Gransnet forums

Grandparenting

Only children

(84 Posts)
Overthemoon Thu 26-Oct-23 18:08:27

I'm an "only" and there are pros and cons. My eldest daughter has one child and is in her late 30s, they seem to have decided to just have the one. I'm very fortunate to have one grandchild, but feel sad they may not have any more, what do other grans think?

Greyduster Sun 29-Oct-23 16:56:52

I wasn’t an only child, but by the time I came along, I had an adult brother and two married sisters, so it felt as if I was! I had a cousin who was six months older than me and we were always close growing up , but he lives in Ireland now so I don’t see him. We are in touch fairly regularly. My grandson is an only and his only two cousins are older than he is, so he has very little contact with them now. It hasn’t seemed to bother him, not having siblings but I think it would have been good for him.

Sleepygran Sun 29-Oct-23 16:46:38

I had siblings. 2 of them.One on another continent,and another in the uk who didn’t get on with our parents.
There was no support from them when our parents died,or at any other major life event.Those who wish they had siblings wouldn’t want mine!
Families and siblings don’t always support each other,count yourself the lucky ones if you’re do!

cc Sun 29-Oct-23 16:31:30

I would love to have been an "only" and have never got on with my sibling, we're just chalk and cheese. I imagine she feels the same.
It's pretty hard work having just one child I should think, nobody to play with if you're at home.
I had four who fought in pairs!

priestbridge Sun 29-Oct-23 13:27:44

I am an only child. I am 72 now. It didn’t bother me when I was a child.
How I have wished over the last 20 yrs I had had a sibling to share the decisions and ask for advice.

Kandinsky Sun 29-Oct-23 13:19:03

I’m one of 4.
I wish I’d been an only child.
My mother was always stressed & money was tight. I often felt like a massive inconvenience.
She’d have coped much better with less children & I might have felt loved & valued. ( I never felt either of those things )
I see my siblings occasionally, but see my friends more & have a better relationship with them. So all in all, having siblings didn’t really improve my life.

The number of children you have isn’t the key thing, it’s how you treat them.

Rusume Sun 29-Oct-23 13:08:53

I have a good friend who is an only. Not only that but both her parents were as well added to which she is divorced with no children of her own! So she truly has no-one. She is godmother to a few and goes to them every Christmas but I know she feels a bit like a spare part.

Overthemoon Sun 29-Oct-23 12:30:02

Really interesting to read all the different experiences, thank you! I wasn't spoiled as an only with material things thankfully. The only thing I would say is in my late childhood/ teenage years unknowingly my parents made me feel 'special' their attention was obviously always on me so life hit me hard when I realised I'm the same as everyone else. Everyone is special! That was a hard lesson to learn through those years. I was determined not to have just one if I could. I'm blessed to have two. They get on ok, but are very different. They will have each other later on.

Nannarose Sun 29-Oct-23 12:24:14

Germanshepherdsmum

It must be nice if you are able to have more than one child. I’m the third generation of my family who couldn’t.

Indeed, GSM. My cousin and her husband are both 'onlies' whose mums were unable to have any more children for medical reasons. Both are close to their cousins as substitute siblings.
We all have different families, mostly these days by choice, but still, fate may intervene to prevent us doing exactly what we would wish. I think the secret is always to be grateful with the hand you are dealt, and make the most of it. I certainly am.

In principle, I don't really think much about the money / inheritance issue. But I have 1 GC who is an only. A sad history on the 'other side' of the family means that she has a large amount of money in trust. My 2 other GCs will have nothing like that, but they do have a horde of loving relatives!

Juicylucy Sun 29-Oct-23 12:07:36

I’m an only child, I had a great childhood but now I’d love to have siblings to chat with or pop for a cuppa I’m 67.
My eldest dd only had one dd who is now 14 so will remain an only child I expect.

nanna8 Sun 29-Oct-23 12:01:14

I would have loved to have had a brother or sister, especially now I am older. One of my grandchildren is an ‘ only’ but she sees her cousins a fair bit and has a very social nature. When I was a child I had a difficult relationship with my mother and I was very shy as a result of being made to feel inadequate. Things improved when I left home and understood that she had a mental illness. If I had had a sibling I think life would have been easier (perhaps ) .

JdotJ Sun 29-Oct-23 11:54:00

I'm an only, as was my dad, although my mum was one of 5 so I do have 6 cousins. My DH mum was also an only. DH has one sister so my 2 children have only 2 cousins they never see as live far away.
I would have loved a sibling, or two !
I really envied classmates who were from big families. I still envy friends now who have siblings. Grass is always greener I suppose.
One thing that really used to annoy me was when 'anyone' would say "I bet you're spoilt"! - No, I wasn't. You cannot spoil one child unless you have two or more and one becomes a favourite.
I think being an only is why I loved school so much. It was my social life as well, I hated weekends as I was on my own, it has made me a voracious reader, for which I'm thankful but I'm sure nowadays I would be given the label of Autism were I of school age as I find mixing incredibly hard.
Being an only gives you no social skills but does make you very analytical and not one to suffer fools.

Bea65 Sun 29-Oct-23 11:45:32

Thank your blessings... i was only able to birth one child..

Boolya Sun 29-Oct-23 11:40:17

I am an only child and I would have given anything for siblings when my Dad died when I was 14 and my Mum when I was 16.
Luckily I now have a good friend whose Mum also died so we can compare notes, so to speak.

pen50 Sun 29-Oct-23 11:26:12

I have a sister. I have never hated anyone so intensely! Luckily, I grew out of that when I became a teenager and we're quite close now; she and her family will be at ours for Christmas Day.

PamelaJ1 Sun 29-Oct-23 06:18:57

Calendergirl
Same here, one in Aus, one down the road and they are very different, like chalk and cheese.
I consider myself lucky to have 3 sisters and we are a very happy family. Well most of the time! We live quite a way from each other but get together and are there for each other.
I have one GS and I do feel sorry for him although he seems fine with his situation. What concerns me is that he has never had to battle for what he wants and has not (IMO) had to learn to share. It’s a helpful lesson.
As Peppa pig would say ‘it is what it is’.

Mamasperspective Sun 29-Oct-23 04:35:49

I have a brother and, as much as I do have love for him, he has caused so much stress, caused so many issues and been such a burden over the years that I often find myself thinking that I wish I had been an 'only' and my life would have been so much more enjoyable. I am now very low contact with him which works much better.

Sparklefizz Fri 27-Oct-23 11:33:03

I'm an only child and longed for siblings when I was growing up. We had no money and my parents both worked very hard so I was left to my own devices most of the time, and was a "latchkey kid" from the age of 5. No one turned a hair in those days.

I had to learn how to entertain myself, and the benefit of that is that I learnt to read long before school, always had my nose in a book, or drawing and painting, or playing solitary games .... but I didn't like being lonely and alone.

I was determined if at all possible to have more than one child, and was lucky enough to have 2 (and 2 miscarriages). I love it that my son and daughter are close and will have each other when I pop my clogs.

Franbern Fri 27-Oct-23 10:31:36

My brother was twelve years older than me. By the time I was at school, he was no longer living in the family home, so I always felt like an ONLY, I loved this and fully appreciated the extras that this brought to me, including my own bedroom. I did have an imaginary younger sister, which my Mum coped with very well, but my Dad found difficult and could never ndeestand why I got so upset when he refused to kiss her goodnight, etc.

In adulthood I was an ONLY as my brother would disappear for years at the time, and was not around for either of our parents demise.

Always stated that I wantd four children, and actually ended up with six (four and five came as one package, and sixth started out as fostered - and stayed).

I love it that they all get on very well, Two of my g.children are only's. They do have their cousins, and are both very confident people.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 27-Oct-23 10:14:45

It must be nice if you are able to have more than one child. I’m the third generation of my family who couldn’t.

eazybee Fri 27-Oct-23 10:12:19

I was an only child, which I didn't mind, but I wanted and was fortunate to have two children,who had fun together as children, and saw how supportive they were/ are of each other, and how they share the burden of me!

Oldnproud Fri 27-Oct-23 10:08:56

Luckily, my own two children (sons) have quite a good relationship.

Oldnproud Fri 27-Oct-23 10:07:53

I'm in the 'might as well have been an only' group. In fact, 'would almost certainly have been happier as an only' might be more accurate, as my brother, three years older than me, only really had two attitudes towards me: ignoring me, or teasing me.

For most of our adult lives, there has been no contact between us at all. There has never been a single "how are you doing?" type phonecall / conversation between us ever - neither of us would know what to say to the other anyway after all this time!

Having a sibling certainly hasn't added anything positive to my life, and the hurt that it caused me as I was growing up has never gone away.

PaperMonster Fri 27-Oct-23 09:03:21

Whilst mine is an only child, I had hoped for another but decided against it due to my body not actually coping with pregnancy and not wishing to have to rely on others to look after my child whilst going through another pregnancy.

In conversation with my ex this week who is one of five, and who has ailing parents, all the practicalities seem to be falling to the only sister.

Nansnet Fri 27-Oct-23 08:15:56

I'm an only, and I've felt differently at different stages of my life.

When I was young, even though I had a very happy childhood, I would often beg my mum to have another baby because I was jealous of my friends who had siblings. Although, I do remember those friends at the time telling me how lucky I was not to have to share everything, including my mum & dad.

By the time I was a teenager, I'd changed my mind, and I was glad I was an only child. I had my lovely dad wrapped around my little finger, and I didn't want for anything. I'm sure it would've been very different with more children to take care of.

By the time I was a mature adult, I'd changed my mind yet again. My parents both became ill younger than I would have imagined, and I had no one to share the burden. The stress of taking care of them, first my mother, then my father, and the heartache of eventually losing them, without having a sibling to share all the ups and downs with, was extremely difficult. The sadness, loneliness and heartache that I felt almost broke me. I did have lots of support from my DH, and my own adult children, and other members of the family helped and supported as much as they could. However, I don't think that this was the same as having a close sibling to share these different life stages with. I basically had to put my life on hold for a very long time, and it's a lot for one person to cope with.
For this reason, if there's a choice in the matter, I wouldn't wish being an only child upon anyone.

Calendargirl Fri 27-Oct-23 07:27:23

I was one of two, and have two children myself.

I know after my DD was born, I was keen to have another child. I realise it doesn’t always work out like that, but being so happy with her made me want another, in fact I somehow felt I would have been more upset to only have one child than none, which must sound heartless to those who are desperate to have even one child, I don’t mean it to.

Just that two was great for us.

(Should add that now DD lives in Australia, she and her brother are not close, no fall out or anything, just both leading their own separate and distant lives. Wish they were closer, but just how it is.)