Gransnet forums

Health

Magnet therapy bracelets

(19 Posts)
lilypollen Mon 24-Apr-17 17:41:20

A friend has recommended these to me as he has had much improvement in a painful knee joint. I'd like more than one opinion so wonder if anyone has used them. Positive and negative comments welcome.

Rigby46 Mon 24-Apr-17 18:28:18

It's not opinions you want, it's evidence. You'll be lucky - IMO ( not evidence) it's either the placebo effect or the knee might have got better anyway. But they do no harm, so give it a try

Izabella Mon 24-Apr-17 18:30:59

I agree. There are plenty of opinions but no hard evidence. Suck it and see as they say.

BlueBelle Mon 24-Apr-17 18:50:18

I agree I think it's a placebo effect too but hey ho fairies might fly for all I know

Iam64 Mon 24-Apr-17 18:57:06

Fairies may well fly BlueBelle, what do we know. I bought a magnet bangle and my aches do seem to have improved but like others, I suspect they were due to give me a break anyway.
The only caveat I'd add is that friends who use magnet collars for their elderly dogs all report improvements in mobility and dogs seeming to "feel" better. Same with horses, though I can't recollect how they fit the magnets on to the horse.

BlueBelle Mon 24-Apr-17 19:04:32

Did the horse really say that ? sorry Iam64 but I do think people can see what they want to see I had a friend who swore she could heal animals and know exactly what they 'were saying to her' but honest they could have been 'saying anything' it was all in her head and imagination IMO I didn't want to tell her they don't really talk bless her

Iam64 Mon 24-Apr-17 22:01:29

Whadya mean they don't talk? I have two talking dogs and our previous dog wrote to the children when they were at university. We have proof as they kept all his letters grin

BlueBelle Mon 24-Apr-17 22:38:28

???

cornergran Mon 24-Apr-17 23:11:57

Didn't work for me sad.

lilypollen Mon 24-Apr-17 23:34:27

Thanks for the observations. I was also thinking of a collar for our dog who has weakness in hind leg (yes Iam64, he talks)shock I am open to alternative therapies and in the past have had success with Tissue salts. Will report back if/when I get a bracelet.

paddyann Tue 25-Apr-17 00:22:58

my late father in law used magnet treatments for his knee problems and found they really helped ,he also had a mattress topper with magnets in it ,he used them before and after his knee joint replacement op along with Arnica Gel from a company called SBC ,My mother in law uses a magnet wrap for her spondylitis in between her acupuncture treatments and shes remarkably fit foor mid eighties lilypollen you could try Actipatch on your dog ,although its made for humman use it gets fab reviews for pet use too,its electro mmagnetic and available at most chemists

nadene1234 Thu 25-May-17 13:28:18

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

nadene1234 Thu 25-May-17 13:31:37

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NfkDumpling Thu 25-May-17 14:01:07

We got talked into a Magnetix bracelet. DH wore it for six months and it had no effect whatsoever. I tried it so as not to waste it. Ditto.

However, I did used to wear a strap around my knee which had a magnet in it and that did help. But it may have been the strap rather than the magnet, I don't know.

Lazigirl Thu 25-May-17 14:12:10

Check the results of randomised controlled trials and save your money.

Nelliemoser Fri 26-May-17 06:57:55

It is a placebo nothing more. But if it works for you fair do's. Can anyone provide a scientific possibility for this improvement?
Placebos are known to be effective I am begining to believe that with some pain the mind can help overcome it. "Positive thinking, distraction maybe, but don't waste lots of money.

Sparklefizz Fri 26-May-17 08:41:49

I have got Fibromyalgia and find that magnetic plasters (plasters with a small magnet) stuck on the point of pain do work .... but then I bought a magnetic bracelet which did nothing. I think if the magnet is applied directly to the painful part, as in a knee wrap or wrist wrap, it will work, but just generally wearing a bracelet is not specific enough.

rosesarered Fri 26-May-17 12:34:46

The NHS do magnet therapy, I had it done (too soon) after a broken bone and muscle damage and had to ask them to stop, it was painful to nerve endings, so yes, it does do something.
I have a magnetic necklace which I wear if neck and shoulder muscles ache, and it does help.You need to buy from a reputable source though.

rosesarered Fri 26-May-17 12:35:53

Yes Sparkle I think it needs to be on or near the affected part of the body.