Gransnet forums

Gardening

Magpies!

(6 Posts)
Sbagran Sat 31-Dec-11 16:57:02

Not sure if the gardening forum is the best place to ask this but the question didn't seem to fit into any other subject!

Does anyone know of any plant or other thing that will deter magpies from our garden that will not put off all the other little birds?

Don't get me wrong - I love magpies - they are beautiful creatures and I don't wish them any harm, but we are trying to encourage the smaller birds to our bird tables and feeders. We have seen bluetits, robins, sparrows, wagtails etc but the magpies scare them off.

Any ideas gratefully received.

Happy New Year Everyone!!! wine wine wine

bagitha Sat 31-Dec-11 17:27:13

In my last garden I used a "ground guard" to protect small birds from larger ones. It's like a cage that sits on the ground. The little birds can get in but the big ones can't.

www.birdfood.co.uk/product_details.php?area_id=2&group_id=18&nav_id=172&prd_id=1038

Now I use it to protect my parsley from rabbits and deer.

JessM Sat 31-Dec-11 17:52:31

Lets face it, the magpies eat their eggs and nestlings so why wouldn't they scare them off.
My DH is keen feeder of birds. The general mixed seed bird feeder is in front of the house (feeders are I should say)
There we get a wide variety including magpies, crows, woodpigeons, pigeons, collared doves, starlings, greenfiches, wagtails, and lots of goldfinches etc etc, some of which clean up the ground (thanks guys). In the back garden only nyjer seed and peanut feeders and only sparrows, bluetits starlings and goldfinches - but the bigger birds rarely visit. I think they nip to the pond to have a drink maybe in dry weather. Best birds are spotted woodpeckers on the peanut feeders and the occasional sparrowhawk, which is welcome to scare anyone any day of the week in my book.

jingl Sat 31-Dec-11 18:27:33

Bagitha, that is such a good idea! Have ordered a mesh guard and a ground feeding table.

One fat pigeon can clear our bid table in half a minute flat!

Thank you. smile

crimson Sat 31-Dec-11 18:49:51

I'm sure a friend of mine had a bowl of seed on the ground with a sheet of glass over it; I couldn't believe that the small birds would go into such a claustrophobic place, but they did.

Sbagran Sun 01-Jan-12 09:00:10

Thanks folks for the suggestions so far - I have just watched two magpies at our bird table which is the type with a little roof over !!! We have lived here since August and have had the magpies plus the other birds around the whole time so perhaps they just tolerate each other but I know magpies steal the eggs and young so will persevere! The cage looks like a brilliant idea - thanks again
smile Happy new year to you all smile