are called cookies.

A US biscuit is a type of bread.

graciemabel Wed 10-Dec-25 15:38:18

I find it hard to get Monterey Jack cheese here, also clam chowder. I had it in Monterey California and in New Zealand, amazing!!! oooh and proper sourdough bread.

WithNobsOnIt Wed 10-Dec-25 15:41:57

welbeck

Maybe our bland British food lacks that unique residue of cattle growth hormone ?

Indeed. You tell em wellbeck.

Allira Wed 10-Dec-25 16:29:16

BlessedArt

Smileless2012

I miss American pancakes with maple syrup and their milk shakes.

Ditto.

I also miss American barbecue. It’s unmatched.

What would constitute an American barbecue?

How does it differ from a British barbecue, or an Australian one?

Norah Wed 10-Dec-25 16:58:24

BlessedArt

Smileless2012

I miss American pancakes with maple syrup and their milk shakes.

Ditto.

I also miss American barbecue. It’s unmatched.

We're vegan for several years, but I miss pulled pork barbecue.

We do cook it and the delicious Memphis sauce for our family.

silverlining48 Wed 10-Dec-25 17:14:08

My one experience of USA was 5 days in NY celebrating a special birthday, and nothing I ate was particularly memorable. It all seemed steeped in far too much sugar, even the savoury things. I was desperate for fruit and fresh veg when we got back.

Chaitriona Wed 10-Dec-25 17:20:40

About sixty years ago I was in Montreal and New York living with American people and the food was amazing to me. But I only really knew Scottish food which was very traditional at the time. The steaks. The corn on the cob. The quality of what they could grow in Canada was amazing. I ate a lot of things for the first time. Not southern American cooking. But Jewish, Chinese, French, I realized how much wealth and diversity there was in America. Of course I didn't come from a rich family in Scotland.

Dearknees1 Wed 10-Dec-25 17:31:36

I’m not a fan of American food. I remember ordering a grilled cheese sandwich which came dusted with icing sugar. Also brown gravy with everything including salmon.