Gransnet forums

Health

Knee Arthroscopy Keyhole Surgery

(13 Posts)
Noplacelikehome Mon 18-Jan-16 14:24:38

I've got knee problems kneeling and pain at back (hamstring) Xray shows arthritis, but surgeon thinks torn cartilage. I'm scared of pain and apparently it'll hurt after the General Anaesthic. Is it worth going through, or should I just put up with the discomfort I have?

Charleygirl Mon 18-Jan-16 14:30:40

A knee arthroscopy is a breeze. I had very little pain after mine and my knee was no longer unstable because I had a meniscus removed at the same time as a washout. I personally think that it is well worth it.

tiggypiro Mon 18-Jan-16 19:23:25

I totally agree with you Charleygirl. As well as the arthroscopy, I had metalwork removed from the tibia and a ligament repaired. No more pain or instability and no problems/pain after the GA. Absolutely brilliant and no further problems in the 5 years since.

Jalima Mon 18-Jan-16 19:37:29

My DH is dithering Noplacelikehome
He has had the examinations, the diagnosis of 'floating meniscus' and could go for surgery but just keeps changing his mind.

Sadiesnan Mon 18-Jan-16 19:58:37

They give you excellent pain killers these days. I've had a number of surgeries lately and I can honestly say I didn't suffer. I had shoulder surgery, which was done by keyhole and afterwards I had no pain. If you're anxious talk to the doctors. The anaesthetist is the doctor who will sort out your pain relief.

Indinana Mon 18-Jan-16 22:12:52

I had a knee arthroscopy 8 years ago to remove torn shreds of cartilage. I opted to have the procedure under a spinal block rather than a GA, as the recovery is so much quicker and less risky. They asked me if I wanted to see what they were doing - yes! So they turned a monitor around to face me and I watched the whole thing. It was quite surreal but not in the least scary seeing the surgeon poking around inside my knee - couldn't feel a thing so it might just as well have been a TV programme I was watching smile. No pain afterwards, beyond a slight ache for a few days, really hardly anything. And that knee has lasted me another 8 years so far with no trouble. (It's my other knee that's playing up now sad)

Noplacelikehome Tue 19-Jan-16 12:51:10

Thanks for all the encouragement. Hope you get fixed up soon Indinana.

jamesannie Thu 31-Aug-17 07:59:04

Hi,Most of them is afraid of Arthroscopic knee replacement surgery. This surgery is a modern surgical procedure to relieve pain and disability.The patient has to understand the risks and the benefits of the knee replacement surgery.It is a surgical procedure to replace the weight-bearing surfaces of the knee joint to relieve pain and disability. It is performed through the implant of an orthopedic metal and plastic component shaped as a joint so that the knee can move properly.
Arthritis is the most common reason for the need of knee replacement surgery.For knee damage,knee replacement surgery is recommended. For more information refer
[url=http://astermedcity.com/blog/Readmore/what-to-expect-from-a-knee-replacement-treatment/3828]Arthroscopic Treatment in Asia[/url]
.This will be very helpful.

ninathenana Thu 31-Aug-17 08:40:12

I don't think it is very helpful actually jamesannie the OP is asking about arthroscopy not knee replacement.

H has had the proceedure and apart from a little soreness for a day or two he said it was fine and very benificial.

Jane10 Thu 31-Aug-17 08:45:33

I thought that the clinical evidence for arthroscopic was slight? Many places no longer offer it. Sounds like several of you benefited from it though.

Chewbacca Thu 31-Aug-17 08:54:23

I've had knee arthroscopy on both knees and the benefits for me have been huge. The first one was offered to me quite willingly but, as Jane10 says, medical opinion had changed by the time I needed it for the other knee and I had to really argue my case for that one. It's been 12 years since my first op and my knees are still going strong! My neighbour, on the other hand, had an arthroscopy earlier this year and it's not helped her at all.

TriciaF Thu 31-Aug-17 09:21:23

I've never heard of this - it might help husband if his knee gets worse.
Recently the GP drained off some fluid, and later gave him a cortisone injection, which has helped. But probably only temporary.

Chewbacca Thu 31-Aug-17 20:44:53

TriciaF, I tried the cortisone injections in my knee before having the arthroscopy but, to be honest, the benefits were minimal and didn't last more than a week or so and the injections weren't pleasant either. I've never needed another cortisone injections since having the arthroscopy.