Gransnet forums

Gardening

Blessed thistles

(7 Posts)
Luckygirl3 Mon 27-May-24 17:34:09

I have resown my wild flower area, which has been beautiful for the last 3 years, and lots of germination has taken place. But ...... it is full of thistles, which have grown much more than the little newly germinated seedlings.

I think the only thing I can do it to trample all over the little seedlings and weed out the thistles or they will take over completely.

Any other ideas?

The field behind me is full of thistles, so I assume that they have a 2 year cycle and are now sprouting up!

Septimia Mon 27-May-24 18:07:01

I was told that if you cut thistles off so that the base of the hollow stem is exposed the rain will get in and rot the roots etc. Easier than trying to pull them up.

Baggs Mon 27-May-24 18:12:36

Septimia

I was told that if you cut thistles off so that the base of the hollow stem is exposed the rain will get in and rot the roots etc. Easier than trying to pull them up.

It rains a lot where I live. You have to dig thistles out of you want rid of them. Chopping them down to the ground is only temporary. They resprout with ever more vigour. At least, marsh thistles do.

They are hell to dig out so get them out while they're small, Lucky.

Luckygirl3 Mon 27-May-24 18:26:59

I have a brilliant weeding tool which has 2 prongs that goes into the ground either side of the weed and you rotate it and pull it up with the weed in. It has a plunger that you use to eject the weed into a bucket ... even I can use it!

madeleine45 Mon 27-May-24 18:47:18

I dont know if you try to garden totally organically but you could try putting on a glove and put weedkiller on it and the reach the thistle and rub that but not your seedlings. But sounds as though with thistles next door you will always get some in your meadow and then it is keeping an eagle eye so that you can get them up quickly before they grow much.I would not put any weedkiller on in any other way. Cutting them down as soon as you see them will at least weaken them and enable your plants to grow a bit more

Gwyllt Mon 27-May-24 18:58:51

Something in the back of my mind says farmers used to cut thistles in the meadow during July for best control presumably before they set seed

Callistemon21 Mon 27-May-24 19:59:20

Don't bother trying the white vinegar and salt method either.

Thistles and some other weeds are resistant.

I decided that part of our lawn should be a wildflower meadow but it got taken over by yellow flowers which someone said were ragwort 😯 so it's lawn again now.