Gransnet forums

Health

Cheese is the new poison

(121 Posts)
thatbags Sat 04-Feb-17 16:32:57

According to a leading American quack doctor cheese is addictive and it is what is making us fat, not sugar. His name's Neal Barnard and he has written a book called The Cheese Trap: How Breaking a Surprising Addiction Will Help You Lose Weight, Gain Energy, and Get Healthy.

One of the comments after the article I've just read does point out that he's American and that Americans don't understand cheese.

Jalima Sat 04-Feb-17 22:41:14

I've just remembered some lovely creamy tasty cheddar we have in the fridge which must be eaten soon
If I eat it now will I have cheese dreams?

The GP warned me off cheese - because of the salt content.
This must be the latest nanny pronouncement.

I just mentioned it to DH and we reminisced about his aunt who used to eat a chunk of cheese most days while she was cooking dinner.
She nearly reached her 100th birthday - if she hadn't eaten all that cheese perhaps she would have lived longer.

seacliff Sat 04-Feb-17 21:18:08

Well there was ecently a thread about what did Gransnet make you buy.

This thread caused me to have marmite and cheese on toast for tea - was delish.

Cherrytree59 Sat 04-Feb-17 21:16:30

I'm sure I read somewhere on Gransnet that it was a good idea to eat a cube of cheese after eating acidic food or drinks as it neutralises and protects the tooth enamel.

willsmadnan Sat 04-Feb-17 21:03:08

It's quite funny ( in retrospect ) but every time I went to my French GP all she went on about was cutting down on cheese, lardons, charcuterie ( basically processed meat such as salami, pate, Bayonne ham). All the stuff the French live on! Never asked about my wine consumption. Thrisher ... I think Death by Baked Camembert is infinitely preferable to Death by Cocolate Cake. grin

NfkDumpling Sat 04-Feb-17 20:56:33

DH came back from the deli today with some local smoked goats cheese we've not had before. It's wonderful and is really testing my No Snacking February.

Anniebach Sat 04-Feb-17 20:52:51

I was once told our passion for cheese is a craving for salt

trisher Sat 04-Feb-17 20:47:47

Death by camembert, gives life a whole new dimension.

morethan2 Sat 04-Feb-17 20:37:22

Well that's me done for. I'd never give up cheese. I'd sooner give up chocolate.
The quack doctor may be right because I'm probably addicted and I'm fat

Deedaa Sat 04-Feb-17 20:28:22

DD has been to the States quite a few times for pleasure and business and her constant complaint is the awful cheese. I gather from some of the American cookery shows that they have some good imported Italian cheeses, but the stuff they make themselves is awful.

TriciaF Sat 04-Feb-17 20:23:19

Maybe he's thinking of pizzas - they're very popular, and often have loads of greasy cheese dripping off them.

willsmadnan Sat 04-Feb-17 20:02:53

America knows FA about good cheese. They decided they would boycott Roquefort because France would not support the Iraq invasion.... and we all know how that panned out. Well, a clear case of cutting off one's nose to spite one's face. Having lived in France for nigh on 20 years I'm going to put my head on the block and say France and the UK produce the finest cheeses in the world .... Italy comes close, but they perhaps don't have the wide range ... but I stand corrected on that. As for the US? A non-starter. IMO, of course.

Welshwife Sat 04-Feb-17 19:45:29

We love cheese but find we go in phases with it - gave done the Brie one for a while and at the moment we are on Comté 12-16 months old! I quite often have a slice for breakfast with an apple.

I had to go and see a cardiologist and he kept saying - stop eating cheese, cheese is too salty, women love cheese and it makes them fat! I had to keep calm as he was doing an echgramme! But I did still eat it.

Roll on a few months and I was talking to my GP about foods which give me reflux and he asked if I could eat cheese - I told him I could and he said that was fine then as you need it to get enough calcium. But he does say you are better to eat it at lunchtime rather than the evening.

bikergran Sat 04-Feb-17 19:41:23

yesterday my dd turned up with a little bag (thought it was a bag of crisp) on opening it it was a little packet, complete with 2 crackers/3 pickled onions/a triangular portion of spread cheese and a little plastic spreader (used to be little wooden ones when I used to buy them in the pubs or off licenses) anyone one else remember them smile

tidyskatemum Sat 04-Feb-17 19:11:56

I'm sure there are delis that sell good cheese in the US, ffinnochio, but your average American thinks cheese either comes out of a tube or as a flabby proceed square on top of a burger. I'm gobsmacked that The Times is giving space to this "leading doctor", whose background is apparently in psychiatry and neurology, to flog his latest book with no empirical evidence to support it. Keep on munching the good stuff, folks.

thatbags Sat 04-Feb-17 19:08:09

We've had whole threads on GN on what people call rolls, barm cakes, baps smile

thatbags Sat 04-Feb-17 19:06:38

When I first lived in Scotland I knew what a roll was but if I ever asked for a barm cake people looked at me as if I was barmy.

thatbags Sat 04-Feb-17 19:05:30

<whispers in a Lancashire friendly way> it's barm. Old English/Danish for yeast

thatbags Sat 04-Feb-17 19:02:37

When I told MrB that someone thinks cheese is addictive, he said: "Course it is! I've been addicted to it all my life". Nuff said.

ffinnochio Sat 04-Feb-17 18:44:03

Americans sell fabulous cheeses. You've just got to know where to buy it. Try a good Italian deli in NY and your cup will runners over.
Bought Delice de Bougogne today. Full fat and fabulous. smile

annodomini Sat 04-Feb-17 18:25:02

Now the Stilton in my fridge is calling out to me! I think there's a soupcon of brie in there as well. hmm

Agus Sat 04-Feb-17 18:18:34

I put this in DH's study!

He is quite happy believing this is true but I could possibly be 'labelled' a cheese addict

pensionpat Sat 04-Feb-17 18:05:52

I was referring to the lovely ploughman ?

wot Sat 04-Feb-17 18:05:29

?

pensionpat Sat 04-Feb-17 18:04:31

More innuendo!

wot Sat 04-Feb-17 18:04:07

Are they like soft rolls? Baps, barn cakes, balm cakes.........all delicious with cheese!