Gransnet forums

Gardening

Are there ANY good multi purpose composts?

(55 Posts)
karmalady Sun 13-Apr-25 09:43:17

I am so peeved, yet again I opened a new bag of westland multi purpose with john innes. It is blooming rubbish. I have potted on some brassicas today, had to use that. Twigs, sticks, leaves and goodness knows what else in the lumps

The only answer might be to sow seeds later, pot on once and quickly put in the ground

I am about to re-sow my squash, they came up, then I potted on and now they are yellow

Plus that compost dries out in the blink of an eye

Westland seed compost is just about ok

buffyfly9 Mon 14-Apr-25 08:59:13

We buy Clover from our local garden centre. Use it for every thing, seed sowing, potting on, garden planters etc. Has peat in it (from a sustainable source ) and it is excellent stuff.

Polly99 Mon 14-Apr-25 09:20:02

BlueBelle could you order compost to be delivered from a garden centre?. That's what a friend does as they are unable to drive now.

merlotgran Mon 14-Apr-25 09:24:26

I buy my compost from Amazon. I have Prime so next day delivery is free. I have a sack barrow so once it’s been dropped off I can easily transport it to my shed.

Churchview Mon 14-Apr-25 09:24:37

BlueBelle Our allotment site has a notice board which usually has a poster up advertising a local woman who delivers compost, bark chippings, top soil etc. Could you perhaps stroll past your local allotment and see if you have similar?

BlueBelle Mon 14-Apr-25 14:04:15

I should have added my bags are John Innes which used to be a good nance in the gardening world
Yesterday I opened a packet of Thomason and Morgan lobelia seeds and it was completely empty not a thing in the little silver pouch inside the packet I know lobelia are tiny like dust almost but it was totally empty but how can I prove that !!!

BlueBelle Mon 14-Apr-25 14:21:43

ChurchviewI have an a.llotnent 🤣🤣no one delivers compost though

Liz46 Mon 14-Apr-25 14:22:52

Many years ago I bought a streptacarpus Laura from Dibleys at the Southport Flower Show. Every spring I would carefully put it in fresh compost and luckily got some more plants by doing a leaf cutting. After the usual repotting last Spring, the (peat free) compost went mouldy and my plants died.
I had given one of the plants from my leaf cutting to a friend so she was able to help me out. I told my tale of woe to the owner of a local nursery and he sold me some compost which contains peat. The plants don't look anywhere near as good as they used to but I am treating them well and hope for the best. I love that plant.

BlueBelle Mon 14-Apr-25 14:24:28

polly99 looks like that’s what ll I have to do in future shame though

25Avalon Mon 14-Apr-25 17:23:11

Try Jamieson Brothers multi purpose compost which contains peat. Sliding scale of charges starting at £7.46 for a 60L bag plus delivery.
There’s also McCann’s compost containing Irish peat ( they are an Irish company) which if you google you may find near you. £60 for 10 x 60L bags. Holm’s have it if you are near Winchester or will deliver within a 30 mile radius.

Ohmother Mon 14-Apr-25 23:23:55

I was repotting a tree and was advised to mix some garden soil with the compost as the peat free stuff does not retain the water as well.

Leavesden Tue 15-Apr-25 13:56:33

I agree most composts now are just a mix of straw, twigs and dust. It dries out so quickly.

Shirls52000 Tue 15-Apr-25 13:59:46

I order my compost and top soil from Wickes, they deliver and horticultural grit from Amazon

kibera10 Tue 15-Apr-25 14:10:40

I use 'Clover' multi purpose compost and have been using it for years and in my view its the best available. It does contain peat. I have tried a number of peat free composts, but haven't yet found one which gives me good results. I run our allotment trading shed and currently I can get Clover compost from our wholesaler. For seed sowing I add vermiculite to the compost. With peat free composts you need to starting using plant feed after about 5 weeks.

chicken Tue 15-Apr-25 14:15:08

For seed sowing, I bought some John Innes seed compost from Amazon this year. Not cheap, but it was really good quality and the germination rates have been excellent. Potting compost now is not a patch on what it used to be. I mix two parts multipurpose compost with one part each of John Innes no. 2 and manure plus a bit of fish, blood and bone fertiliser. This doesn't dry out too quickly and gives good results. I speak as an ex nurserywoman.

Norah Tue 15-Apr-25 14:16:23

I use big bags of Miracle-Gro Peat Free Premium Moisture Control Compost. It doesn't dry out very fast, drains well.

Jaxjacky Tue 15-Apr-25 14:25:47

Thank you 25Avalon

Whitewavemark2 Tue 15-Apr-25 14:33:52

Can I just gently say that there is no such thing as a sustainable source of peat.

Once it has gone - that is it.

Just about to renew our herb bed as it has got totally out of control.

So just purchased a bag of Sylvagrow + bag JI3 - will mix it with grit and garden compost.

J52 Tue 15-Apr-25 14:41:54

If it’s of any interest, Wickes has 50L bags of compost for £4 instead of £6.50. The offer is on until April 22nd.
I don’t know how good it is, but we’ve just bought some to top up the raised beds.

JPB123 Tue 15-Apr-25 15:39:23

Jack’s Magic I think is great.

Greyduster Tue 15-Apr-25 15:53:57

I’d used Jacks Magic for years until last year when I was really disappointed with how horrible the peat free stuff was. I ended up sieving it to get anything fine enough for potting on small seedlings, or rooting cuttings. Levington with John Innes used to be pretty good but I’ve not used the peat free stuff.

mabon1 Tue 15-Apr-25 16:27:17

All m seeds have come on a treat with seed and potting compost, any brand does the job for me.

25Avalon Tue 15-Apr-25 16:30:50

Sphagnum peat moss is renewable.

karmalady Tue 15-Apr-25 16:34:57

sylvagrow is not available locally, they are having a lot of trouble sourcing any compost.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 15-Apr-25 16:38:06

25Avalon

Sphagnum peat moss is renewable.

I stand corrected😊

BlueBelle Tue 15-Apr-25 16:53:04

Greyduster John Innes has gone the same way I ve bought three bags and it’s awful full of bits of wood and everything else got little flies and tiny toadstools coming up in every seed tray I ve used it in