Gransnet forums

Food

What Classic American Comfort Food Do You Wish Was Easier to Find Here?

(107 Posts)
Mrbenjamin Tue 09-Dec-25 15:47:13

I've been on a bit of a mission lately trying to recreate some of the classic American dishes I grew up loving, but I’ve found that some ingredients or even the exact methods just aren't common here in the UK (or wherever the majority of Gransnet users are).

I'm thinking of things like perfect, fluffy biscuits and gravy, real slow-cooked barbecue pulled pork, or a proper Chicago deep-dish pizza.

What American comfort food do you adore, but struggle to find or make correctly? And does anyone have any secret tips or recipes for getting that authentic American flavour using ingredients available here? I'd love to hear your experiences!

Jaycee19 Wed 10-Dec-25 17:34:10

On my arrival in America my grandson ran up to me, gave me a big hug and asked if I could make golden syrup suet pudding for him. When he was last visiting me in England he loved it. My daughter couldn't find the main ingredients in the local supermarkets and to buy online was extortionate. Each country has its special dishes.

Allira Wed 10-Dec-25 17:35:36

My mother used to make that, Jaycee, light and delicious!

Now I fancy those American pancakes 😀

AskAlice Wed 10-Dec-25 17:36:07

My American friend tells me that the gravy that they always had with biscuits was made with the fat from cooked bacon, thickened with flour and then they added milk. Never tried it, but I might have a go now, just to see what it tastes like!

Allira Wed 10-Dec-25 17:45:41

So it's what we might call white sauce, but made with bacon fat instead of butter.

lazydays Wed 10-Dec-25 18:05:49

CrazyH
The steak is cooked leftover barbecued steak from the night before and sliced thinly like bacon then fried with a fried egg
I went on a horseback trek in the rockies.
Myself and a friend we had a wrangler who looked after our horses and the pack horses and erecting the tents etc.
We also had a cook and the first morning he asked if we wanted the leftover steak or did we want the wrangler to have it, being 2 women we just thought no thanks we don’t want steak for breakfast.
Anyway when it was cooked it was lovely like beef bacon!
We envisaged 2 steaks on a plate!

tattygran14 Wed 10-Dec-25 18:10:00

We went to a diner, biscuits and gravy were labelled as that but were scones and soup. Quite disappointing, as I’d often wondered what they were.

David49 Wed 10-Dec-25 18:25:38

In San Francisco last year we did find a traditional Diner that did serve decent food, they do exist, a big improvement on the trash disguised as fast food.

Very hard to find in the U.K.

Dreadwitch Wed 10-Dec-25 18:51:23

Well we don't eat biscuits with sauce so you'll never find the right ingredients I doubt. There's no Chicago either so there's no pizzas. And any slow cooker can make pulled pork that's nothing special lol

Mojack26 Wed 10-Dec-25 19:28:35

I lived in US for 2 years. Still miss Sloppy Joes,not same making them here...still miss DQ and my chocolate fudge sundae

PaperMonster2 Wed 10-Dec-25 20:13:29

Deep fried breadcrumbed green beans. Pecan pancakes. The best tuna I’ve ever tasted, hash brown casserole.

Magenta8 Wed 10-Dec-25 20:18:21

It's a drink rather than food, root beer. McDonalds used to sell it a long time ago. It tastes like fizzy cough linctus - delicious.

JPB123 Wed 10-Dec-25 20:24:12

Cajun food ,I would love to eat in New Orleans.

keepingquiet Wed 10-Dec-25 20:33:22

I have nothing to add but haven't had Key Lime Pie for ages and I miss it...could really eat a slice right now!

NotSpaghetti Wed 10-Dec-25 21:04:04

Magenta8 this is pretty good.
Bought at Sainsbury's

mokryna Wed 10-Dec-25 22:00:58

I remember being served a sort of semi savory thick biscuit, with my meat dish.
Don’t forget the Americans have marshmallows with their turkey. Each country to their own traditions.

Allira Wed 10-Dec-25 23:11:39

NotSpaghetti

Magenta8 this is pretty good.
Bought at Sainsbury's

Thst's Australian gold, my friend!
There's Bundaberg rum, too, if you want something stronger.

Spinnaker Wed 10-Dec-25 23:25:36

And let's not forget Bundaberg Ginger Beer too - it's beaut !

NotSpaghetti Thu 11-Dec-25 06:30:23

Yes. My grandson likes the ginger beer in particular. 👍

Chocolatelovinggran Thu 11-Dec-25 08:22:54

Re barbecues ( which might have originated in South Africa?): my Floridian friends were firm on the difference between a barbecue and a cook out .
No, I never understood it.

fluff Thu 11-Dec-25 10:48:40

I make pulled pork every Christmas, it’s the easiest thing to make.

fluff Thu 11-Dec-25 10:50:50

Some of the steakhouses have amazing steak, and cheesecake from the cheesecake factory if I’m being unhealthy, but I can get that from Costco anyway.

David49 Thu 11-Dec-25 11:36:23

fluff

Some of the steakhouses have amazing steak, and cheesecake from the cheesecake factory if I’m being unhealthy, but I can get that from Costco anyway.

Steak is very expensive often $40+ tax+tip. If you pay by card the tip options are 15, 20, 25%.
Maybe it’s the value of sterling but it seemed so much more affordable 20 yrs ago.

imaround Thu 11-Dec-25 18:21:21

Here is the scoop on American BBQ. Sorry. It isn't the same as English BBQ.

www.munchery.com/blog/american-bbq-a-history-regional-styles-12-recipes/

Allira Thu 11-Dec-25 18:36:16

Quite different!

imaround Thu 11-Dec-25 19:16:57

Here is the very simple sausage gravy recipe for biscuits and gravy.

I think I saw she had a homemade biscuit recipe linked.

Use butter rather than bacon fat. I also drain off some of the pork fat when making the roux.

The gravy is best, IMO, with black pepper and salt as seasoning. A good pork breakfast sausage has enough seasoning in it.

sugarspunrun.com/sausage-gravy/