Gransnet forums

Gardening

I’m so sick of our flowering cherry tree!

(92 Posts)
Witzend Sun 20-Apr-25 10:53:27

Pretty for maybe a week, with a mountain of pink ‘snow’ to clear up afterwards. Actually IMO they should be called ‘No-cherries’ trees - what is the point of all that blossom with no fruit to follow?

We didn’t plant it , it was there when we bought the house decades ago and is now really too big. (And protected, so we can’t have it felled.).
Personally I’d much prefer a tree that produces fruit, apple blossom is IMO much prettier anyway - or even ‘real’ cherry blossom.
I dare say I will be seen as VVU but I now see flowering cherries as overdressed and blowsy!

MayBee70 Sun 20-Apr-25 15:06:40

There always seems to be a spell of windy weather when the cherry trees are covered in blossom.

madeleine45 Sun 20-Apr-25 15:29:35

It is very sad to see people only looking at what they see is a problem and not enjoying the fleeting beauty which is there. The pleasure and joy of seasonal things seem to be brushed aside for the ability to have things all year round. So strawberries at christmas etc. Seasonality allows us to look forward and savour something. As you say things like the beautiful Magnolia are here for a short time and here in the north it shows a positive attitude to have one as the frost can often kill them and camellias too which is a shame. Yet still the gardeners plant with hope and are blessed with the beauty when it works. As said by others it also provides early nectar and food for the bees.

Did people not look about at their neighbours when they moved house? As I have moved 19 times , checking what was around me was important, and looking at gardens also showed me what I might be able to grow there myself. My only suggestions for Witzend are these.
1. you could have 2 large pots and plant in a clematis in each. One early alpina and a late viticella. By putting them in pots you will be able to feed them and water them so that the tree wont take up all the nutrients. Then wind the clematis round the branches of the tree and the early one will flower and then have lovely seedheads which will show with the later clematis.
2. Choose a different area of the garden and grow something special there so that you can look at that and turn your chair to ignore the petals etc from the cherry tree. Perhaps have some pots near the window , with eyecatching plants to take your attention from the cherry tree.
3. If it is going to really annoy you every year might you think about moving? I am not being facetious, but just depending on your life at the moment, you might be changing jobs or retiring or whatever, and it might be something that could be a consideration for future homes.

My only other suggestion is that you might choose to take a holiday at this time and that way you will not be there to see all the petals, and they dont last long do they?

MayBee70 Sun 20-Apr-25 17:06:01

When I moved into my house 50 years ago, as someone in my twenties I gave no thought to what it would be like being surrounded by trees ( which have also had fifty more years of growing since then). And I never thought of the old arthritic me having to constantly clear up slip hazards etc from my garden. My partners house ( also my son and daughters houses) aren’t surrounded by trees and are so much easier to keep clean. And they can grow flowers in their gardens, too. I do try to not clear away the leaves and pine needles/cones etc because of the insects that live in them but it looks very messy. My neighbour, who is even older and more fragile than me, has a driveway covered in slippy moss that worries me for her sake. It seems to have become much worse in recent years with the wet weather we now seem to have.

woodenspoon Sun 20-Apr-25 17:30:26

I love flowering cherry trees. We have a very pretty one in our front garden, not huge, full of blossom. It’s so lovely. We have discovered another one buried under laurels which has been cut back when they were pruned. Now, it’s full of red shoots and I’m hoping it will recover and flower for us.

Visgir1 Sun 20-Apr-25 17:42:21

My DD has one on her Front garden, planted by previous owners. It's probably as old as her (30's). Every year or two they get out the long big puners and give it a good hair cut. The tree stays compact, looks good with limited mess especially over the cars.
Christmas time it's festooned in lights.

Franski Sun 20-Apr-25 17:43:10

Witzend.
You are perfectly entitled to your opinion. Personally i love cherry blossom. I remember an overcast cold April day in central London. People heads down, wearing grey and black, walking along and then a gust of wind blew a cloud of pink petals across the road like confetti. It was such a spontaneous act of grace that i have loved them even more since that day.

karmalady Sun 20-Apr-25 17:56:28

My 4 apple trees are in full flower and absolutely stunning right now, very beautiful. I am going to have a very good crop, will be able to give a lot away as well as preserve for all of winter. Two of the varieties will keep until february in my garage. I like to see cherry trees but on a roadside verge will do me

Carlotta Sun 20-Apr-25 18:00:07

Am I missing something? Why does the petal blossom need to be swept or picked up? From what I've seen, the fallen blossom looks like a lovely pink carpet? Why does it need physically removing rather than just letting nature take its course? Is it poisonous or dangerous to animals or something?

pascal30 Sun 20-Apr-25 19:08:01

We had one when we were children.. it was great for climbing..

do you have GC?

Oldnproud Sun 20-Apr-25 19:14:53

Witzend

Sorry, but I’d still prefer almost any real fruit tree, perhaps especially an apple. But I know so many will disagree!

I'm with you there. The blossom is there for such a short time that it feels like a waste of precious garden space if that is all they have to offer.
Give me a fruit tree that will also provide fruit every time.

My plum tree blossom has been lovely, and the fruit it produces, while unpredictable in quantity, is always delicious.

Right now, my two little apple trees are covered in blossom.
However, so far in the time I have had them they have not lived up to expectation fruit-wise, but I live in hope and will give them a couple more years to get their act together.

Things in my garden have to prove their worth if they are to be granted permanent residence!

Syracute Sun 20-Apr-25 19:26:42

I LOVE my cherry blossoms and making jam from them . I have a white one and a wild cherry pink one .

Coconutty Sun 20-Apr-25 19:35:02

I love them, we never sweep up. The blossom looks like confetti

Carlotta Sun 20-Apr-25 20:00:17

Thank goodness for that Coconutty, I'm glad to hear it.

Churchview Sun 20-Apr-25 20:35:13

To me the fleeting nature of blossom is its joy. If it was here all year we would take no notice of it. These few short weeks of glorious blossom against a blue sky stay are one of my great pleasures.

I live in a cottage named after the massive tree in the garden. It's taken a long while to work out which plants will thrive under it, it makes shade and mess but my goodnes, the wildlife that live on and around the tree, its blossom, fruits and fallen leaves bring my garden to life every day of the year.

Usedtobeblonde Sun 20-Apr-25 20:37:45

I can forgive the mess of petals for the glorious picture of the trees in full blossom, a magnificent and heartwarming sight.
I look forward to it each spring.

Georgesgran Sun 20-Apr-25 20:39:08

The blossom looks like confetti, Carlotta until it gets wet, goes rotten, sticks to your shoes and gets trailed into the house.

As for kerb appeal to passers-by, we live in a very small cul-de-sac, without footpaths and with open plan front gardens, so no through traffic.
The ‘offending’ tree on my neighbour’s front lawn was planted just after we moved in to the then new build development, but it’s never been properly pruned, other than an odd twig taken off.

It’s just as well we’re all different, isn’t it.

CanadianGran Sun 20-Apr-25 20:54:21

We had a controversy in our town with flowering cherry trees. They were on a boulevard next to a parking lot of a government building. The workers I guess were complaining about the blossoms landing and sticking to their vehicles so a decision was made to take down the trees.

While it was happening, several people noticed and stopped the workers. It turns out that the trees were donated by Japanese citizen born in our town, but interred in a camp at the age of 13 with his family during the war. The Japanese were not allowed to re-settle within 100 miles of the coast after the war, so his family settled in Edmonton. He had fond memories of our town, so in 1959 donated 500 cherry trees to the city.

Three of the seven trees by the parking lot had already been removed before the workers were stopped, but the others were saved.

By publicizing the story, more citizens are now aware of the story behind the cherry trees in our town. I think of Japanese Canadians and all they suffered whenever they are blooming.

www.thenorthernview.com/community/the-legacy-of-prince-ruperts-cherry-trees-5951839

foxie48 Sun 20-Apr-25 21:17:24

I've got two cherry trees, two magnolia, a lilac and forsythia in flower on the drive ATM. They are stunning, particularly good this year. On Monday we saw that a branch had come off one of the cherries, so OH brought some indoors. Almost a week later the blossom is still fresh and the leaves have opened up. It's magnificent I had no idea that it would be so long lasting as a cut flower!

valdavi Sun 20-Apr-25 23:08:56

I love them too & agree that the fleeting nature of blossom is part of it's beauty. They're also an attractive trees with a nice shapes all year round.Tai Haku are my favourite but all lovely.

I have 2 copper beech on our boundary, the largest probably 70' tall.You have to be aware what will grow under them, & a bit of watering is essential when newly planted, but I can grow peonies, spring bulbs, & smaller trees like acers & trimmed yew under them.They are lovely in leaf, glorious in the autumn & lovely for sitting in the shade on a hot day. Yes they're messy, but I'm not a tidy gardener & take shoes off when I come in.

crazyH Sun 20-Apr-25 23:25:44

The house opposite has the most gorgeous Japanese Crab- apple blossom tree - he tells me that’s what its called but he has to move his car away because the falling blossoms stick to his car

NotSpaghetti Mon 21-Apr-25 06:36:33

Franski that's exactly how I feel about the tumbling petals blown in a spring breeze!
😍

David49 Mon 21-Apr-25 07:24:06

Our Cherry trees do produce fruit, the birds love then but spread the seeds which is a pain because we get seedlings popping up everywhere.

If the OP doesn’t like her Cherry cut it down and plant something else

flappergirl Mon 21-Apr-25 10:30:19

Agree with Carlotta and Coconutty, why on earth would anyone sweep up blossom?

vegansrock Mon 21-Apr-25 10:32:21

It’s a shame that people hate trees because it makes their car a bit dirty for a couple of weeks a year. I can understand if it’s threatening your house foundations or spoils the whole of your garden but we need to balance a bit of inconvenience with the need to conserve somethings in our nature depleted country.

TheWeirdoAgain1 Mon 21-Apr-25 10:38:43

If I had a garden I'd love that gorgeous tree in there!

Don't kill it, it's been there a lot longer that you have!